User review spotlight: Ultima IV: Quest of the Avatar (DOS)

Phantasy Star Universe (Xbox 360)

63
MobyRank
100 point score based on reviews from various critics.
3.0
MobyScore
5 point score based on user ratings.

User Reviews

Phantasy Star Online... how I miss you. Parf (7317) 3 Stars3 Stars3 Stars3 Stars3 Stars

Our Users Say

Category Description MobyScore
Acting The quality of the actors' performances in the game (including voice acting). 3.0
AI How smart (or dumb) you perceive the game's artificial intelligence to be 2.5
Gameplay How well the game mechanics work (player controls, game action, interface, etc.) 3.0
Graphics The quality of the art, or the quality/speed of the drawing routines 3.0
Personal Slant How much you personally like the game, regardless of other attributes 3.0
Sound / Music The quality of the sound effects and/or music composition 3.5
Story / Presentation The main creative ideas in the game and how well they're executed 3.0
Overall MobyScore (2 votes) 3.0


The Press Says

MobyRanks are listed below. You can read here for more information about MobyRank.
82
Shin Force
PSU is definitely not perfect, or even "much better" than PSO. There's pros and cons to every change/addition Sonic Team made. The graphics scream "port+widescreen"; a new hybrid 3rd person gameplay takes time to appreciate; and the music is good, but certainly not at PSO's level. Best features: nearly unlimited gameplay, friendship and interest. Worst features: breaking weapons, failing synthesis and waiting for Sega to unlock content via updates. However, after 250+ hours, I still find myself running this game in my Xbox 360 with no end in sight.
80
SEGA-Portal.de
Phantasy Star Universe ist definitiv eine würdige Fortsetzung der legendären Serie, wenngleich der Storymodus mit rund 25 Stunden etwas mager ausfällt. Doch die vielen Neuerungen und Verbesserungen gegenüber des Vorgängers bringen sich sowohl online als auch offline gut ein und garantieren durchzechte Nächte. Da sieht man auf der Xbox 360 auch ganz gerne mal von der nicht mehr ganz zeitgemäßen Grafik ab. Wer bereits den Vorgänger mochte und bereit ist, monatlich 9,99€ für die Guardians-Licence zum Onlinespielen zu berappen, wird auf jeden Fall auf seine Kosten kommen. Doch auch alle anderen Liebhaber von japanischen RPGs sollten sich Phantasy Star Universe einmal ansehen - es lohnt sich!
80
DreamStation.cc
Overall, fans who spent hundreds of hours in any of the previous versions of Phantasy Star Online will probably enjoy Phantasy Star Universe, but gamers coming over from legitimate MMORPG's will almost assuredly be turned off by the arcade type feel and lack of variety in areas to explore. This is a good mixture of an MMO and an action adventure game, but lacks the overall epic feel that a dedicated game might. If you're in the market for a role playing game heavy on the action then Phantasy Star Universe is a great option for you seeing as how there aren't very many other options on the 360 right now anyway.
77
Xbox360Achievements
For non-RPG fans, this might be a little more tolerable because of the free-action battle system, and even for RPG fans it's at least a small departure from the norm, but aside from that, it really is the norm, and doesn't offer anything we haven't seen before.
70
Gameplay RPG
Phantasy Star Universe offre une épopée grisante qui comporte de bonnes surprises scénaristiques, un mode on-line accrocheur et une bande-son attrayante. Cependant, PSU souffre d'une qualité technique déjà obsolète face à la concurrence mais aussi d'un gameplay convenant peu au RPG solo. D'un jeu majestueux que l'on aimerait posséder, on passe rapidement à un titre de qualité réservé aux fans de la saga. En somme, un soft à ne pas mettre entre toutes les mains... Dommage !
68
GameSpot
PSO fans will probably appreciate the game's new setting and its somewhat streamlined gameplay, but those changes definitely don't make Phantasy Star Universe a modern game.
65
4Players.de
Der Online-Modus ist ein inhaltlich künstlich limitierter Lag- und Slowdown-Marathon ohne jeglichen Story-Gehalt. Zudem fehlt es der Spielwelt an Umfang, der Spielmechanik an Abwechslung und den Community-Features an Komfort. Der Story-Modus hatte mich hingegen positiv überrascht, kann mit seinem antiquierten Leveldesign und der dürftigen KI aktuellen Offline-Rollenspielen jedoch nicht das Wasser reichen. Auch technisch wirkt PSU reichlich veraltet. Online gibt's hingegen auf allen Systemen unfreiwillige Bullet-Time, während eure Mitspieler epileptisch durch die Gegend zuckeln und ihr Gegentreffer aus dem nichts kassiert. Grundlegende Jäger- und Sammlertriebe werden zwar nach wie vor befriedigt und mit ein paar Freunden machen auch die simplen Missionen eine Weile lang Spaß, aber auf Dauer hat PSU im Hinblick auf den finanziellen Aufwand einfach zu wenig zu bieten und stellt trotz gelungener Erweiterungen zweifelsohne den bisherigen Tiefpunkt der Serie dar.
64
Play.tm
