Moby Poll: What kind of game collector are you?

Black Dahlia (Windows)

70
MobyRank
100 point score based on reviews from various critics.
3.9
MobyScore
5 point score based on user ratings.

User Reviews

Challenging adventure and a treat for puzzle lovers. Jeanne (75612) 4 Stars4 Stars4 Stars4 Stars4 Stars
One of the last greats in the field, highly recommended to adventure fans/movie buffs Vance (98) unrated

Our Users Say

Category Description MobyScore
Acting The quality of the actors' performances in the game (including voice acting). 3.6
Gameplay How well the game mechanics work (player controls, game action, interface, etc.) 3.6
Graphics The quality of the art, or the quality/speed of the drawing routines 4.0
Personal Slant How much you personally like the game, regardless of other attributes 3.9
Sound / Music The quality of the sound effects and/or music composition 4.0
Story / Presentation The main creative ideas in the game and how well they're executed 4.0
Overall MobyScore (28 votes) 3.9


The Press Says

MobyRanks are listed below. You can read here for more information about MobyRank.
95
Mega Score
Alguns jogos usam o terror para vender, Este parece usá-lo para cativar um público adulto. Algo que parece conseguir quando mistura factos e ficcção num filme interactivo.
93
Adventurearchiv
Actually I'm not one of those, who squat hours at the computer and forget the entire environment, but with "Black Dahlia" it happened that I was bound to the computer in such a manner, realizing that it was already 2 o'clock in the night. For me the game is one of those for a long time again, that is very much appealing me concerning atmosphere, graphics and puzzles that I wished, I could play it again, without any foreknowledge.
91
Game Revolution
Black Dahlia is a great game that all adventure/mystery fans will not want to pass up. It has a very long and well developed story about some REAL events from the forties. The game is so well researched, it makes you feel a part of the time, from the clothing, to the style of speech. The graphic interface is excellent and the complex plot will draw you in. It is truly an involving murder mystery, with thought provoking and relevant puzzles. A must buy for all murder mystery/adventure fanatics.
90
Puntaeclicca.it
Una produzione molto impegnativa, tipica di quando i giochi d'avventura erano sulla cresta dell'onda. Uno dei giochi più significativi e complessi che un appassionato di questo genere non dovrebbe lasciarsi sfuggire. Per adulti ed esperti.
90
Quandary
It's a sad moment for me as I begin this review because, to be perfectly honest, I'd rather not be writing it just yet. Unfortunately, putting pen to paper (or fingers to keyboard) means that I've finished playing Black Dahlia, and it was so enjoyable I didn't want it to end.
83
Electric Games
Black Dahlia is a pretty good game overall. It's a very long game, one which gives you a lot of gameplay for your money. The plot is very linear, although that does keep the disk swapping to an absolute minimum. I experienced only one crash the entire time I was playing the game, and even that didn't cause any real problems. I'd have preferred to see the entire game rendered or even animated, instead of the full motion video sequences, but it does the job it was meant to do. Bottom Line: Fantastic rendered graphics, I've seen worse uses of FMV. Excellent sound, especially the music. Acting is a mixed bag, most of it quite average. Dennis Hopper and Teri Garr are far too underused. Game interface is slick, with only a couple of slight flaws. The story will keep you interested, and the game is very long. Puzzles are quite difficult on the whole, but entertaining.
80
Meristation
La dificultad de los puzzles es elevada. Esto lo considero bueno por preferencia personal y porque muchas aventuras gráficas, con el ánimo de abrirse a mayor número de usuarios, caen en una facilidad excesiva, con lo que algunos jugadores expertos se las ventilan en pocos días, habiendo realizado una inversión dudosamente rentable. La película no es una obra maestra, pero me resulta entretenida y ameniza bastante entre puzzle y puzzle. No es el típico caso en que las animaciones aburren y nos preguntamos cuando nos toca hacer algo.
80
Computer Games Magazine
