User Reviews

There are no reviews for this game.

Our Users Say

Category Description User Score
AI How smart (or dumb) you perceive the game's artificial intelligence to be 3.3
Gameplay How well the game mechanics work (player controls, game action, interface, etc.) 3.6
Graphics The quality of the art, or the quality/speed of the drawing routines 3.6
Personal Slant How much you personally like the game, regardless of other attributes 3.7
Sound / Music The quality of the sound effects and/or music composition 3.2
Overall User Score (18 votes) 3.5

Critic Reviews

MobyRanks are listed below. You can read here for more information about MobyRank.
Now much of what I've done is comparing the original game to the expansion pack, but since both of them are combined into MCG, you have the option to play both MC and the MC expansion pack on the same CD. Having both combined into one CD can create some confusion, but it's a definite help when it comes to the overall purchasing of the game. Instead of paying $60 for the first game, and then an additional $30 for the expansion pack, the whole thing is just $75. Mixing these together gives you the option of playing both versions in multiplayer, and combines their look and attitude. MechCommander Gold really is a great game, but the expansion pack really didn't have enough effort put into it. But overall I still feel it's a game well worth the cost and highly recommend purchasing it.
Power Play (Nov, 1999)
Ich habe mich auf Nachschub gefreut — da kamen mir die neuen Missionen gerade recht. Doch Zugegeben: 12 Missionen sind nicht viel, und die kleinen Änderungen bei der Bedienung nicht unbedingt der Rede wert, zumal sie inkonsequent, gerade bei den neuen Angriffsoptionen umgesetzt wurden. Neue Mechs und Waffen mögen dem detailverliebten Fan des Battletech-Univerums erfreuen, bringen aber kaum mehr strategische Tiefe. Lediglich der Editor kann hier noch besonders herausragen, bietet er doch die Möglichkeit, kreativ zu sein. Aber selbst da gehen die meisten Firmen heutzutage andere Wege und legen den Editor entweder sofort dem Vollprodukt bei oder bieten ihn im Nachhinein kostenlos zum Download an. Empfehlen kann ich Mech Commander Gold nur denjenigen, die die alte Version nicht besitzen, auch wenn momentan der Weg über Importeure genommen werden muß. Alle anderen werden sich ärgern oder zähneknirschend ein Spiel quasi doppelt bezahlen.
MechCommander Gold really does deliver when you break down the things that it offers. There aren't many areas where this one falls short and that is quite a feat in it's self. Graphics, sound, gameplay and lasting impression are all things that this game does well and ends up making this worth the price. It is a well made game with lots of playtime to be yoked from within.
MECH GOLD adds new Mechs and weapons, and a brand new campaign. Owners of the original game can get a rebate from Microprose, which makes for some inexpensive gameplay; and if you never played, here’s a great opportunity to see the more tactical side of the real-time strategy genre.
GameSpot (Oct 19, 1999)
MechCommander Gold is a subtle enhancement to a nearly excellent real-time strategy game. However, its limited scope will feel frustratingly familiar to MechCommander veterans, although newcomers should enjoy the game in its more refined state.
While MechCommander Gold is dramatically better than its older brother, for all intents and purposes, it is merely the same game with some new missions and one huge patch. This is something for which we’ve been waiting a long time and should have seen sooner than this. While it’s great to finally have some things fixed, the added features don’t add up to a year in development, but still make for a decent experience if you’ve never played the original.