User review spotlight: Ultima IV: Quest of the Avatar (DOS)

Renegade: Battle for Jacob's Star (DOS)

72
MobyRank
100 point score based on reviews from various critics.
3.3
MobyScore
5 point score based on user ratings.
Written by  :  Ray Soderlund (3500)
Written on  :  Apr 10, 2000
Rating  :  2.17 Stars2.17 Stars2.17 Stars2.17 Stars2.17 Stars

1 out of 1 people found this review helpful

write a review of this game
read more reviews by Ray Soderlund
read more reviews for this game

Summary

Sometimes its best to stay with an original concept.

The Good

The Renegade Legion universe gets a second spin in this sequel to the original Renegade Legion: Interceptor and this time has a little more depth because you run through a story as opposed to the random mission generator of the original. This universe has a lot of potential going for it and it's good to see another attempt at it.

For a fan of the board game/original game, it was almost as much an enjoyable experience to fly the various Commonwealth fighters as it was to fly an X-Wing.

The graphic style, which is has a serious-cartoon appearance, is fitting enough for the universe and defines the various characters adequately.

The Bad

Unfortunately, this game came out on the heels of Wing Commander 3 and TIE Fighter, two exceptional entries in the space dogfighting genre. Without anything to compare it to, Jacob's Star might have been a decent to good game in many people's minds, but TIE Fighter was flawless in its sleek gameplay and nothing looked as good the very story-driven Wing Commander 3.

This game feels more of a hybrid of X-Wing and Wing Commander 2. The in-flight graphics are incredibly simple and, while they serve their purpose, don't stir any excitement. The controls are sloppy and far from the fluid feel of the more professionally done games. The AI is also fairly weak.

Finally, the storyline is hardly the best written, and the voice-overs do not lend anymore credibility to it.

The Bottom Line

A mediocre action 'flight' sim based in the Renegade Legion universe. While the universe is splendid, the flaws and inferiority of the game compared to the games of the same period make one wish SSI had just done a true, turn based strategy sequel to Renegade Legion: Interceptor, rather than turning it into a flight-sim game.