Mafia II

The Good
The first Mafia will always remain one of my favorite games. It had unique quirky charm that made me ignore its flaws and enjoy it immensely, without trying to compare it to GTA games, which had been the obvious inspiration.

In terms of story and presentation, the sequel succeeds - at least partly - in capturing the spirit of the first game. The cinematic direction of the numerous cutscenes is very good. Character graphics and animation are beyond anything I've seen in a video game; even Mass Effect doesn't reach this level. The voice acting is uniformly solid and convincing. I couldn't shake that New York Italian accent from my speech after a session of this game. You can feel the vice, the coldness, the cruelty; but nothing is overdone, there are no cartoony exaggerations: everything is gritty, merciless, and realistic.

The story of Mafia II is not bad. I've read criticisms, heard people saying that Vito and Joe are shallow and unpleasant, and the story is just about betraying and killing everyone. Well, that's true. But it's a story about mafia, no? Organized crime. Gangsters. So yes, Vito and Joe do very bad things, and so do everyone else you encounter in the game. But that was just the point: to show how false ambitions, perverted sense of respect and extreme cynicism turn an ordinary guy into a merciless killing machine. Yes, Vito's soul becomes hollow, but it can never become completely so. This fact is not taken lightly in the game. And in the end, it becomes clear that Vito's spirit and his vices can never be reconciled.

The atmosphere of the 1940-ies and 1950-ies is very well-realized - the clothes, the propaganda, the jazz music, the rampant racism and misogyny. Of course, it concentrates on the dark side of United States of those years. And it does it very well, in a somewhat brutal, but poignant fashion. Though the city's beauty is largely ephemeral, it does feel nice to drive through a cozy neighborhood on a sunny day or shoot assorted mafiosi in a stylish apartment decorated by retro posters.

The Bad
Mafia II is unsatisfying in all of its basic gameplay categories: as an open-world "sandbox" experience, as a shooter, and as a driving game.

As a free-roaming game, Mafia II lets you do just that: roam (and even that not quite freely). Otherwise, its city offers nothing interesting. There are no optional missions. No decisions to make during missions. No possibility to choose the order of the story missions. You can't go online or buy property or drive a taxi or have a girlfriend or anything that was so fun in Grand Theft Auto games. Everything else is a beautiful, yet superficial decoration. The ultra-linear structure of the missions and the hollow nature of the city make the experience pale in comparison to the GTA behemoths.

It was certainly "forgivable" eight years ago, when the first Mafia came out; but now, people expect more, and rightfully so. Mafia II is a typical modern game: classy presentation superimposed on simplified, reduced gameplay. It gives you the scenery but forgets to give you fulfilling activities to go with it.

The world is also full of artificial borders. In such type of games, a big part of the fun is to be able to drive anywhere. In Mafia II, you can drive pretty much only on the roads. Sure, you can wreak havoc in a park or something, but not much more. You can't access water at all. For some reasons mountain roads are adorned by annoying fences that you can't drive through. So instead of performing a spectacular car jump from a mountain top, you'll have to drive down the same road you used to go up. Same applies to on-foot navigation. Why can't my character jump? Why can't he swim? Why doesn't he fall of a cliff, why are there magical borders preventing him from doing that?

Mission design in Mafia II is exceedingly weak. There are no imaginative setpieces, no variety, and for the most part almost no challenge at all. The first part of the game is particularly bad: it is built like an inflated "tutorial" where you perform menial, tediously executed tasks to advance higher in the ranks of organized crime. It may be realistic, but it's boring both in concept and execution. I imagine it would have been possible to create a fun minigame based on passing around cigarette boxes, but the game doesn't even want to do that: you just have to press a button whenever you want to and voila - task accomplished.

It doesn't get much better than that. Many missions literally consist of calmly driving somewhere, sitting through a lengthy cutscene, and driving back. Even though you can drive cars, there are almost no missions at all focused on driving. In fact, it wouldn't be an exaggeration to say that driving in the game is mostly a cosmetic element. There are no tense chases, no exciting shoot-outs, no racing, no time limits, no fun action-loaded setpieces and next to no diversity in missions generally. The only type of mission that involves solid gameplay are the third-person shooter sequences, which are much less numerous than expected.

