Current MobyGoal: Help us reach 250 documented ZX81 Games

Xianjian Qixia Zhuan 2 (Windows)

...
MobyRank
100 point score based on reviews from various critics.
3.8
MobyScore
5 point score based on user ratings.
Written by  :  אולג 小奥 (168579)
Written on  :  Jan 01, 2006
Rating  :  3.83 Stars3.83 Stars3.83 Stars3.83 Stars3.83 Stars

4 out of 4 people found this review helpful

write a review of this game
read more reviews by אולג 小奥
read more reviews for this game

Summary

Love, werefoxes, and Buddhist disputes could have given us more

The Good

The first Xianjian Qixia Zhuan game was a big hit in China. Surprisingly, Softstar took its time, releasing the sequel much later than expected.

There are several noticeable (mostly gameplay-related) improvements in the sequel. What I disliked most in the first game were the endless mazes with annoying respawning enemies. I was pleased to discover that the sequel corrected this flaw. The mazes in this game are much smaller and much easier to navigate. There are still all kinds of passages to find and treasures to collect, but it gets nowhere near the monotonous corridors of the first game.

The first game had also had serious problems with gameplay balance. In the sequel, they corrected the balance issue (finally, enemies in later dungeons give you appropriate amount of experience, so you'll never feel the urge to avoid enemies like in the first game), and also added some really cool touches to the combat system. One of them is Li Yiru's ability to summon monsters. Some of the bosses become your possession after you defeat them, and fight on your side as playable characters. You can have up to two such creatures summoned in a battle. Their actions are controlled by AI, but you can assign a general strategy, telling them to concentrate on attack magic, defensive spells, and so on. Those monsters gain strength the more you use them, and become pretty much indispensable for major battles.

Another very nice addition is the "magic field" spells Qiqi can cast. Such spells raise the power of a certain element, and lower the power of the opposing one. So if for example you are fighting a boss who likes using fire magic, what you can do is summon the beautiful ice goddess and then have Qiqi cast an "ice strong - fire low" spell. It will mark the field with ice element, and it will remain so until the end of the battle. Of course, not all is simple, and if you meet a group of enemies who use both ice and fire spells, you'll have to think twice.

Yet another innovation are Wang Xiaohu's tiger attacks ("xiao hu" meaning "little tiger" in Chinese), which require special "tiger" points that you accumulate by repeatedly attacking in battles.

Like in the first game, your HP and MP are restored slightly after each battle, and you are fully healed when you gain a level. You can increase your stats by repeatedly doing an appropriate action: attack a lot and your vitality will increase, cast a lot of spells and you'll gain higher magic power, etc. There are loads of weapons, accessories, and items to find and to try out. And probably the most important feature: there are no random battles, and you can save anywhere. Two of the things many people dislike most in Japanese-style RPGs are absent here.

The second game also handles the "no random battles" aspect significantly better than the first. In the first one, enemies were respawning automatically the moment you left the room and entered it again. They were also much more numerous, aggressive, and hard to avoid. The combination with the sheer complexity of the mazes and the necessity to backtrack almost made me wish the battles were random. In the second game, everything is much more balanced.

Visually, the game represents the "lost art" of 2D graphics. Though technically way behind the times, the graphical style has a charm that is not always present in 3D games. The music is expressive and catchy. Some melodies are recycled from the first game, including much of the battle music. A refreshing change is the abundance of battle melodies; there is no "standard" battle theme, but about four or five of them, if not more.

The Bad

The difficulty level is still pretty uneven. Some bosses are very easy; others are an absolute pain. The game also has the nasty habit of taking characters away from the party just when you need them most.

Xianjian Qixia Zhuan 2 is, once again, absolutely linear. It is so linear that it makes most other Japanese-style RPGs look like sandbox experiences in an open world. It is, in fact, even more linear than the previous game, and that's saying a lot. The game is simply a journey from one location to another. There is no "world map", and no places to explore besides those the game takes you to automatically.

The worst part of it is the final stretch. Without knowing that the last town was really last, I decided to spare money and didn't buy the most expensive weapons and healing items. But when I found myself having trouble in the last dungeon, I discovered, to my amazement, that I couldn't even go back to that town to buy more supplies.

Dreadful linearity is coupled with a minuscule size. The game is noticeably shorter than its predecessor and doesn't feel "epic" in the least. There are barely any towns in the game, and the whole thing feels somewhat rushed and reduced, as if large portions of the game were cut out during development.

That would be less of a problem if the initial premise and the subsequent plot were more exciting. Unfortunately, it's quite lukewarm by Chinese standards. With a few exceptions, the characters are not particularly interesting, and the endearing tragic romances from the first game are replaced by pretty mild emotional exchanges that do not live up to its tear-jerking progenitor.

The Bottom Line

The long-awaited sequel to the most popular Chinese RPG corrects many flaws that plagued its famed predecessor, or at least makes them much more tolerable. However, its tiny size, depressing linearity and toned-down emotional intensity make it less than the stellar follow-up it strove to be.