With a host of interesting twists on historical events, and a few creative surprises of its own free will, it's difficult to not recommend Black Dahlia to any adventure gamer with a genuine appreciation for a well-crafted tale. Given the sinister ramifications of your failure in this game, it's welcome reassurance to know that the series of events in Black Dahlia, even if they are flavored by actual facts, are mere fiction. Or 'gulp' are they?
80
Adventure Classic Gaming
Black Dahlia begins its somber and mysterious tale in 1941. The United States is plagued by a serial killer in Cleveland known as the “Torso Killer” and the grisly murder of an aspiring but aggrieved young actress in Los Angeles named Elizabeth Short, who is dubbed “Black Dahlia” for her propensity to wear black. Meanwhile, the Nazi’s regime and their obsession with occult mysticism trouble the pre-war Europe and have made the country very apprehensive. These actual, real life events have now been woven together and fictionalized by Take 2 Interactive in a game called Black Dahlia (as known as Black Dahlia: An Occult Mystery). While the story, atmosphere, and graphics are all excellent, a number of laborious puzzles, bugs, and crashes in this game may leave you somewhat disheartened.
79
PC Zone
Like olives stuffed with anchovies, or sex utilising a variety of 'bells and whistles', interactive movies are an acquired taste, and by now you'll probably already have made your mind up whether to buy Black Dahlia or not. But if you're still undecided whether to leap head-first into that whole genre pool, you could do a lot worse than testing the water with this baby.
75
Entertainment Weekly
Where Black Dahlia falls short is in its dorky (albeit standard) interactive technology: You choose between two, maybe three actions from an awkwardly written predetermined list that has little bearing on the plot's essentially linear progression. At heart, Black Dahlia is an extremely long movie riddled with puzzle-solving intermissions — a nonintuitive experience, to be sure.
75
Just Adventure
Black Dahlia is not a flawless game. However, its excellent storyline, with superb reproduction of the 1940s atmosphere and beautiful, well-integrated graphics and video, coupled with minimal disk swapping, are highlights. Though I encountered technical problems during Black Dahlia, it is clear that most people have not. Illogical, tedious puzzles and potential technical difficulties are the only obvious pitfalls of the game.
71
PC Gameplay (Benelux)
Enkel liefhebbers van de oorlogsperiode zullen in totale extase zijn en "die-hard" puzzelaars zullen ook een stevige kluif hebben aan dit spel.
65
PC Action
Der Thriller mit der spannenden Horror-Story wurde von Take 2 als aufwendiger interaktiver Film inszeniert, in dem u. a. auch Dennis Hopper ein Gastspiel gibt. Anspruchsvolle, gut in den Plot eingearbeitete Puzzles fordern von Ihnen viel Geduld, gute Augen und eine gehörige Portion Kombinationsgabe. Technisch kann Black Dahlia – abgesehen von kleineren Bugs – weitgehend überzeugen.
64
GameStar (Germany)
Black Dahlia ist ein reines Spiel für Erwachsene, von der Unbekümmertheit eines Tex Murphy fehlt hier jede Spur: Die über acht CDs ausgebreitete Story nimmt sich ernst und spart nicht mit Brutalität und Schockeffekten. Sie ist überaus souverän, fast hollywood-like in Szene gesetzt, wozu auch die exzellenten Schauspieler (allen voran natürlich Dennis Hopper) beitragen. Lediglich den Hauptdarsteller hätten einige Schauspielstunden gut getan. Das Fehlen von echtem 3D ist zu verschmerzen, nicht aber die unglaublich umständliche Handhabung des Inventars.
60
Power Play
Es ist nicht einfach so, daß „Black Dahlia“ schlecht wäre, im Gegenteil hat es sogar etliche starke Momente — aber leider krankt es eben auch an zwei grundlegenden Gebrechen. Erstens ist es zu schwer, und zwar viel zu schwer. Schwer genug, um selbst Profis den Angstschweiß auf die Stirn zu treiben! Zweitens (selbst wenn einer fähig und willens wäre, sich durch die nicht immer fairen oder auch nur sinnvollen Betonrätsel zu beißen) braucht es eine viel zu lange Anlaufzeit, um auf Touren zu kommen. Stunde um Stunde versinkt es trotz aller Anspielungen auf gräßliche Mysterien im gähnenden Aktenstaub. Dieser Part würde vielleicht Wappenkundlern Spaß machen, aber solche Leute halten Computerspiele ohnehin für Teufelswerk, kommen also als Zielgruppe schwerlich in Frage. Die Misere endet erst mit der dritten CD und Dennis Hoppers Auftritt in der Rolle von Pearsons unglückseligem Vorgänger Pensky; eine Szene, die wirklich unter die Haut geht.
