Star Wars: Jedi Knight - Jedi Academy

The Good
This game capitalizes on its predecessor's strength: lightsaber combat. This time around there is more variety with plenty of opponents and new saber modes (dual saber and saber staff). While these fights can get fairly hectic, the developers have added some special moves that you can execute, and the whole experience can really come together quite well.

While the story is minimal, and there is a groan factor at the beginning of every mission as you "unexpectedly" encounter trouble in the unlikeliest of places, once the action gets going it is generally varied enough to keep you entertained. There are vehicles to operate, huge monsters to contend with, and you even get to man the battle stations to shoot down some TIE ships a couple of times.

The Bad
The games missions are structured more like "chores", which you must do in groups of five (you can skip one of each group), in order to get the the few plot-advancing missions. This means that each one is mostly unrelated to the others plot-wise. A major gripe I have with these missions is a good 50% of them are not what they advertise to be. For example there is an early mission taking you with rescuing crash survivors. However once you get to the crash site, your ship breaks and it turns out there are no survivors to save. So the mission is actually about fixing your ship to get back. There are quite a few such bait-and-switches, where nothing gets accomplished by your being there.

My second biggest gripe is the level design. Of all the Jedi Knight games, I believe the first one with its old proprietary engine worked the best at presenting Star Wars' massive settings. In Jedi Academy, to an even greater extent than in Outcast most of the levels seem cramped and artificially walled off. Additionally, some of the levels' population of baddies goes strangely unexplained. While it's easy to believe that an Imperial Remnant installation on some god-forsaken planet would be full of Storm Troopers, one tends to wonder why the rooftops of a residential district on Corusant are a veritable menagerie of alien life hell-bent on trying to kill you. Civilians are nowhere to be seen, even in places you would expect them, and a number of areas seem empty and desolate because of this. And while there is significant variety in levels, a lot of them are simply a sequence of nondescript hi-tech looking rooms with various meaningless displays, populated by a lot of troopers. I believe that the use of the Quake 3 engine, which was designed to allow for intense combat in relatively small and cramped quarters really hurts the game here.

Puzzles are more or less meaningless - there are buttons to push and keys to find, but it seems like they're only there because one is supposed to be pushing buttons and finding keys in these types of games. The rule of thumb is push any button you see, and this will get you past 90% of the games "obstacles".

It is also unfortunate that the designers chose to limit the use of force powers to a few "key" points. For example, while you posses the push and pull force powers, you can only use them on designated objects in the game world. It would be much more fun to incorporate the force powers into the physics system, and allow the player to find creative ways to use them to navigate obstacles. Instead you will see your trigger light up when pointed at a "force-friendly" object, to let you know that this rock, out of thousands of identical rocks in the level can be force-pushed.

The Bottom Line
Despite its flaws, it is definitely an enjoyable experience once you get going. The lightsaber fights alone are worth the price for a star wars fan. As a shooter/saber fighter it's a pretty good game, but don't expect a lot of Star Wars immersion.