Developed by
Released

Platform
...
MobyRank
100 point score based on reviews from various critics.
3.4
MobyScore
5 point score based on user ratings.
DND » Capitalization
Forum Search:  

View Mode: threaded | watch thread

Capitalization
SharkD (313), Oct 30, 2007
dnd is spelled with lowercase letters. Can't find where to fix it.
Re: Capitalization
Pseudo_Intellectual (34315), Oct 30, 2007
User Avatarhere's a screenshot that says that the current spelling is at least acceptable.
Re: Capitalization
Pseudo_Intellectual (34315), Oct 30, 2007
User AvatarAnd these guys seem to have a bit more cred in the field than you, pretty consistently using a capitalised spelling.
(Edited by SharkD (313), Oct 30, 2007)
Re: Capitalization
SharkD (313), Oct 30, 2007
http://www.gamasutra.com/features/20070223a/barton_02.shtml

http://www.geocities.com/jim_bowery/empire2.html - quotes a developer for the PLATO system

http://www.armchairarcade.com/neo/node/1396 - quotes a developer for the PLATO system

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dnd_(computer_game) - only one source cited, which I have no access to
Re: Capitalization
General Error (3823), Oct 30, 2007
User AvatarWeeell... I guess this game probably has no "official true and approved title"; both "DND" and "dnd" are appropriate IMHO.

This game started out as a mainframe game. In the beginning of computing, all you had was uppercase letters. So, the programmers just typed the lower-case letters (which, still today, have uppercase letters on them), and on the screen they saw the uppercase letters. So the game was typed "dnd", but read "DND".

How you call it is just a matter of taste -- at least, both versions are spoken the same.

I agree that on commercial games, the title is consciously chosen, including the letter's capitalization ("hey, our title is boring, but we could just change that e to an E and then it looks, erm, cool!!"), so the title's capitalization is important. But here, it just doesn't matter.
(Edited by DJP Mom (10808), Oct 30, 2007)
Re: Capitalization
DJP Mom (10808), Oct 30, 2007
User Avatar
SharkD Wrote:
http://www.armchairarcade.com/neo/node/1396 - quotes a developer for the PLATO system

And here's an interview at Armchair Arcade with the creator of DND, Daniel Lawrence - a snippet from it:

Q: (Interviewer Matt Barton) "There is also another program called dnd that was apparently written by Whisenhunt and Wood back in 1975 for PLATO. Is there a relationship between these games other than the names? I’m guessing that their “dnd” and your “DND” are two entirely different games. How does your game compare to theirs?"

A: (Daniel Lawrence) "Not to my knowledge at the time. I did not know/see the other game, but note I was in the same area of the country as they were. Some of my play testers may have well been giving me suggestions from their experiences elsewhere."

Edit - The game in the database is Daniel Lawrence's, it seems. I think he would be the final say on how his game is capitalized, don't you think?

Re: Capitalization
Pseudo_Intellectual (34315), Oct 30, 2007
User AvatarI think he would be the final say on how his game is capitalized, don't you think?

I think that its use in-game would determine that 8)
Re: Capitalization
DJP Mom (10808), Oct 30, 2007
User AvatarWell yes, I would say so too, but it looked like SharkD needed a little more convincing. In-game it is most definitely DND, plus the author distinguishes it from the previous "dnd"...I think we are agreeing :-)
Re: Capitalization
General Error (3823), Oct 31, 2007
User AvatarThanks for the information, I didn't know that "dnd" and "DND" were two games.
Re: Capitalization
SharkD (313), Nov 04, 2007
DJP Mom Wrote:
Well yes, I would say so too, but it looked like SharkD needed a little more convincing. In-game it is most definitely DND, plus the author distinguishes it from the previous "dnd"...I think we are agreeing :-)

I still think I'm right, because I think so and that's enough!
Re: Capitalization
Pseudo_Intellectual (34315), Nov 05, 2007
User Avataryou don't need to convince yourself; you need to convince /us/ 8)
 

Errors and omissions on this page may be reported to the MobyGames approvers.

MobyGames™ Copyright © 1999-2009, MobyGames.
All rights reserved. Do not duplicate or redistribute in any form.
moby sites | about us | advertise | disclaimer | privacy statement | become an approver | RSS