However, those shooter fragments absolutely cannot hold a candle to the first Mafia. That game had hardcore, challenging shooting gameplay in generously designed levels you could tackle in different ways. There was basic freedom of decision and pacing that is essential to 3D shooters. Not so in the sequel, where you are glued to predictable, formulaic episodes taking place in tiny, sterile locations. Cover-taking is so over-emphasized that you'll be shredded to pieces if you try fighting in the open, but will dispatch any foe with enough patience if you just play the sitting duck. The levels are thus severely limited by the abundance of artificially placed furniture and debris just screaming "take cover behind me!". You don't need to use your imagination - just do exactly what the game wants you to do and you'll be fine.

The Bottom Line
Mafia II nicely recreates the atmosphere of a historic setting, and its storytelling is acceptable. However, as a game, it is but a sad reflection of its predecessor's glory, failing both in its treatment of open-world gameplay and as a regular action title.

The Good
Well I wasn't expecting this to be the killer game the first one was. But even though this sequel was maybe disappointing, it was over my expectations, which by now you should know were very low.

Well the game delivers when it comes to the storyline. The characters are voiced superbly and very natural movie-like acting. As for the cut-scenes they're always entertaining to watch and never drags on. This is one feature that made the first so great. Vito is a level headed and likeable protagonist. Many other interesting characters to be found. This is the main reason to play this sequel.

Game play is pretty much like the original, take the Grand Theft Auto games and mix it with Max Payne and you've got mafia. Driving feels more realistic though just like the first game and you tend to drive safe here. Cars don't seem disposable as they were in GTA, you'll probably hang on to one car for a reasonable period. Cars are from the 40's and 50's, they all look delicious and can be modified (engine tuning and tire rims) at a body shop. Color, License plate can be changed to legalize your car. The Max Payne part is the gun fights. There is also reasonable good and easy controlling fist fighting. Thanks to the use of modern physic engines you get a good visual experience. Glass flying, shattering even walls chipping etc.

The theme is done right, you feel like you're in the 40's and 50's thanks to the art direction, city detail and licensing of music from that era. The details of the city are fantastic, another highlight. The game is divided into chapters, after a mission you can do whatever you want in the city and then go sleep on your bed to start the next day/chapter.

The Bad
Well you don't get to do a lot in this city other than the standard rob shops, buy items, piss off cops, shoot pedestrians, drive around or run over people. If you've been playing all the GTA games then like watching porn you'd be dead bored of this by now and want something more creative. But to be fair Mafia was never exactly a “Free Roaming” game, it just gives you an open world. Side missions would have been a good way to extend this games life. Instead they're relying on the modern trend of Downloadable Content (DLC) and Cliff hanger endings. The ending of this game is comparable to you about to get it on with your girlfriend in your room. As she's about to take her clothes off and you're harder than the nightmare mode in Doom, your family comes back from that weekend out of town. She picks up her top and you're screaming “NO, NO! Don't let the credits roll, that can't be it?!” Whatever happened to the good old days of having a full game shipped in the box?

Lot of wasted potential, like the stealth mission in the start introduces some promising features which hardly will get used latter game. Driving occupies 70% of this game, while shooting 20%. It's kind of like a less annoying Farcry 2, at least you don't have to deal with annoying re-spawning A.I. I love linear games but this game seriously needs a more non linear approach to some of it's missions. Sometimes the game tuns into Indigo Prophecy where you're simply pressing the use key to create a rather interactive cut scene. For example you have to pick up the correct color cigarette and toss it at your partner. While it does act like a break from all the shooting and driving, it's not even a mini-game, nor interesting and very slow. Therefore killing the already low replay value of this game. As for the A.I. it looks smart at first but then you realize it's just "take cover for a long time then shoot" or "I got a shotgun time to rush".

The Bottom Line
Mafia 2's flaws and average gameplay is easily overshadowed by its storyline and presentation. Thankfully the flawed gameplay never reaches unplayable territory. The replay value is quite bad unless you want to refresh yourself with the storyline. If you're not a fan of the series I would wait until the price drops for PC or just rent it if you're playing on console.

