5.00 Tropico: Mucho Macho Edition (2002)
4.16 Railroad Tycoon II (Platinum) (2001)
4.15 Hidden & Dangerous 2 (2003)
4.14 Planescape: Torment (1999)
4.12 Fallout 2 (1998)
4.04 Mafia (2002)
4.00 Baldur's Gate (1998)
3.98 The Ultimate RPG Archives (1998)
3.98 Age of Wonders II: The Wizard's Throne (2002)
3.96 Baldur's Gate: Tales of the Sword Coast (1999)
3.94 MDK (1997)
3.93 Railroad Tycoon 3 (2003)
3.93 Tropico: Paradise Island (2002)
3.93 SpellForce: The Order of Dawn (2003)
3.91 S2: Silent Storm (2003)
3.87 Lemmings Revolution (2000)
3.87 Metal Fatigue (2000)
3.86 Age of Wonders: Shadow Magic (2003)
3.79 Interplay 15th Anniversary (1999)
3.78 FireFly Studios' Stronghold (2001)
3.77 Enemy Engaged: RAH-66 Comanche versus Ka-52 Hokum (2000)
3.76 Rowan's Battle of Britain (2001)
3.75 FireFly Studios' Stronghold Crusader (2002)
3.73 The Devil Inside (2000)
3.73 The Italian Job (2002)
3.71 The Suffering (2004)
3.70 Tropico 2: Pirate Cove (2003)
3.69 Tzar: The Burden of the Crown (2000)
3.69 Desert Rats vs. Afrika Korps (2004)
3.68 Mall Tycoon (2002)
3.62 Death Track Racing (2000)
3.60 Space Colony (2003)
3.58 Carmageddon II: Carpocalypse Now (1998)
3.58 Sheep (2000)
3.55 Sacred (2004)
3.53 Midway Arcade Treasures (2004)
3.49 Vietcong (2003)
3.32 Star Trek: Starfleet Academy (1997)
3.24 Flying Heroes (2000)
3.12 The Ultimate Wizardry Archives (1998)
2.97 Jetfighter IV: Fortress America (2000)
2.92 Martian Gothic: Unification (2000)
2.76 Hidden & Dangerous (1999)
2.65 Airport Tycoon (2000)
2.54 Dogs of War (2000)
2.50 MTV Celebrity Deathmatch (2003)
2.42 Codename: Eagle (1999)
1.92 Outlive (2001)
1.83 Söldner: Secret Wars (2004)

^*Games must have at least 5 votes to be included.