User Reviews

An outstanding game, probably the best arcade style-racing game ever (?) David Lafferty (16) 4 Stars4 Stars4 Stars4 Stars4 Stars
Extreme racing and driving skills game with high performance autos earned by level completion. Tar Larner (2) 4.33 Stars4.33 Stars4.33 Stars4.33 Stars4.33 Stars
MSR for Xbox phlux (4340) 3.17 Stars3.17 Stars3.17 Stars3.17 Stars3.17 Stars

Our Users Say

Category Description User Score
AI How smart (or dumb) you perceive the game's artificial intelligence to be 3.4
Gameplay How well the game mechanics work (player controls, game action, interface, etc.) 3.8
Graphics The quality of the art, or the quality/speed of the drawing routines 4.2
Personal Slant How much you personally like the game, regardless of other attributes 3.6
Sound / Music The quality of the sound effects and/or music composition 3.8
Overall User Score (32 votes) 3.7


Critic Reviews

MobyRanks are listed below. You can read here for more information about MobyRank.
95
XBox Solution (XBS) (Jul 18, 2002)
This game needs to be in every true racing gamers’ library. Hours and hours (and days) of racing excitement, awesomely detailed graphics, and customizeable soundtrack make for a top of the line racer.
90
Peliplaneetta.net (Apr 01, 2002)
Siinä missä MSR oli hieman keskeneräinen klassikko, PGR on sen kehittyneempi muoto lähes joka suhteessa. Sisäinen nostalgioijani tietysti suree huonoja kuskeja rankaisevan Kudos-systeemin helpottamisesta, vaikka se nykyisellään onkin toki vähemmän ärsyttävä, ja raikkaan erilaisen musiikin korvaamisesta mainstream-tavaralla. Xboxkaan ei voi koskaan olla niin sympaattinen kuin Dreamcast, tuo sioille heitetty helmi, mutta PGR olisi pirun hyvä peli vaikka millä koneella. Minun mittapuullani tämä on tasoissa GT3:n kanssa koska tahansa, jo sen vuoksi että pelissä on jotain järkevää tekemistä loputtoman saman toistamisen sijaan, mutta moni on varmasti eri mieltä. Kokeilkaa silti.
90
GameZone (Feb 19, 2002)
Project Gotham is the first racing game that I know of to show damage on real-life car models, such as the Volkswagen Beetle. Unfortunately, the damage is minimal. You can crash all day long, it doesn't matter. I banged up the side of my Bug several times, and the only damage I had to show for it was a small dent and a broken tail light! It's disappointing to see such little damage in a game that excels in almost every other way.
90
GamePro (US) (Nov 15, 2001)
While Project Gotham shares many gameplay similarities with Bizzare’s other racer, Metropolis Street Racer for the Dreamcast, this speedster is definitely much better in every respect. In the twisting streets of San Francisco, New York, Tokyo, and London, you must prove that your driving skills consist of more than just crossing the finish line in first place. Graphically, an attention to detail is evident in Project Gotham. And if the sights aren’t enough, your ears will rock to the banging tunes. Don’t get Project Gotham just because it’s one of the first racers for the Xbox. Get it because it's one of the top driving games for any system.
89
ActionTrip (Jan 22, 2002)
Lastly, this is an awesome game, buy it! I swear I have never played such a piece of shit in my life, and that's why I think it's simply marvelous! It's very good and that's why it sucks. Am I getting through to you here? Good.
88
Gamesmania.de (Mar 08, 2002)
Project Gotham Racing zeigt deutlich, was auf der Xbox in Zukunft möglich sein wird. Für Rennfreaks ist der Titel ein klares "must have".
88
IGN (Nov 09, 2001)
This one's not for everyone. That being said, neither is the Tekken or Gran Turismo series. Both are games that require some heavy duty dedication to really find the beauty of their respective play mechanics, and Gotham is no different. It's a tough game that demands perfection more often than not, and to beat some particular races you'll be restarting the entire race the moment you've made an error. But if you're meticulous enough to enjoy getting into the meat of a deep title like this one, you'll find that the designers have really tried to create a new driving experience, and for the most part, succeeded in doing just that.
87
Game Freaks 365 (Apr 19, 2003)
You race through more then 200 different circuits in New York, London, Tokyo, and San Francisco. There are over 25 high performance dream cars to unlock including the Ferrari F50, Porsche Boxster S, Corvette Z06, and Aston Martin Vanquish. There is a multi-player aspect to this game. You and up to three other friends can go head to head in an all out race. But this game lacks the support of the Xbox system link so you would have to play 4 players on one tiny screen for each. But overall there is at least 20+ hours of racing here. For only 20 dollars, how can you lose?
86
videospiele.com (Mar 14, 2002)
