Eschalon: Book I Reviews (Windows)

71
Critic Score
100 point score based on reviews from various critics.
...
User Score
5 point score based on user ratings.

User Reviews

Nothing more than a primitive hack-n'-slash Alex Z (1750) 2.5 Stars2.5 Stars2.5 Stars2.5 Stars2.5 Stars
[v1.0] High hopes for a decent old skool RPG remake remain unfulfilled. Indra is stressed (20706) 2.33 Stars2.33 Stars2.33 Stars2.33 Stars2.33 Stars
Return to the roots! Baxter Arnett (15) 4.17 Stars4.17 Stars4.17 Stars4.17 Stars4.17 Stars

Our Users Say

Category Description User Score
AI How smart (or dumb) you perceive the game's artificial intelligence to be 3.2
Gameplay How well the game mechanics work (player controls, game action, interface, etc.) 3.8
Graphics The quality of the art, or the quality/speed of the drawing routines 3.5
Personal Slant How much you personally like the game, regardless of other attributes 3.9
Sound / Music The quality of the sound effects and/or music composition 3.7
Story / Presentation The main creative ideas in the game and how well they're executed 3.7
Overall User Score (17 votes) 3.6


Critic Reviews

MobyRanks are listed below. You can read here for more information about MobyRank.
90
GamerDad (Jan 24, 2008)
This is the sort of game that allows kids to understand why we love games from the early Ultima, Wizardry and Might & Magic series without having to look at pixilated DOSBox images. The content isn't extreme in any way - mild blood, mild language and violence. The dialogue is interesting without being complex, funny without being low-brow, and engaging throughout. Both of my boys have been loving this game (as well as Avernum 5 as I mentioned) and look forward to the next chapter!
80
GameZebo (Sep 02, 2008)
Fantasy role-playing fans in search of an “old school” click-fest might enjoy Eschalon: Book 1, but at the risk of insulting the talented developers at Basilisk, the game-play gets a little, well, bland after a short while. While the dialogue is well-written, the clichéd story and somewhat repetitive hack-and-slash-then-rest gameplay might bore some eventually. Yes, you can try to improve your cartography or lock-picking skills and try to unlock new areas to explore, but likely only RPG fans will have the patience to sink hours into this fantasy adventure.
78
Gameplay (Benelux) (Feb, 2008)
Eschalon Book 1 voorziet een aantal grote steden en een 10-tal dungeons die evenwel niet van verschillende levels zijn voorzien zoals we gewend zijn van de echte Old School klassiekers. Maar al bij al is dit een uitstekend begin van misschien wel een klassieke reeks in wording.
76
GameBanshee (Jan 19, 2008)
In any case, I like Eschalon: Book I. Although at times it comes across as sketchy in content, there’s a good deal to enjoy: the artwork, the low resource requirements, the relatively large, open field for gameplay. Combat is handled well, challenges increase gradually but sensibly if you go the fighter route and remain cautious in travel, and dungeons are appropriately varied. If it doesn’t require a great deal of thought, that only makes it more of a casual game than some other RPGs, the kind of thing you can pick up for a few minutes to an hour, then put away and play again a day or a week later. It isn’t compelling, urging you to see what new challenge or brilliantly devised quest lies around the next corner. But it is fun. And that means a good deal.
50
2404.org PC Gaming (Feb 13, 2008)
Despite the many warts, Eschalon is not without charm, as this game would have been an award-winning achievement in 1986 or so. Everything is done well, for that era, but, much like steam locomotives, I’m just not convinced this style really works nowadays. Players with that certain hunger for this sort of game will be satisfied, although mainstream gamers will probably find their gaming dollar better spent elsewhere.
50
Absolute Games (AG.ru) (Jan 23, 2008)
Eschalon: Book 1 — одноразовое творение для тех, кто тоскует по временам, когда играм хватало 3,5-дюймовой дискеты, мониторам — четырех цветов, а людям — лабиринтов из псевдографики, где «М» значило «монстр». Как CRPG она, увы, куда примитивнее и скучнее того, что выпускали Origin и Sir-Tech на заре 1990-х. Спасибо за путешествие по волнам памяти, господа из Basilisk Games, но я лучше сыграю в Exult.