60
Computer Gaming World (CGW)
Overall, BLACK DAHLIA is yet another in a long line of games that leaves me with mixed feelings. The period flavor is good, the story is interesting, the research is well done. But many of the puzzles are tedious and frustrating; the main character doesn’t develop; and the finale is a disappointment, to say the least. This is a pity because with a bit more attention to the adventure side of the game, and with a less dismal conclusion, this could have been a superior product. As it is, anyone who plays BLACK DAHLIA should be prepared for an uneven ride.
60
PC Games (Germany)
Anscheinend gehört es in diesem Genre inzwischen zum guten Ton, alle Puzzles so umständlich und schwierig wie nur irgendwie möglich zu machen. Schade um die guten schauspielerischen Leistungen, die Akte X-würdige Story und die wirklich tolle Grafik. Ein klaviersaitendicker Geduldsfaden gehört nämlich dazu, um hier nicht sofort frustriert aufzugeben. Zu hoffen bleibt, daß die in Kürze erscheinende deutsche Version für hiesige Spieler etwas leichter verständlich sein wird...
59
GameSpot
Adventure gamers who don't mind puzzles that are rote and unrelated to the story will probably enjoy the bulk of Black Dahlia. The technology is nice, the story is interesting for a while, and the game is relatively long. But those longing for the days when puzzles were actually a part of the story will probably find Black Dahlia to be just another pretty romp through a bunch of unrelated locales.
58
Svenska PC Gamer
Spelet bara fortsätter och fortsätter. Och fortsätter. Det ligger på åtta - åtta! - CD-skivor. Det en aman kan göra är att svära åt det, skälla ut huvudrollsinnehavaren för att han aldrig säger det man vill han ska säga, och framförallt för att han aldrig säger "tack" eller "hej då" när han lämnar ett rum. Oartighet är det värsta som finns.
58
Just Adventure
Black Dahlia has all the potential to be a classic adventure game like Curse of Monkey Island, but a few flaws keep it from achieving such a goal. Take Two should have thought twice about some of their puzzles and made the game interesting and fun the whole way through. A large drop in the middle of the game is a serious dump on the entire experience. However, Black Dahlia is definitely worth a try for those ready for its challenging puzzles.
56
PC Player (Germany)
Die hier gebotenen Rätsel erfreuen allenfalls menschliche Dechiffriermaschinen, die in der Schule gut in Mathe waren. Man muß wirre Codes knacken, Einzelteile zusammensetzen, mühsam Wege erkunden, langen Dialogen lauschen und vor allem ein gutes Auge für abstrus versteckten Kleinkram haben. Für mich ist Black Dahlia deshalb ähnlich reizarm wie eine vertrocknete Primel; da spiele ich liebe zum dritten Mal Monkey Island durch.
50
Just Adventure
Overall, Black Dahlia is yet another in a long line of games that leaves me with mixed feelings. Period flavor is good; the story is interesting; the research well-done. But many puzzles are tedious if not frustrating, the main character declines instead of improves, and the finale is a disappointment, to say the least. Which is a pity, because with a bit more attention to the adventure side of the game, and a less dismal conclusion, this could have been a superior product. As it is, anyone who plays Black Dahlia should be prepared for an uneven ride.
50
Adventure Gamers
Set against the backdrop of the second world war, Black Dahlia is an ambitious game that takes its cue from such classic movies as The Maltese Falcon and Touch of Evil. Although the premise of this game is not new — think Raiders of the Lost Ark — the game uses largely historic facts to spin its web of intrigue, betrayal and horror. The game is named after Elizabeth Short, a young girl with dreams of stardom in Hollywood, who was found naked and severed in two in an abandoned lot in 1946. With ebony hair and known for wearing all black, Elizabeth was quickly coined the Black Dahlia by the press. Yet her story only makes up a small portion of the game.
28
PC Jeux
Dans le même esprit que Ripper, Black Dahlia ne convaincra pas le Sherlock Holmes en herbe.