4.31 Nancy Drew: The Haunted Carousel (2003)
4.16 Nancy Drew: The Secret of the Scarlet Hand (2002)
4.07 Nancy Drew: Ghost Dogs of Moon Lake (2002)
4.04 Wizardry 8 (2001)
4.03 Nancy Drew: Secret of the Old Clock (2005)
4.00 Shrek 2 (2004)
3.97 Nancy Drew: The Secret of Shadow Ranch (2004)
3.92 Jagged Alliance 2 (1999)
3.91 Nancy Drew: The Final Scene (2001)
3.88 Sacrifice (2000)
3.84 Vampire: The Masquerade - Redemption (2000)
3.82 Civilization II (Multiplayer Gold Edition) (1999)
3.81 Nancy Drew: Last Train to Blue Moon Canyon (2005)
3.80 Majesty: The Fantasy Kingdom Sim (2000)
3.79 Battle Realms (2001)
3.78 Nancy Drew: Danger by Design (2006)
3.76 Nancy Drew: Stay Tuned for Danger (1999)
3.75 People's General (1998)
3.74 Civilization II: Fantastic Worlds (1997)
3.74 Nancy Drew: Danger on Deception Island (2003)
3.73 Panzer General II (1997)
3.71 Pitfall: The Lost Expedition (2004)
3.70 Nancy Drew: Curse of Blackmoor Manor (2004)
3.62 Jagged Alliance 2: Unfinished Business (2000)
3.58 Silent Hunter II (2001)
3.57 City of Villains (2005)
3.40 Panzer General 3D Assault (1999)
3.39 Nancy Drew: Secrets Can Kill (1998)
3.26 Dead to Rights (2002)
3.26 kill.switch (2003)
3.25 Ultimate Spider-Man (2005)
3.17 The Next Tetris (1999)
3.03 Panzer General III: Scorched Earth (2000)
2.99 Shrek SuperSlam (2005)
2.96 Army Men: Sarge's Heroes (1999)
2.68 King's Quest: Mask of Eternity (1998)

^*Games must have at least 5 votes to be included.