Ultimately Phantasy Star Universe fails and succeeds in (almost) equal amounts. It succeeds in tracing classic-but now dated-gameplay structure while offering an instantly accessible social online aspect that may well offer an avenue into MMO not usually accepted by those with more of a penchant for more immediate titles. However, it fails monumentally to accept the next-gen baton handed up hopefully by its Dreamcast predecessor. And it also fails miserably to shoehorn in a single-player game that emerges riddled with presentation, structure, and delivery glitches that vastly overshadow any semblance of genuine appeal.
60
Video Game Talk
The single player campaign will take approximately 18 hours to run through. While most skip the offline section to jump right in to the multiplayer, players new to the game will have a better understanding of PSU if they finish the single player. Sadly, the boring nature of the Story mode won't attract many to stay for the engrossing Xbox Live multiplayer. As for players who loved PSO on the Xbox, you won't find much new material in PSU nor will the online portion last very long for already experienced players. I recommend renting this title to give the online portion a whirl before leaping at your own retail copy.
60
Extreme Gamer
Phantasy Star Universe is still holding on to its roots and needs to be dug out and replanted. Online, or offline the Phantasy Star experience will end up feeling a little generic for today's standards of gaming. If you're a die-hard old school Phantasy Star fan you might enjoy the familiar paint on the walls, but others will quickly know something is missing. If you need that MMORPG feeling on your console this is your only option so far, so make the best out of it until the next developer tries its hand at cashing in on the online RPG phenomenon.
52
Game Freaks 365
The mindless dungeon crawling gets old after a while. You will not have nearly as much fun with Phantasy Star Universe unless you hop on with some friends. Even then, it tends to get boring rather quickly. You are only allowed general attacks with no real variety which hurts player’s creativity greatly. Missing from Phantasy Star Universe is the addition of Mag’s to help boost your character. This is a big feature that has gone missing and had my friends and I rather upset at least. Besides the character development once you unlock it, the only real fun to be had is through the game’s online multiplayer. But the $10 price tag per month can just be too much for players to play such a mediocre title, especially if they are already paying service fee’s for Internet and Xbox Live to play their games.
50
Totally Gaming Network
Disappointing combat, and graphics aside, there is still a good game that's dying to get out from under the rusty shell that is Phantasy Star Universe. The has been beautifully presented, with some fantastically space-age music, and the characters, environments and humour all ooze Sega – its just a shame that they've oversimplified the mechanics so much, and ended up breaking a great game in the process. A decent story, accompanied by some brilliant scripting and a fantastic soundtrack prevent this game from being a complete washout, but in the end, we can only recommend it if you can put up with the monotonous combat.
50
PlayDevil
I'm not saying the game is worthless, but it is a sore letdown, and could have been so much more. Substandard graphics and AI will no longer cut it in a world where MMOs are no longer a novelty. And considering you can play the Beta for free and get just as much as you can out of the game as if you pay, that aspect of the game really cannot be recommended. So then back to the single player, which tells a good story, but is so repetitive you might not bother seeing through the twenty hour quest. If you must play an MMO on your 360, this is probably a better option than Final Fantasy XI, but you might as well just keep playing the demo online. Thus, it is pretty hard to recommend Phantasy Star Universe to you all.
40
Jeuxvideo.com
Bref, si le online constitue le "point fort" de Phantasy Star Universe, c'est loin d'être la panacée pour un ennui qui semble nous guetter à chaque connexion. De plus, il faut savoir qu'en parallèle de votre abonnement Internet, vous devrez acheter une licence de Guardian (pour un prix de 9.99 euros par mois), qui expirera si vous n'y jouez pas pendant trois mois. Non vraiment, chapeau Sega ! En somme, la meilleure solution dans le cas présent est d'éteindre notre modem, de ranger le jeu dans sa boîte et d'attendre patiemment les prochaines productions de Mistwalker.
40
FZ
Phantasy Star Universe gör mig oerhört kluven. Å ena sidan är det ett gediget genomarbetat spel, med bra kontroller och en hyfsad story som blir bättre för varje spelad timme. Å andra sidan är PSU ett spel med stenåldersgrafik och långa, tråkiga dialoger. Det här känns mer som en förlegad expansion än en innovativ kreation för next-gen-åldern. Vem vill förresten betala dryga hundra kronor i månaden för något som var innovativt för sex år sedan?