There are no reviews for the Windows release of this game. You can use the links below to write your own review or read reviews for the other platforms of this game.
|Acting||The quality of the actors' performances in the game (including voice acting).||4.8|
|Gameplay||How well the game mechanics work (player controls, game action, interface, etc.)||4.2|
|Graphics||The quality of the art, or the quality/speed of the drawing routines||4.2|
|Personal Slant||How much you personally like the game, regardless of other attributes||4.0|
|Sound / Music||The quality of the sound effects and/or music composition||4.0|
|Story / Presentation||The main creative ideas in the game and how well they're executed||4.0|
|Overall MobyScore (5 votes)||4.2|
here for more information about MobyRank.
Homestar Ruiner (and hopefully the balance of Strong Bad's five-episode starting season) is a welcome evolution of everything Telltale learned from making Sam & Max, and Strong Bad's quirky, colorful world is perhaps even better-suited to the format, in terms of both genre and storytelling structure. At times like this, it's a wonder that adventure games ever went off the rails.
Barring minor technical errors, The Homestar Ruiner is a great start for this episodic game. It’s funny, inexpensive, easy to play, and has replay value from the mini-games. Since it appeals strongly to devoted fans of the animated series, strangers to the Homestar Runner universe may not get all the in-jokes and strange humor. Therefore, if you’re curious to try it out, I suggest visiting the Homestar Runner website first and reading a few Strong Bad Emails to familiarize yourself with the characters.
Adrenaline Vault, The (AVault)
Until I started playing Homestar Ruiner, I had never heard of Strong Bad and his goofy comrades, but after playing the game I’m hooked. The simplicity of the presentation, the colorful, cartoon-like art direction and the sometimes laugh-out-loud funny writing make this a real treat to play. It might not have much replay value, and there are a few little problems here and there, but if you’re looking for a quick, stylish comedy fix, Homestar Ruiner is the cure for what ails you. Hopefully the upcoming episodes will be able to build on its success.
Taken as a whole, this is a very enjoyable game - if Telltale can keep up this standard all through the season, then they’re looking at another winner.
For Homestar fans, this is a no-brainer, but if they’re the only ones who play it, it’ll be a shame — the only thing you need to enjoy it is a sense of humor. It’s a great beginning to a longer adventure, and absolutely worth a download.
Armchair Empire, The
The kickoff episode to the five-game first season of the newest Telltale Games episodic point & click adventure franchise, Homestar Ruiner will be embraced wholeheartedly by the Homestar Runner community at large, as well as those not quite familiar with the website. With fun puzzles and a funnier story in yet another of its game series, Telltale Games has shown everybody that the success and quality of its Sam & Max franchise wasn’t just a fluke, and that any developer/publisher that is interested creating episodic gaming has only to look Telltale’s way on how to do it right.
Video Game Generation
Homestar Ruiner allows fans to play through most of the franchise’s major locations and interact with virtually all of the major characters, while controlling arguably its most popular character. Strong Bad’s antics translate very well to the adventure game format, and the gameplay is solid with puzzles that are challenging without being illogical. Minor glitches aside, Strong Bad’s Cool Game for Attractive People Episode 1: Homestar Ruiner is a strong start to what should be another long and successful episodic franchise from Telltale Games.
Gamers who enjoy adventure games, but aren't familiar with Homestar Runner owe it to themselves to check this one out. Perhaps the only people who won't enjoy this game are those who don't understand or like the comedic style of the Homestar Runner universe.
Game Over Online
The first Strong Bad episode is out now, and the other episodes are scheduled to be released in the upcoming months. I enjoyed the first episode a lot, and I think the Sam & Max episodes work as a good litmus test. If you liked the humor and structure of the Sam & Max episodes, then you’ll probably enjoy the Strong Bad episodes as well. The Strong Bad episode is also a much better “animated feature” than what just came out in theaters last week, and for about the same price.
Pour ce premier épisode de Strong Bad’s Cool Game For Attractive People, TellTale a fait du bon boulot. Les amateurs de la websérie peuvent sans hésiter sortir la carte bleue, quant aux autres, je leur conseille de se faire une idée avec la démo ou le site officiel.
While I did enjoy playing through Homestar Ruiner, my fear is that the level of fan fare won't be able to be kept up, and quite frankly, I doubt that people who aren't fans of both Homestar Runner and adventure games will find this series too appealing. That being said, if you do happen to fall into this category, then Strong Bad's Cool Game for Attractive People is definitely worth looking into, at least Homestar Ruiner is. We will report on the rest of the season as it becomes available.
