I have part of the UK version of this compilation and would appreciate advice on how to document it.
The EA games documented in the existing summary are
I have seen this compilation on sale on e-bay a few times usually from Germany, there's one on offer now for example : http://cgi.ebay.co.uk/Play-Games-Volume-3-PC-/290558280543?pt=de_entertainment_games&hash=item43a69f835f
The UK version contains only 12 games as is shown by this link to amazon.co.uk : http://www.amazon.co.uk/Bundle-Raider-Theme-World-Driver/dp/B000056H5C/ref=sr_1_3?s=videogames&ie=UTF8&qid=1304876835&sr=1-3
I have part of the UK version of this compilation. The EA games in my version are
Probably best to create a new entry. Just give it the same name, but state clearly in the description that it's from a different region.
Edit: It can sort of be compared with all the different Singstar games we have on file for different regions: Singstar games
Well, personally I don't really know why we have those different SingStar Rocks! entries (even if I contributed one). The game itself is still the same; the only difference is a changed song list. Which, based on previous guidelines and decisions, would fall under the "minor difference" rules.
I am willing to accept the reasoning that it screws up the "Sound" user rating if you have all versions in the same entry. Which is kinda important for a music game.
Well, in this case I totally agree with what vedder said. I think that the most important part of a compilation are the included games and every game difference warrants a new entry. And when the genres and companies are different I see no leeway.
(Edited by Indra is awakening... (16449), May 08, 2011)Re: Differing versions
Indra is awakening... (16449), May 08, 2011
Patrick Bregger Wrote:
Slightly annoyed that sound and music are under the same rating category, not separated.