Wer ein etwas anderes Rennspielkonzept ausprobieren will, eine Herausforderung sucht oder ein großer Fan von Metropolis Street Racer ist, der kann sich Gotham Racing bedenkenlos zulegen. Es gibt coole Fahrzeuge, viele Level zu erspielen und die Schwierigkeitsgrad steigert sich langsam aber merklich in Profibereiche. Die interessanten Fahrzeugtypen und deren Schadenmodelle findet man auch sonst in nur sehr wenigen Rennspielen. Wer aber ein simples Funrennspiel erwartet, bei dem am Straßenrand einiges fürs Auge geboten wird, der dürfte Gotham Racing eher frustrierend und langweilig empfinden. Ich hoffe, dass man in einem künftigen Nachfolger etwas Leben am Streckenrand sehen wird, die Parcours etwas abwechslungsreicher gestaltet sind und die Städte nicht so sehr nach Dreamcast aussehen. Selbst wenn dies auf Kosten des Realismus geschehen müsste.
85
The Xbox has once again shown that it can indeed deliver a great game that looks fantastic, which leaves me running out of reasons not to go out and snatch one up myself. With games like this in its arsenal, I would be surprised if the Xbox didn’t hit the ground running.
85
4Players.de (Mar 12, 2002)
Wer genug von den endlosen Positionskämpfen anderer Rennspiele hat, liegt bei Project Gotham Racing genau richtig. Denn obwohl das Kudos-System mittlerweile nicht mehr neu ist, liefert es eine erfrischende und überaus motivierende Abwechslung. Auch die Grafik kann im Großen und Ganzen überzeugen, obwohl hier eindeutig mehr möglich gewesen wäre, wie die fantastisch modellierten Fahrzeuge deutlich belegen. Und dass man die Möglichkeit hat, seine eigenen Songs einzubauen, sollte eigentlich Standard werden. Genau betrachtet ist Gotham zwar mehr eine konsequente Weiterentwicklung des Dreamcast-MSR als eine Fortsetzung, aber trotzdem: Wer sich nur ansatzweise für Rennspiele interessiert, findet mit der teils nervenzerfetzenden Kudos-Jagd genügend Stoff für viele spannende Abende.
85
Game Critics (Jun 05, 2002)
Project Gotham Racing is an impressive racing game. While its not quite on the same level as the Gran Turismo series, theyre definitely in the same parking lot. Project Gotham Racings innovative kudos system adds a great deal to the traditional driving game formula, making it so that skill and speed are both factors necessary to win. Consider that with the lush car graphics, the multitude of items to unlock, and the sheer breadth and depth of the game and one can see why Project Gotham Racing has made me reconsider my casual dismissal of the racing game genre. While it hasnt made me a hardcore racing game fan, Project Gotham Racing demonstrates that theres still room for innovation in even the most traditional gaming categories.
84
GameSpy (Nov 14, 2001)
Bizarre Creations has done a great job at injecting some freshness in a very crowded genre. Project Gotham Racing is definitely different than most racing games on the market and a worthwhile purchase. Between the novel gameplay, tremendous depth, and beautiful cars, this racer really stands apart. If the difficulty level of the latter stages was kinder and the environmental detail greater, it would have been a near-perfect racing game. As it is, it's still a very good one that has eagerly anticipating a sequel.
84
Play.tm (Mar 15, 2002)
All in all then, Project Gotham Racing is a well conceived and well realised racing game, not exactly brimming with ideas of it's own, but with a nicely-refined racing style, and a great mixture of cars and tracks (shame more locations weren't used though). The name may be pants, but it's an enjoyable spin, especially in multiplayer mode; when will someone come up with an original racing game though?
83
The Video Game Critic (Dec 06, 2001)
A well-designed "kudos" system allows you to earn points by driving with style, speed, and skill. It's really fun to watch your points rack up during a good run. You use these points to unlock new tracks and cars. Unlike Gran Turismo 3 (PS2), you won't have to invest an inordinate amount of time to get to the good stuff. The audio is less impressive, and the "radio" tunes didn't really appeal to me. The four-player split-screen mode is smooth and very competitive. Project Gotham is really a very impressive first generation racer for the XBox.
81
GameSpot (Nov 13, 2001)
At the end of the day, Project Gotham Racing is a unique driving game that pulls off its Tony Hawk approach better than its predecessor, Metropolis Street Racer. The Kudos system would have probably benefited from a longer development period, but the developer wasn't afforded that luxury because of this game's launch status, and while it may be sometimes frustrating, it ultimately ends up being fun. While its unique spin on driving and its scarcity of cars might put people looking for the next Gran Turismo off, anyone who considers themselves a car fan should seriously consider adding Project Gotham Racing to their library of Xbox games.
80
X-Power (Apr 22, 2002)
