3.94 Quake (1996)
3.93 Max Payne (2001)
3.91 Wolfenstein 3D (2002)
3.91 DOOM II: Hell on Earth (2002)
3.91 Wolfenstein (2009)
3.91 Enemy Territory: Quake Wars (2007)
3.84 Vampire: The Masquerade - Redemption (2000)
3.82 DOOM³ (2004)
3.78 Quake III: Arena (1999)
3.72 Quake III: Team Arena (2000)
3.71 Quake Mission Pack No 1: Scourge of Armagon (1997)
3.69 DOOM³: Resurrection of Evil (2005)
3.64 DOOM³ (Limited Collector's Edition) (2005)
3.55 Quake II Mission Pack: The Reckoning (1998)
3.49 Quake II (1997)
3.49 Quake Mission Pack No 2: Dissolution of Eternity (1997)
3.44 Quake III: Revolution (2001)
3.31 Kingpin: Life of Crime (1999)
2.34 Commander Keen (2001)

^*Games must have at least 5 votes to be included.