The Press Says

MobyRanks are listed below. You can read here for more information about MobyRank.
100
DOSHigh Score
Det enda som stör mig lite är att många av objekten i spelet är "osynliga", och ligger gömda i lådor, under sängar eller i högar med bråte. Det vill till ett vilt pixelklickande för att hitta dem, något som kan kännas lite frustrerande ibland. Annars är Malcolm min absoluta favorit-bad guy. Det var verkligen ett snilledrag att göra honom till stjärna. Missa honom inte.
90
DOSPC Games (Germany)
Alle Jahre wieder beschehrt uns die vorweihnachtliche Spiele-Flut eine Fortsetzung der Kyrandia-Saga. Auch heuer ist auf die Westwood Studios Verlaß: Nach dem edelmütigen Brandon und der selbstbewußten Adventure-Emanze Zanthia bekommt endlich der heimtückische Hofnarr Malcolm seinen großen Auftritt.
88
DOSPC Gamer
Great characterizations; simple interface. So-so graphics except in the Windows Mode; interface can get in your way. Tricky puzzles; hilarious dialog; no single right way to win; provides a challenging and entertaining adventure.
85
DOSMikroBitti
Kyrandia-ykkönen oli ihastuttava, joskin helppo ja kakkososa oli vaikeampi ehkä liiankin amerikkalaisella huumorilla varustettuna. Kolmosen huumori on hilpeää ja vain välillä omituista. Pelimaailma on entistä laajempi eikä tarina ole lineaarinen ja tämä tuo uutta intoa pelaamiseen. Tehtävät ovat parhaimmillaan takkuisia, vaikka kynnys pelaamiseen ei nousekaan liian korkealle.
82
DOSPC Format (UK)
It still doesn't quite have the intangible magic of (aargh) Monkey Island, but Malcolm's Revenge is a great game. People who enjoyed the first two instalments will be especially pleased with it.
80
DOSAbandonia
What I love about the game mechanics is that you just click on whatever or whomever you want to interact with. There's no cumbersome interface to navigate every time you want the character to interact. The puzzles, while being ingenius and hilarious, are incredibly difficult, and if you can work your way through without reaching for a walkthrough, you should apply to become a Kyrandian Royal Mystic. I hear there's a vacancy.
80
DOSPC Player (Germany)
Das Westwood-Adventure präsentiert sich noch edler und geschliffener, was Präsentation und Bedienung angeht. CD-ROM sei Dank sorgen Sprache, größere Spielfiguren und herzhafte Musik für eine vielversprechende Atmosphäre. Ex-Bösewicht Malcolm als Held ist eine Idealbesetzung; für alte Kyrandia-Kenner ist die Story besonders reizvoll. Die Puzzles begewen sich auf einem vernünftigen Grad zwischen Anspruch und Lösbarkeit - zumindest meistens.
70
DOSQuandary
The creative team at Westwood have succeeded in producing a thoroughly entertaining game, easily the best of the trilogy so far, with a good balance of typical adventuring fare and elements thrown in for pure fun. This is one game where it really does pay to try everything, everywhere, on everyone, not because of the frustration of not knowing what else to do but just to see what reaction you get.
70
Windows 3.xQuandary
The creative team at Westwood have succeeded in producing a thoroughly entertaining game, easily the best of the trilogy so far, with a good balance of typical adventuring fare and elements thrown in for pure fun. This is one game where it really does pay to try everything, everywhere, on everyone, not because of the frustration of not knowing what else to do but just to see what reaction you get. It's also the only way to score points - meanness points, bitter points, baby sitter points, etc. Though this won't help you to keep track of your progress through the game in the usual sense, it does encourage you to try quirky actions.
67
DOSJust Adventure
At a time when most of the industry seems to have "gone Hollywood", with everyone scrambling to get "big names" for digitized animations and voice-overs, and pushing the edge for whiz-bang graphics and sound effects, it is nice to see at least one company is concerned about content over gloss. Westwood may have gone a little too much on the obscure side, but at least they were listening to the game players, and went for "toughing up" instead of "dumbing down".
60
DOSWorld Village (Gamer's Zone)
If I were not reviewing this game I would have never bothered to complete it. I am a great fan of Westwood Studios work and look forward to their future projects, but in my opinion save your money for another game. If your looking for a good Kyrandia game then buy Kyrandia 2, in my opinion it is just a much better game, and far more enjoyable.
60
MacintoshHigh Score
Gillar man att lösa humoristiska och dråpligt roliga problem, spelet har t.o.m en inbyggd studiopublik som skrattar åt dina dumheter, kan det vara värt att köpa.
40
Windows 3.xAdventure Classic Gaming
This third book in The Legend of Kyrandia series seems to have been a rushed production. The dialogue is much worse than in the previous titles, and the poor acting compounds on this letdown. While there is an ambitious structure to the puzzles, the frequently arbitrary actions and the several long tedious solutions make The Legend of Kyrandia, Book 3: Malcolm’s Revenge more of an ordeal than an adventure.
33
Windows 3.xThe Good Old Days
It's a pity that the game design is so shoddy. Playing the bad guy is a refreshing change, and it's good to see the game making fun of its own clichéd plot. I really want to like the game, but due to the nature of its gameplay (for the third time, but it can't be said often enough: tedious), it's close to impossible. Pity.
33
DOSThe Good Old Days
It's a pity that the game design is so shoddy. Playing the bad guy is a refreshing change, and it's good to see the game making fun of its own clichéd plot. I really want to like the game, but due to the nature of its gameplay (for the third time, but it can't be said often enough: tedious), it's close to impossible. Pity.


Our Users Say

Platform Votes Score
DOS 31 3.9
Macintosh 1 3.7
Windows 3.x 7 3.5
Combined MobyScore 39 3.8


User Reviews

Let me tell you my side of the story... DOS Unicorn B. Lynx Bronze Star Contributing Member (63297)
A worthy closing of the Kyrandia Saga! DOS Rantanplan (1753)

 

Errors and omissions on this page may be reported to the MobyGames approvers.

MobyGames™ Copyright © 1999-2009, MobyGames.
All rights reserved. Do not duplicate or redistribute in any form.
moby sites | about us | advertise | disclaimer | privacy statement | become an approver | RSS