User review spotlight: Ultima IV: Quest of the Avatar (DOS)

Judge Dredd: Dredd vs Death (PlayStation 2)

missing cover art
61
MobyRank
100 point score based on reviews from various critics.
3.4
MobyScore
5 point score based on user ratings.

User Reviews

There are no reviews for the PlayStation 2 release of this game. You can use the links below to write your own review or read reviews for the other platforms of this game.


Our Users Say

Category Description MobyScore
AI How smart (or dumb) you perceive the game's artificial intelligence to be 3.0
Gameplay How well the game mechanics work (player controls, game action, interface, etc.) 3.4
Graphics The quality of the art, or the quality/speed of the drawing routines 3.4
Personal Slant How much you personally like the game, regardless of other attributes 3.6
Sound / Music The quality of the sound effects and/or music composition 3.2
Story / Presentation The main creative ideas in the game and how well they're executed 3.6
Overall MobyScore (5 votes) 3.4


The Press Says

MobyRanks are listed below. You can read here for more information about MobyRank.
75
4Players.de
Auch wenn der Humor und die Atmosphäre der Comic-Vorlage teils recht gut wiedergegeben werden, dürften Dredd-Fans aufgrund der schmucklosen Optik und des monotonen Gameplays doch etwas enttäuscht von der PS2-Versoftung sein. Zudem wirkt alles irgendwie unfertig oder zweitklassig. Weder Steuerung, KI noch Schwierigkeitsgrad scheinen richtig ausgereift und dann sorgen auch noch gelegentliche Bugs für unnötigen Frust. Wer dennoch Stehvermögen beweist und sich auch nicht an den linearen Missionen des recht kurz geratenen Story-Modus stört, bekommt aber trotzdem einen ordentlich spielbaren und vorbildlich eingedeutschten, wenn auch geschnittenen, Ego-Shooter serviert, der vor allem durch seine abwechslungsreichen Mehrspieler-Modi punktet. Doch auch Solisten werden mit Kampfeinsätzen gegen bis zu zwölf Bots, fordernden Sonderaufgaben und freispielbaren Extras eine ganze Weile bei Laune gehalten.
72
Gamesmania
Nach der PS2-Fassung war ich zunächst enttäuscht. Die Steuerung wollte mir nicht so recht gefallen, die Grafik sah unterdurchschnittlich aus und das Gameplay wirkte schlichtweg platt. Auf dem PC bekam der Titel eine zweite Chance und siehe da, ich fühlte mich schnell wie ein echter Judge. Hochauflösend wirkt die Grafik stilvoll, mit Maus und Tastatur ging die Steuerung gut von der Hand und im Team mit einem Freund machte die Verbrecherjagd gleich noch mal so viel Spaß. Rebellion hat sicherlich keinen Meilenstein geschaffen, wer aber auf düstere Science Fiction oder gar Judge Dredd steht, der findet mit Dredd vs. Death einen soliden Ego-Shooter sowie ein gelungenes Lizenz-Produkt.
70
PSW (Playstation World Magazine UK)
A lack of variety is really the biggest problem here. A few mini-games might have really helped, possibly involving the huge Lawmaster bike that Dredd rides in many of the cut-scenes. Despite these problems, this is easily the best rendition of the 2000AD universe outside of the comics, and the game retains much of the satirical humour. Just walking round reading the many billboards can be very entertaining, as they really capture the spirit of Dredd. The Dawn of the Dead-inspired shopping mall level also deserves a mention for both its combination of zombies and shotguns and the amusing tannoy messages that occasionally drown out the muzak. There are lots of references for aficionados to spot, and its nice to see Rebellion giving the fans what they want in the shape of Judge Death, rather than basing a whole game around a lesser character like Mean Machine.
64
Fragland.net
I was, how shall I put it, a little afraid that this “Dredd vs Death” would not stand up to my standard. “Medal of Honor: Frontline” is one of my all time favorites and I thought “Red Faction”, although different, was going to extend that pleasure. It did not glue me to the television for a very long time, however.
60
Jeuxvideo.com
Seuls les inconditionnels du comic book auront intérêt à se jeter sur cette adaptation PS2 qui se classe seulement parmi les FPS les plus moyens de la console. Il va de soi que vous pouvez diviser la note par deux s'il s'avère que la version packagée souffre des mêmes bugs que la version test qui nous été fournie par l'éditeur.
56
GameSpot
Released in Europe in 2003, the game hasn't gotten a whole lot better with age. It's a short, simplistic shooter that's not worth even its budget price.
50
IGN
A budget shooter for the indiscriminate casual gamer, Dredd vs. Death offers little to fans of the FPS genre, especially considering the quality of its competitors. For those starved action gamers in need of an immediately accessible fix, there is still some strange sense of joy to be found in pointlessly gunning down the minions of evil in colorful environments. Fans of the fiction will finally appreciate a style that keeps the faith, but will wonder how this game could have done its source material the same sort of disservice the decade old movie did.
40
G4 TV: X-Play
With the world the way it is now, the twisted satire of "Judge Dredd" could have been perfect. Imagine a mutated Donald Rumsfeld as a boss, or better, head of the Justice Department. Instead, we get a depressingly face-value take on a dystopian future that works neither as a game or a parody, except of itself. There's some humor in each arrest procedure, but it wears thin quickly. And with such poorly developed satire, do we really need to be playing out scenarios where the main character arrests a town square full of anti-fascist demonstrators? Shooting hookers may be OK, but that's just kind of sick. "Dredd Versus Death" is merely another unpleasant footnote to a long-misunderstood career.