User review spotlight: Ultima IV: Quest of the Avatar (DOS)

Black Mesa (Windows)

Black Mesa Windows Title screen and main menu

MISSING COVER

88
MobyRank
100 point score based on reviews from various critics.
3.7
MobyScore
5 point score based on user ratings.

User Reviews

Like revisiting an old friend. Paul Graves (26) 3.43 Stars3.43 Stars3.43 Stars3.43 Stars3.43 Stars

Our Users Say

Category Description MobyScore
Acting The quality of the actors' performances in the game (including voice acting). 3.5
AI How smart (or dumb) you perceive the game's artificial intelligence to be 3.4
Gameplay How well the game mechanics work (player controls, game action, interface, etc.) 3.7
Graphics The quality of the art, or the quality/speed of the drawing routines 4.2
Personal Slant How much you personally like the game, regardless of other attributes 3.8
Sound / Music The quality of the sound effects and/or music composition 3.5
Story / Presentation The main creative ideas in the game and how well they're executed 3.9
Overall MobyScore (12 votes) 3.7


The Press Says

MobyRanks are listed below. You can read here for more information about MobyRank.
100
Gamereactor (Norway)
Det er i det hele tatt veldig lite å utsette på Black Mesa. Utviklerne fikk mye gratis da de tok utgangspunkt i Half-Life, men samtidig er det snakk om en brukerskapt mod som ikke koster deg en krone. Det avsluttende Zen-kapitelet er ikke på plass enda, og jeg kom over en og annen bug underveis, men det spiller ingen rolle. Det gjør ikke de gammeldagse stigene og de småklønete hoppene heller. Dette er en forbedret utgave av et mesterverk, som alle bør få med seg. Absolutt alle.
100
Gamereactor (Sweden)
Som en hyllning till världens bästa spel och utvecklarna som realiserade Gordons mardrömslika måndag står sig Black Mesa likt ett vackert kärleksbrev proppat med lovord, beröm och smicker. Visst, det hängde sig två gånger under mina 16 timmar och jag hittade fyra stycken buggar. Men... Som remake är det den enskilt bästa nyversionen av ett gammalt spel som jag någonsin haft nöjet att testa.
94
OMGN: Online Multiplayer Games Network
As a whole, Black Mesa is an amazing achievement from a legion of dedicated and passionate developers and designers. Everything from the original is present, and with the addition of some modern tweaks, it looks and plays better than ever before. Part of this is due to the ingenious level and game design of the original, but much can be attributed to adding and subtracting just the right amount. Knowing what doesn’t work and what is great often is a slippery slope coming down to opinion and personal preferences. Despite some slightly questionable choices, Black Mesa is an amazing achievement. It’s a great way to experience a classic in a whole new light and a perfect entry point for those who never played the original. It’s, quite simply, one of the best mods ever made.
90
Softonic
Tanto si jugaste el original como si no, Black Mesa es una aventura indispensable que te ayudará a completar esta apasionante historia de Valve y hacer tiempo mientras llega el esperadísimo Half-Life 3.
90
Softonic
Black Mesa is an incredible re-make of a classic game. While it doesn't deviate too far from the original, where it does deviate makes it successful in refreshing a old game and making it relevant again for 2012. If you haven't played any Half-Life games, this is a must play. Still, the game is not perfect, marred only by its extremely lengthy installation and long loading screens. Overall, Black Mesa is a must download. Its excellent story, soundtrack, and attention to detail make it one of the best gaming experiences out there.
90
newbreview.com
A simply mind-boggling amount of effort has been put in for no monetary reward in producing the definitive version of Half-Life; Black Mesa is everything the original was and more. Surprising, brutal, intelligent and arguably still Valve’s finest moment given the treatment it deserves.
90
Eurogamer.es
A pesar de que estas novedades son más bien escasas, y sin dejarse llevar por la nostalgia, hay que felicitar a todos los integrantes del proyecto por este excelente trabajo. El hecho de que sea gratuito es una razón muy de peso para animaros a descargarlo y a revivir esas sensaciones que tuvimos hace 14 años, cuando descubrimos que se podía jugar a "Doom con el mouse" mientras empezábamos a engancharnos una historia que aún hoy da de qué hablar.
90
Games TM
We’ve seen that we shouldn’t doubt the sincerity of a team of people working together just because something is taking them a long time. We’ve seen that Valve is not perfect. We’ve seen it is possible to take something brilliant and make it better if the right amount of care is given. And we’ve seen that Half-Life, a 14-year-old FPS, is still better than a hell of a lot of its current generation stablemates.
85
Spazio Games
Avremmo premiato un progetto come Black Mesa anche se fosse stato a pagamento, ma giocarselo gratuitamente non può che innalzare ulteriormente la valutazione finale. Questo remake di Half-Life riconferma infatti sia l'assoluta validità del gioco a quasi quindici anni di distanza dalla sua uscita, sia l'ottimo restyling grafico portato avanti da un team di oltre quaranta sviluppatori su base assolutamente volontaria. Il risultato, seppur ancora un po' acerbo per qualche sbavatura tecnica e non privo di bug, convince pienamente e le novità introdotte non fanno altro che aggiungere prestigio e longevità a un progetto da lodare sotto tutti i punti di vista.
85
Gamer.nl
Black Mesa is een hoop dingen. Het is een van de beste mods uit de geschiedenis, het is een pakket dat Half-Life-fans alles biedt wat ze maar willen. En het is een kans voor nieuwkomers om op een relatief moderne manier kennis te maken met die ene game waar altijd zoveel over te doen is geweest. Maar belangrijker dan dat is het – ondanks de wat achterhaalde gameplay – een belangrijke en bijzonder vermakelijke kijk in de geschiedenis van shooters.
80
Gamereactor (Germany)
Seit dem Erscheinen von Half-Life sind mittlerweile 15 Jahre vergangen. Genug Zeit also, um die Erinnerung zu trüben, aber nicht auszulöschen. Oft ertappe ich mich dabei, wie ich mich innerlich für eine Auseinandersetzung wappne, die dann gar nicht stattfindet und andersrum. Black Mesa ist ein Remake, klar - aber trotzdem ein komplett neues Erlebnis. Vor allem, weil Black Mesa selbst im Vordergrund steht. Die geheime Forschungsanlage erstrahlt in ihrer ganzen Schönheit und in ihrer ganzen Schrecklichkeit. Es ist die Geschichte von der menschlichen Hybris und dem langen Fall, die hier so eindrücklich erzählt wird, ganz ohne einen sprechenden Protagonisten oder lange Zwischensequenzen. Es ist eine der besten Videospiel-Storys überhaupt, finde ich.
80
Metro.co.uk
A fantastic labour of love that genuinely manages to improve on the ground-breaking original – if only by missing out some of the worst parts.
80
Destructoid
No matter what level of experience you have with Half-Life, this is worth playing. It's a brilliant tribute to one of the greatest videogames ever made, and it's also a good game in its own right.
70
Factornews
Pas exempt de défaut, mais le travail se sent et la nostalgie fait son petit effet.