Project Gotham Racing is zeker een must have voor elke race fan of iemand die zich aangetrokken voelt tot het genre. Het is zeker de moeite waard om de Multiplayer eens uit te testen met some friends. De vriendschap zal al snel omslaan naar de onbezonnen drang om te winnen. Al snel laat je vrienden stof vreten en hier zullen zij alleen maar op willen antwoorden door net hetzelfde doen. The Graphics zijn echt wel super. Microsoft heeft het zelfs zo ver gekregen om de auto constructeurs te overhalen een damagesysteem in te bouwen en geef nu toe dit mistten we toch allemaal bij Gran Turismo. Voor zover deze vergelijking opgaat bestaat het game uit genoeg originele ideeën om het staande te houden. Voor mij is het alvast zeker geslaagd en dit is toch dat telt. Great Graphics, Great Music en een geweldige gameplay kunnen niet liegen. Dit is een toptitel!! Laat hem zeker niet uit je collectie ontbreken Or U Bite The Dust!!
80
This is a shrewd move on the part of Microsoft. Give gamers a title that immediately plays to their need for a racer with depth, but won't be unfathomable to a first-time player. Gobbling up Kudos by catching air, powersliding, and other driving feats is highly addictive.
80
Overall I had a pretty good time checking out Project Gotham Racing for GiN. I just wish I was a little better at it. My girlfriend Alison repeatedly stomped me into the ground on this game. Fortunately, I was able to return the favor in Dead or Alive 3. I think overall I was most impressed with the visual aspects of Project Gotham Racing, as well as the whole Kudos challenge concept. PGR takes the checkered flag with an impressive 4 GiN Gems.
80
Jeuxvideo.com (Mar 13, 2002)
En somme on peut donc dire que Project Gotham Racing se veut un client assez sérieux sur Xbox en matière de courses de voitures même si son niveau d'innovation n'est pas transcendant depuis MSR sur Dreamcast. Il n'en demeure pas moins qu'il bénéficie d'une réalisation soignée et que son gameplay se veut assez solide. Il devrait procurer un intense plaisir de jeu à ceux qui craqueront pour lui alors qu'il sera possible de faire durer les sensations grâce à une longévité remarquable pour qui voudra traquer tous les bonus.
80
Eurogamer.net (UK) (Mar 25, 2002)
It would be nice to say Project Gotham is the best driving game I've seen, but it isn't. With Rallisport Challenge available at launch, it probably isn't even the best driving game on the Xbox, but it is a damned fine one irrespective. Devotees of Metropolis Street Racer will lap the game up interminably, and even a hardened GT and Ridge Racer nut like myself found it hard not to be impaled by this Dark Knight's sceptre of entertainment. Admittedly it's not one hundred percent of everything we hoped for; visually, aurally and in terms of gameplay. It's a bit too tough in places, but there is plenty of variation, authenticity and charm to the game, and anything that I can play for four hours straight without a break deserves a glowing accolade.
80
Gameplanet (Oct 31, 2002)
All in all, this is a very good racer that steps out of the mold of its predecessors. It's different enough to appeal to people who would not normally look twice at a racing car game without being so different as to alienate fans of the genre. Not all ardent race fans are going to dig this one though, so if you go to bed in a flame-retardent racing suit and helmet (f1 duvet included), you might want to rent this one first to be sure it's you.
75
Game Revolution (Nov, 2001)
Project Gotham's single player experience is split into four gameplay modes - Quick Race, Arcade Race, Time Attack, and Kudos Challenge. Quick Race has you racing against five other cars, Arcade Race sets up a cone obstacle course, and Time Attack pits you against the clock. Kudos Challenge is basically a combination of all other modes and is where you'll spend the most amount of time. Complete challenges, win races, and unlock stuff.
70
While X-Box fans may have been hoping that Project Gotham Racing would be their system’s Gran Turismo 3, they’ll find something entirely different inside this case when they get home from the store. Instead of a diehard simulation, they’ll instead be treated to a half-arcade, half-sim racer that makes a lot of demands on its players. At first this technique seems fresh, but after a few incredibly disappointing runs down the later tracks you’ll find it more frustrating than satisfying. With a vast selection of tracks and a large selection of cars, there’s plenty of substance to this racer, and the gameplay’s inherently fun premise is a lot less frustrating in a multiplayer environment. As such, this makes a great head-to-head challenge against up to three friends, or a perfect pastime for the obsessive driving perfectionist. If you’re looking for a fun racer or a true sim, however, it’d be best to wait a while before leaping into the streets of Gotham.