4.03 StarCraft (1998)
4.00 Star Trek: The Next Generation - Echoes from the Past (1994)
3.97 Star Trek: Armada II (2001)
3.89 Star Trek: Judgment Rites (1993)
3.84 Star Trek: Voyager - Elite Force (2000)
3.81 Star Trek: Bridge Commander (2002)
3.80 Star Trek: Armada (2000)
3.79 Star Trek: Invasion (2000)
3.59 Star Trek: 25th Anniversary (1994)
3.55 Star Trek: Elite Force II (2003)
3.40 Star Trek: Deep Space Nine - Harbinger (1995)
3.37 Star Trek: Judgment Rites (Limited CD-ROM Collector's Edition) (1995)
3.18 Strange Adventures in Infinite Space (2002)
3.02 Star Trek: Hidden Evil (1999)
2.87 Star Trek: Away Team (2001)

^*Games must have at least 5 votes to be included.