Adventure Classic Gaming
Ultimately, just as in the other adapted franchises from Telltale Games, the strength of the game relies on the strength of the material. The developer has earned a reputation for handling Sam & Max very faithfully, and its treatment of the universe of Homestar Runner is no different. Mike and Matt’s handiwork is all over this game, and at times it feels like a couple of their cartoons interspersed with short segments from their website all run together. How much that idea appeals to you will be the key element to how much you will enjoy this game. Aside from slight issues in making the transition from 2D to 3D, the world of Free Country USA is much the same in the game as it is on the internet, and the quality of the gameplay makes this game an easy recommendation for any fan of the Homestar Runner series and worth at least a try for all adventure game fans.
All in all, totally worth the playtime and highly recommended for fans of adventure gaming and fans of Strong Bad. You Homestar runner fans can just…umm…go run the race to the end of the race.
Cheat Code Central
Unless you happen to be an enemy of all things cool and funny, the first installment of Strong Bad is where it's at. This new monthly series shows tons of promise, and the next episode, Strong Badia the Free, looks even more delightfully ludicrous. If you own a Wii or a PC, there's absolutely no reason why you shouldn't throw down some money to pick up Episode 1. Strong Bad's first wacky gaming adventure is highly recommendable, but can you handle his style?
The A.V. Club
Strong Bad's Cool Game for Attractive People, Episode 1: Homestar Ruiner is a point-and-click adventure game, of the "Try the hedge clippers on the car, because why not?" variety. Like Telltale's other comic-based games (Sam And Max, Bone), it will be released in Sunday-afternoon-length episodes, and the story in the first one is just complicated enough to satisfy. But the strange mini-games, the dialogue, and the interactive peek into the mind of Strong Bad are the real draw.
Overall, despite its faults, Homestar Ruiner is a pretty enjoyable game, a lighthearted cartoon romp with a great sense of humor and an original flavor. It suffers from some problems with its puzzle and dialogue design, but it is fun to play, and the developers incorporated a lot of details along with a great script -- even the Main Menu is entertaining! Even if you’ve never heard of Homestar Runner or watched any of the videos, you can still have a great time with this game, and it will definitely inspire you to go to the website. Plus, you’ll get some great cynical one-liners to use on your friends!
Net zoals Sam & Max is het Telltale gelukt om gewoon weer een leuke point & click game af te leveren. De sfeer van de oude Lucasarts adventure games is zeker terug te voelen. Leuk voor de fans maar ook voor niet-fans raden wij het zeker aan. Wij haatten Strong Bad en Homestar Runner hiervoor maar deze episode vonden wij prima.
PC Gameplay (Benelux)
Sam & Max genieten onze voorkeur, maar dit is net zo goed een leuke en grappige adventurereeks. Op naar episode 2!
Strong Bad‘s Cool Game for Attractive People ist sehr lustig, total abgefahren und einfach mal anders. Dass das Spiel hierzulande viele spielen werden, wage ich jedoch zu bezweifeln. Das liegt zum einen daran, dass kaum jemand die Serie Homestar Runner kennt und zum anderen, dass der Humor für nicht englisch sprechende Menschen kaum zu verstehen ist. Eine Übersetzung des Titels ins Deutsche schließe ich aus, ich bezweifle zumindest stark, dass sich ein deutscher Publisher an eine Lokalisierung traut. Dafür ist der Humor auch zu sehr auf das amerikanische Publikum zugeschnitten.
PAL Gaming Network (PALGN)
In the end however, these are all near moot points, considering both the cost and inherent polish in admission. As yet another example of the industry's exaggeration of the death of adventure games, Strong Bad's Cool Game for Attractive People - Episode 1: Homestar Ruiner is not quite the upholder of its genre's elegant values. But as an example of the continuous satisfaction to be garnered from episodic delivery, the game's a welcome, if short-lived experience for both adventure game and Homestar Runner fans alike. A positive foreboding for the rest of the SBC4AP saga.
All in all, it's solid for what it is, but unless you really like logic puzzles involving everyday objects and cheating, the fact that it's a game will not make up for the fact that it's Homestar Runner if you don't enjoy the site. If you do enjoy the site, this game will be wonderful for you in spite of its flaws, which is probably what they were going for anyway.