The Good

• Presentation values from graphics, art, voice work, story, music and sound are all beautiful and engaging
• The set-pieces are fun and engaging for a time
• Decent controls

The Bad

• Butchers almost all of the gameplay that made the original such a great game
• The amount of detail to the city is wasted
• Game is relatively short
• Nothing to do in free-roaming other than shoot people and instigate cops
• Enemy AI is just as bound, restricted and linear as the rest of the game

The Bottom Line
The debate of "Are games art?" is steadily growing higher and higher and to properly reflect my feelings on Mafia II, I must reflect my stance on this frothing debate. To me, "Video games" are not art; a video game is just a game, a set of rules are given and you must use them and try to beat other players be they real or computer. However games have spawned off something new and very different, which are definitely able to reach an artistic standpoint.

However their relations to video games still exist in the fact that you interact with them and play them. Great examples of this new evolution are Silent Hill 2 and Grand Theft Auto IV. Both "games" are not games in the traditional sense, and are truthfully more of an interactive experience; however they still have gameplay to tie them down and retain the aspect of "Interactivity," in Silent Hill 2 it was the immersion that made you feel as though you were being haunted, oppressed, and chased by your own nightmares taking real form and in Grand Theft Auto IV it was the way you interacted with the world and the fantastic characters, making you feel as though you have stepped into another persons shoes and reality in a genuine locale.

However they MUST keep this bridge between the artistic elements and the former aspects of being a "Video game," and this is where Mafia II fails. Mafia II, from the presentation standpoint, is a fantastic piece of art. The story and characters are brilliant, providing arguably one of the best Mafioso stories in years regardless of medium. The visuals are fantastic with extremely detailed and beautiful graphics and they capture the style of the two eras the game takes place in perfectly, combined with the great music both original and licensed Mafia II is a wonderful piece of art. But it fails to retain the interactivity required for this interactive medium.

The sad thing is this could have easily filled in that bridge. Anyone who played the original PC version of the original Mafia and not it's butchered PS2/XBOX port will know why. The driving mechanics were complex and while the controls took time to get accustomed to, it was a fantastic shooter with many nuances and while the city and free roaming were not the focus of the title, it had many hours, plenty of variety, and enough gameplay opportunities in its story to stay fresh throughout. I do not want to sound like a PC biased nerd but we can't ignore the fact that the PC is a more advanced system in delivering a more nuanced experience. Yet we live in a world where consoles are becoming more and more advanced and much more common and practical than the PC, and I have no qualm with this when it comes to the fact that there are thousands of fantastic console based titles; but some PC experiences need to remain on the PC intact. Almost nothing that made Mafia a nuanced title is here, and this is simply to allow the game to fit on the PS3 and Xbox 360 and not just the PC.

The result is a title that is a masterpiece and yet an utter disaster. Don't get me wrong, the set-pieces are memorable and tie in with the story perfectly; but there's no reason to replay them. This is something that shouldn't be an interactive experience, this is something we should see in theatres. It follows the perfect linearity of a film, but forces you to doddle about for lengthy, uninteresting periods between each "scene." There are 15 chapters in the game, and they each represent a "scene" that could've been made into a fantastic film. The only gameplay that connects them is get in your car, drive all the way to the other end of the town, get out, and start the film. Then you go through a set piece and control your character for that scene, then you drive back all the way to your house, "Sleep" and start the next scene then move on.

The city in the game is a waste of beautiful detail, while I wish it wasn't clearly an ape on New York which has becoming a far too common locale, the world looks as alive and complex as the Liberty City of GTA IV. It helps that the games period is represented perfectly. It actually takes place during two time periods, the first half is set in the 1940s during the height of World War II and later on the beginning of the 50s. Both periods are portrayed fantastically with cars, clothing, music and culture being mirrored perfectly. It's joyous at first to drive in a period piece car listening to Jazz and war propaganda and the like. However you will soon grow weary of drying because as mentioned earlier, the only point of driving is to connect the dots and get the scene moving.

