PlayStation 2

Myst III: Exile

I think consoles are a bad choice for games like Myst and that’s too bad because while this game is good, hardcore console gamers probably won’t want to fit some time in for this puzzle adventure. Decent graphics and superb sound put you right in the middle of an engaging story (which stems all the way from the first Myst), but the horrendous and continuing loading issues will have you severely distracted. If you have $20 (yes, only 20--I imagine to compete with the PC sales) to spare and you love puzzles and you love loading times, then help yourself but don’t say I didn’t warn you.

You have to give Ubi Soft credit for releasing Myst III: Exile for the PS2. From a historical perspective, it gives today's gamers a look at what a top-shelf game looked like and played like just ten years ago. Once the novelty wears off and pointing and clicking starts to get old, though, there won't be too many PS2 owners that will be sticking with Exile with so many more exciting titles to choose from.

In the end, much of Myst III's appeal depends on how much you like puzzle solving, since that's the focus of and key to progression in the game. If the mere existence of a problem fires your determination to solve it, then the game can be highly entertaining. Because Myst III progresses at the pace at which you solve the puzzles, it lacks any sense of sustained drama or tension, let alone action. Some players will surely find it all rather dull or frustrating. Still, this relaxed pace can be refreshing. Ultimately, what's most impressive about Myst III: Exile is that it combines intellectual challenge with scene after scene of enchanting beauty.

Even though the game reminded me of playing PC games when I was younger, I cannot in good conscience recommend this game to anyone. This is not the type of game a console gamer will want to sit through and play to the end, the story might be compelling, but players will not want to actually find out what it is with the antiquated type of gameplay. It is sad to see that a game of this caliber has not made the jump into this generation of gameplay, because with a story as intriguing as this, in a full 3D game, the developers might have a sure fire hit on their hands!

I can't see myself recommending Myst III: Exile to anyone at any time. If you wanted to pick it up for Windows or Mac, chances are that you already have or will (especially now that it's dirt-cheap), and console adventure fans should find it almost worthless. Possible to own only by the remote chance that a cheapskate family member sees it in a bargain bin, it's in your best interest to steer clear of this one and wipe your memory of anything even remotely associated with it.