Wii

Uncharted Waters 2: New Horizons

Personally, I could go either way. But if you've played any RPGs in the past at all, you should be familiar with your own tastes in the genre -- do you prefer simple and straightforward fare like Paper Mario, which a linear story and not much micro-managing required? Or do you like the endless layers of statistics and secrets hidden within something like Ogre Battle? Uncharted Waters: New Horizons is certainly more suited to the latter group, so if you're not afraid of lots of numbers, characters, and a free-range open world without a lot of handholding, then dive on in and spend 800 Wii Points here. But if that all sounds like too much trouble for you to deal with, chart your course to a different destination.