To be fair this problem reared in the original game, but it was very clear that it isn't meant to be a free-roamer. This game wants desperately to be a free-roamer and tells the player to unleash themselves, but the ONLY thing to do in the city is occasionally cause havoc and car chases. There are no character interactions, mini-games, or expansive sights and events to mess around with. Even the first game at least had a Taxi driving thing to fill in the gap, but it also had more to it.

You can tell the developers tried to remember what made the original game great. As I said, the set-pieces are astounding on your first run but there is still limited interactivity and unless you want to get that achievement for picking up all the PlayBoy magazines hidden in each chapter (Sorry for being a smartarse, but Playboy didn't exist in the 40s. Or the 50s. Though I would be lying if it wasn't nice to see photos from when PlayBoy had far greater taste.) you will simply walk through each scene in the exact notes the developers want you to. There is no way to circumvent the absolutely linear path, even the decision of taking cover and shooting or being more gung-ho is decided as you will find that many segments are impossible unless you take cover in a specific spot or go full-auto in another. The driving mechanics also want to echo the original game, but are just as stripped and bare as the rest.

In the original game you had to obey traffic laws and the fact that you required to actually use gears, levers, etc. added to the first games immersion and it made the chases and driving more intense and interesting as well as more realistic than your standard GTA style chase. In Mafia II, they want you to obey traffic laws and you will often have to turn on a speed limiter but no gears or levers and even then, limiting your speed is more of a way of making sure you always have control over your car and don't go speeding too fast, lose control, and accidentally bump into something you didn't want to hit like in GTA IV. The police rarely care, but this becomes a problem because you will forget that traffic rules are still in the game. There might be a moment where you are zooming at 125 miles per hour and a cop will just pass by, but if you try it later the cops will start chasing you.

The overall problem is that the gameplay simply isn't complete. There are other mechanics, such as the bribing system and whatnot but they all feel out of place when you realize how linear the game truly is. Everything feels like a wasted opportunity to go to a greater title, this could've been a wonderful follow up to Mafia and could've even combined the strengths of the original Mafia and the variety and immersion of GTA IV but with a more realistic model. That was what the original game was like, it was very similar to GTA III in some ways and had a similar feel, but it was a more realistic and more dramatic alternative that delivered and improved on that games best moments. Why Mafia II couldn't have followed that model is beyond me, and it ultimately disappoints me.

This game is worth a rental to play through once, as the directing, acting, and story are poignant and wonderfully told and the set pieces are fun to control when you look past how limited said control is. But the sad fact is, it simply doesn't have the gameplay to truly match an interactive experience. The AI is just as bound and scripted and will always act the same way, with the exception of car cop chases. If it had been a film it could've been better, and all the missed opportunities combined with the fact that it cuts a superb predecessor down to a barely recognizable size makes Mafia II a shameful sequel.

The Good
As I mentioned in the title of this review, the presentation is nothing less than stunning; The city and the people that live in it give the impression that it's all real, the music on the radio fits the 40's and 50's very well and people who know a bit about history will notice the huge amount of details in this game. All i can say is: "wow".

The story is very interesting to follow and it's very well written. Unlike most storey-based games it didn't lose my interest and I never stopped playing the game because I was getting bored either.

Once you actually get to use your guns the cover-based shooting works, it is nothing original, but at least it works.

The Bad
The city may be huge, but there is barely anything to do in it and the things you can do fail to be worth your time. Even if you buy all the clothes in the games, fill your garage with beautiful cars and still have a few million dollars in your pocket the story may decide you lose it all.

The story also demands that some missions have no action at all. I lost count of how many missions had me drive people to a building just to watch a cutscene before driving them back to their home.

The story is well written, but it does become pretty obvious that all you are doing is trying to gather enough money to pay people back. The way Vito just keeps losing other people's money is a display of admirable stupidity.

The Bottom Line
The game has an amazing story, but it sacrifices way too much gameplay for it, but that aside this is a pretty cool game. A little love for the Godfather-style is a requirement. The presentation is beyond what we (used to) consider good and the game is very immersive. I do recommend renting this game for a week or two because replay value is nowhere to be found.