Carnivores 2 Reviews (Windows)

ESRB Rating
Critic Score
100 point score based on reviews from various critics.
User Score
5 point score based on user ratings.

User Reviews

A top-notch 3D hunter that didn't get the attention it deserves Luckspeare (1502) 4.67 Stars4.67 Stars4.67 Stars4.67 Stars4.67 Stars
The best game of the Carnivores series Ethan Miller (12) 3.67 Stars3.67 Stars3.67 Stars3.67 Stars3.67 Stars
Unfairly neglected, Carnivores 2 is a real gem Jim Newland (56) unrated

Our Users Say

Category Description User Score
AI How smart (or dumb) you perceive the game's artificial intelligence to be 3.1
Gameplay How well the game mechanics work (player controls, game action, interface, etc.) 3.5
Graphics The quality of the art, or the quality/speed of the drawing routines 3.3
Personal Slant How much you personally like the game, regardless of other attributes 3.4
Sound / Music The quality of the sound effects and/or music composition 3.4
Story / Presentation The main creative ideas in the game and how well they're executed 2.7
Overall User Score (17 votes) 3.2

Critic Reviews

MobyRanks are listed below. You can read here for more information about MobyRank.
As with all budget titles, the price is the best thing about Carnivores 2. But do not grimace if you find this one under the tree this Xmas. It's fun, fairly involving, and it looks and sounds almost as good as a game you would pay full price for.
Many gamers are skeptical about the rise of "hunting" games. Crusty gamers like us often consider the hunting game a sorry excuse for a first-person shooter, lacking the cutting edge technology and design quality of blockbusters like Half-Life or Quake II. Early hunting games certainly helped to create that opinion, with dated graphics, poor gameplay, and hick appeal. Besides, why hunt ducks when multiplayer gaming showed the most dangerous game is man himself? Even crap like Microsoft Windows can get better with time. Carnivores 2 just crashed through the brush and made us eat our words.
IGN (Jan 25, 2000)
Carnivores 2 is an enjoyable action game at an affordable price, and it's a perfect mainstream title for "non-gamers". It's one of those diversions you would probably play only for a few minutes at a time (nothing wrong with that if you consider how many times you've played Solitaire, Tetris or Bust-A-Move while on the phone with a buddy) but do yourself a favor and forget that it's "another hunting game" and if the $19.99 isn't enough incentive for you, download the free demo from our download site.
GameSpot (Nov 12, 1999)
Carnivores 2 is a great diversion just like its ancestor. You can play for a few minutes or, just as easily, a few hours, because each hunt can last for as long as you like, and the game provides an extensive and variable challenge. Your style of play will change drastically depending on whether you're hunting a meat eater or a plant eater, and the game is even more dynamic than the first now that you can throw everything into the mix at once. Those who played the original Carnivores ought to expect more of the same (at the same low price), while those who didn't, but who either like dinosaurs or the idea of shooting them, ought to take this second chance without hesitation.
All in all, Carnivores 2 represents a solid hunting game with a great twist. If you didn't play the first one and think you might like a hunting sim featuring prehistoric animals that can also hunt you, then it might be worth your time. Otherwise, you need to be a true fan of the first Carnivores to relish the few enhancements that this second release brings.
It's definitely fun for a while—probably long enough to justify the game's $19.99 price tag—but you'll likely tire of the game long before you have enough points to hunt the really big game.
Game Over Online (Nov 25, 1999)
Let's see now, excellent graphics, realistic sound... oh, and they added the digit 2 to the end of Carnivores. Clever! Besides the addition of a few new dinosaurs, Carnivores 2 does little to expand on the original game. They've got a solid 3D engine, but I think it's time they use a little of their imagination to create a real solid gaming experience. Something with a little substance. Maybe then they wouldn't have to sell their games so cheap.
PC Gamer (1999)
Engine and control quirks aside, and considering the low price, you definitely get what you pay for when you buy Carnivores 2; it does have its moments. There were plenty of times when I wanted to go out to get that elusive "one more kill" so I could qualify to hunt the T-Rex, and more than a few occasions when I was humbled by the AI behind some of those pesky raptors. I'll tell you, those scaly bastards are no pushovers. Fans of hunting games will - and should - snatch this one up in a second, as it provides quite a different challenge than those pathetic, placid deer.
Diese Deer Hunter 2-Trespasser-Mischung bringt so viel Freude wie ein 32-Mann Q3A-Level mit nur einem Gegner... und der spielt mit Tastatur.
Absolute Games ( (Nov 06, 1999)
динозавров чуть больше, количество оружия удвоилось... Печально, не так ли? Кто-то продолжает клепать аддоны (да, на полноценную игру Carnivores 2 как-то не тянет), а кто-то это и поглощает в жутких количествах и порциями любого размера. C’est la vie, а потому не буду я более желать милым людям из Action Forms ничего о новых играх и нестандартных концептах. И не обвиняйте меня в космополитизме, отсутствии братских чувств и всяких сентиментальностей. Ребят, клепайте этих динозавров до потери пульса, ершкин кот! Предлагаю в следующей части сделать две охотничьих зоны, два вида ящериц и втрое увеличить доступные модели огнестрельного. Желательно, чтобы было побольше огня, эффектов и всякого подобного. Думаю, напалм подойдет. Нафиг напрягаться, правда? Ну вот и ладушки.
PC Joker (Dec, 1999)
Wald und Flur sehen mit Voodoo- oder D3D-Bescbleunigung nett, im Softwaremodus immer noch brauchbar aus und erfreuen das Ohr mit Dschungelsound. Auch die Tastatursteuerung geht in Ordnung, nicht aber das Gameplay: Genau wie in Teil eins hat man schon nach kurzer Zeit genug von diesem überaus öden 3D-Shooter für Großwildjäger.
GameStar (Germany) (Dec, 1999)
Die GT-Labors züchten eine neue Art von Jagdsimulation heran: Weil die wegen Minimal-Spielspaß allein nicht überlebensfähig sind, reichern die schlauen Köpfe sie mit 3D-Action-Genen an. Aus der Retorte schlüpft ein Zwitter, der weder Vater noch Mutter ähnlich sieht. Zu langatmige Pirsch, zu wenig taktische Möglichkeiten – Carnivores 2 dürfte die natürliche Auslese des Handels nicht überleben.