The Elder Scrolls III: Morrowind

The Good
First things first: I loved Arena. I loved Daggerfall. And I tried so hard to love this game, but I failed. The best things about this game is its story and its world, that's basically a continuation of the first Elder Scrolls games. Other than that, there's not much to like about this game. I will explain why.

The Bad
Morrowind is a huge game. It is huge and extremely open ended. Now both these descriptions are usually used to point out the good things about a game. But not this time! Morrowind manages to make both huge and open ended be bad things. The game is so huge the developers ran out of juice after, like, the first village. The rest of the game is bland, generic and colourless. Also, since there's no speech and no real physics system, the game feels horribly dead. The npc's are even worse. No matter who you talk to in the entire game, they always say the same things! If you would talk to a child (there are no children in Morrowind by the way!) you'd get exactly the same, detailed descriptions about the world as if you were talking to the village elder. Everyone, and I mean everyone, seems to know everything about everything.

For some reason this game is well known for its graphics. The same graphics that look bland and yet drives even the meanest gaming computers to its knees. The viewing distance is short and the human models look like.. monsters. Oh, right. The monsters. Take a stroll through the wonderfully repetitive landscape of Morrowind and within ten minutes you will have fought at least ten flying lizard birds. And so it goes on and on and on. Should I mention the equipment? It's incredibly easy to get hold of and since the economic system doesn't work, it's unsellable. You start at level 1 in the game. 20 minutes later you'll be level 10. Around three hours later you'll be level 20 and have most attributes and equipment maxxed out. And if you don't want to wait that long there are trainers that can train you to max in every skill in the game. Practical? Yes. Fun? NO.

A bad game can still be saved by a strong story and fun quests. Does Morrowind have any of these? Unfortunately, no. Most side quests consist of you getting item X to character Y and as a reward you get the useless item Z. Repeat forever, since there are lots and lots of these quests in the game. Due to its open endedness the game feels totally unfocused and there's nothing to drag you into the story. After about an hour of playing you will have forgotten what the hell you're even doing in the game world. And after you've completed the game you'll be feeling confused, empty and disappointed because you will still not have grasped why you did everything you did.

And on top of all of this, the game is way too easy, it has lots of show stopping bugs, suffers from minimal dungeons and it isn't even true to the world set up by the previous games.

The Bottom Line
After buying and playing Daggerfall in the mid nineties I was eagerly awaiting Morrowind as soon as I first heard of it. It took the game five years to arrive (I think) and when it came out it turned out to be this. I don't think I have ever been so disappointed in my entire life when it comes to a computer game. Fortunately for me I found the excellent Gothic game series instead.

The Good
One of the greatest things about this game is it's completely open-ended. The game starts out on a prison ship, and soon you are released on Vvardenfell, an Island in Morrowind. From there you can choose to follow the main quest and fulfill ancient prophesies, join one of the guilds and rise through their ranks, or just explore the huge island. You can stop and start any of these things at almost any time in the game. Those are just a few examples of how open-ended this game is. Another great quality this game has is the graphics. The detail and quality of each individual object in the game is astounding. This game will probably give you 100+ hours of game time, if not, more.

The Bad
This game has few flaws, but they're just enough to piss you off. For an example, lets say you've gotten nearly to the top rank of a guild, you may have to make a choice, to stay at the Master rank of the guild forever or try to become a Magister and then the Archmagister which are higher ranks than Master. Seems simple to make the choice right? Well your boss "forgets" to give you the choice and you automatically get stuck at the Master rank forever. Glitches like this will pop up ever so often in the game. Of course you can get a patch for most bugs and glitches in the PC version, but obviously not for the xbox. Sometimes there are ways to avoid these problems but most people don't figure that out untill it's too late. The glitches in the game, avoidable or not, are too big a problem than we hoped fore.

The Bottom Line
This game is a must get for open ended RPG fans. And luckly, the new Elder Scrolls III: Morrowind Game of The Year Adition, that will be coming out very soon, will fix many of the previously stated glitches and bugs in the game. It will also include the expansions, Tribunal and Bloodmoon, which are also must gets for RPG fans. All and all, this is an amazing game that will keep surprising you when you think you've seen it all. This is my favorite game.

The Good
The world is huge and beautiful. In fact its so big you often get lost, but to your pleasant surpise in the middle of nowhere you find ruins, tombs, or people. Speaking of the people there are over 1,000 NPCs you can interact with in the world. over 20 cities to go to, many books to find for pre-story and more story for those people who like RPG's a lot. Plus 13 factions to join and do missions for, 10 races to choose from, over 21 preset professions or create your own! The possibilities in this game are limitless and although you might feel like "what do I do now?" when you first start because there is no guided main mission. There does exist a main mission which happens to be the hardest in the game, as well as 1,300 other missions to do. So clearly you can see that the team has worked really hard on this game. Most impressively in all the text you come upon in the game, I haven't found one typo.

The Bad
Travelling in the game can get kind of cumbersome because the means of transport are limited (silt riders, mages guild, spells, game addons) unless you want to walk. Because the world is so huge, you kinda wish you had a horse but that would mess up the whole game for many reasons. The huge city of Vivec is too huge in my opinion, I've gotten sick of walking up and around the huge buildings, but the rewards of what's inside the buildings almost outweigh the walking distances. The journal and map could be better, but that is fixed in the expansion packs.

The Bottom Line
This is a great RPG, if you like RPG's you'll love this. If you don't "like" RPG's you'll like this game. It's worth just to look at even the sky is beautiful.