SBCGfAP is packed with little extras and mini-games, although none provide more than a few minutes of diversion. The real fun is discovering all of the inside jokes from the series plastered throughout. You can explore every room in Strong Bad's house, buy stuff from Bub's concession stand, outwit the Poopsmith, and participate in all of the lunacy that gives the website such ongoing popularity. Gamers who aren't fans of Homestar Runner won't get much out of this, but if you enjoy the work of the Brothers Chaps and are looking for a few hours of primary-colored mayhem, you might want to give the first episode a spin.
More enjoyable for existing series fans, Homestar Ruiner provides a light, enjoyable experience that succeeds mostly as a platform for its humor.
Here’s the so basically: If you’re a fan of Strong Bad, the game is worth getting. If you are not a fan, it’s not worth getting. That’s it!
Strong Bad's Cool Game for Attractive People est un peu décevant comparé à d'autres jeux épisodiques sortis ces derniers temps. Il ne vous arrachera que quelques sourires si vous n'êtes pas un grand connaisseur de la websérie Homestar Runner. Mais à 6 euros l'épisode (et environ 22 euros le pack contenant les cinq premiers épisodes), SBCG4AP a de quoi conquérir les coeurs et surtout les portes-monnaie.
Ohne die Internet-Serie zu kennen, habe ich mich von Beginn an köstlich amüsiert. Nachdem ich mir einige Folgen angesehen hatte, wurde es noch lustiger. Jedoch müssen Sie, wie bei Sam & Max, sehr gut Englisch verstehen, auch dieses Adventure erscheint nicht als deutsche Version. Für umgerechnet sechs Euro ist Strong Bad für englischkundige Freunde schrägen Humors auf jeden Fall einen Blick wert.
"Strong Bad's Cool Game for Attractive People Episode 1: Homestar Ruiner", como um jogo tradicional, oferece uma experiência rasteira e bem menos envolvente do que a própria franquia "Sam & Max" da mesma Telltale, por exemplo. A mecânica clássica utilizada serve apenas de muleta para piadas tradicionais do universo de "Homestar Runner", retratado com extrema fidelidade, deixando o game com cara desenho com certos toques interativos. Fãs dos personagens pode não ver nada de errado e se deliciar, já que o roteiro tem algumas tiradas muito engraçadas e criativas, mas o conjunto parece raso demais para o jogador desavisado que ignora o material que deu origem ao título.
Overall my suggestion would be, stick the game’s suggestions (hints) on high, enjoy it as a constant stream of brain-dead semi funny entertainment, in a universe you are probably familiar with, and get as much stress-free enjoyment from what admittedly, feels like a pretty polished episodic game. And be excited by the fact there will be one a month for a while to come… Or you could just watch all the video’s on Youtube for free, and have about as much fun.
Homestar Ruiner is hardly a game, and the point-and-clickery only serves as a barrier between the player and some genuinely funny moments. It is a shame that this episode was so disappointing, as the series has tremendous potential. If Telltale can make the gameplay half as good as the humour, it will be a winner.
There is hope: this franchise is just way too funny to imagine that it won't hit its stride in the next few episodes. I have to say, the teaser preview that you unlock for Episode 2 at the end of this episode did look really funny. But it's clear that there are going to be some growing pains along the way as the developers figure out how to make the humor and style of Homestar Runner translate into a video game. Fans of the franchise probably won't be too disappointed if they pick this up, but people looking for a series point-and-click adventure game are probably going to want to go elsewhere.
After the consistent quality of the Sam & Max games, you might have the expectation that this game is going to be similarly excellent. I certainly did. I was sadly disappointed. Now don't get me wrong, technically, Strong Bad is rock solid. The graphics, sound and voice acting all are good quality. I just didn't like it at all. I guess I couldn't deal with the conflicting messages between an adult male voice and such infantile attitudes in the main character and his quest. And things just went downhill from there.
Homestar Ruiner looks quite good, but ultimately this new format doesn't work out. The punchy comedic pacing that works so well in a series of video shorts does not hold up when stretched out over a few hours, and the few times you do chuckle will only punctuate the fact that such moments are few and far between. Though it is reasonably priced at $8.95, Strong Bad's Cool Game for Attractive People isn't recommendable. Folks looking to get a Homestar humor fix are better off visiting the Web site than going on this subpar adventure.