Join our Discord to chat with fellow friendly gamers and our knowledgeable contributors!

Written by  :  MurlocQ (20)
Written on  :  Sep 17, 2009
Rating  :  1 Stars1 Stars1 Stars1 Stars1 Stars

1 out of 27 people found this review helpful

write a review of this game
read more reviews by MurlocQ
read more reviews for this game


The worst space simulation-shooter ever made!

The Good

Before I begin my review I wish to tell that I played with the Kilrathi’s Saga version, but during it, I tried the original DOS version too. Well, the good thing its genre and atmosphere. It is a science-fiction game filled with action. It has a long story with so many characters from the first part and from its extends. And I think that is all the good about the game one can tell.

The Bad

Ah yes. Let's begin on the whole world of the game, I mean its engine.

I don't know who was that genius, who invented that, such a game must be in a 2D world. For there are other games like: Elite I-II, the Mercenary trilogy, or the Epic were already 3D games in those times. They were using polygons instead of sprites in the early '90s. And due to the 2D sometimes one cannot feel, see when he or she is going to avoid (or collide) for example (with) a carrier.

Let us continue with the Controls. Now in the Original DOS version you could fly easily with keyboard or joystick. In the Saga version these controls are almost useless. The keyboard is too slow, because its speed in the beginning is zero, and it’s need time to accelerate to a good speed, but if you stop holding any of the direction keys it's starts over again from 0. And the game detects any joysticks as digital. So if you push it any of the directions the ship begin to move instantly in that way's maximum point; and finally the mouse. So one need to get used to it, but if you already know the way, there is not much trouble with it.

Now let's see the dashboard! It's very detailed and good-looking, but you can't see out of it. For the whole dashboard covers your vision. And that's true for all four directions. In the Kilrathi's Saga version one can turn it off with the function keys, but in the original you need to fly blindly. And that can be really infuriating, when you can't see the enemy shooting at you, because the panel conceals him. Oh, there are the communication videos! They can sabotage your mission because while they are active you have to press the ‘c’ key several times, and always in the moment when it is crucial to give an order to your wingman. I know it can be turned off, but without them I think the game loses some of its value.

And here are the flight controls! I know I've already mentioned those, but here I mean to those keys, which can only be used on the keyboard. Like the throttle controls. Sometimes you need to hit these several times. And I'm meaning the word 'hit' in its literal sense. For example you took off from the carrier, and there are enemies right in the zone. You wish to be fast and agile, and not to be a sitting duck. So you need to hit the maximum speed button. Once I counted how many times I needed to hit that key. The result was FIVE TIMES!! And the game sometimes playing this with you with the enter key, which releases the missiles and torpedoes. And if I remember well, somewhere the manual mentions the same bug, and counseling that to hit the keys several times, or push them like a deaf the doorbell.

If I mentioned torpedoes, let us talk about them. If you targeted the enemy outpost, base or spacecraft with it, you need to lock on to it. After that a crosshair begins to move toward to its brackets. It approximately takes 20 second according to the game manual, but sometimes it took more than that. And it can be very disappointing such a situation like when you kill all the fighters then move out of your target’s range, and stop in the space to wait this ritual. Then charge at your target, because the torpedoes can be shot down. That means the enemy can shoot it down always if you’re not close enough to your target.

The weapon system is very good thing. Because it’s always running out of energy when you in need of it the most. Sometimes it happens that you can’t destroy your enemy, even if you flying against each other in head to head. But of course, he can destroy you, and fire whenever he wants. The other thing with the system is the auto aim. Sometimes it just turns on and you need to correct is aiming because you shooting AT the target and not before it, so you obviously can’t hit it.

The enemy and ally intelligence are equally wrong. The enemy breaks in front of you, when you are at full speed. Ergo he kills you and himself. Or sometimes he rams you, or simply flies in to you, destroying your shields, armour and himself. Your allies are so desperate that, if you coincidentally attack the same target as your wingman, and you get crossed his shot, he won’t stop shooting at you, until you kill your target or leave that Kilrathi.

The fighters that you are using during the game are really annoying ones. For example the Épée. It’s so fast that you can’t control it. You collide with someone or you need to slow down, but it’s still very sensitive. Now the ‘best’ fighter called Sabre (the designers surely adored the different cold steels, because all the fighters have such name except the ferret.) is really fast and agile but in opposition with the opinion of the fellow wingmen and officers its armour and shield are very weak. Oh, and by the way there is another infuriating thing in the game: the tractor beam. Only two ships have such beam. And can be only used and accessed it from the turrets. Yes, those two fighters have turrets; I think to remind you to a flying fortress or something like that. Now the funny thing if you wish to tractor the object in the space it is necessary to perform a complete stop. And here comes the situation that brings the raging beast out from you: if you stop and switch to the turret to use the beam, sometimes, no, mostly the ship begins to move, usually on half speed. So you are trying to acquire something, but you are constantly leaving it. So you need to go back to the pilot position manoeuver to the object and begin the whole process from the start. But you need to be fast or the ship begins to move again.

And there are the scripted missions. When you can’t destroy a ship with all your torpedoes for the creators of the game thought the mission’s solution in another way. Or a certain type of enemy fighters begins to move, fight and shoot accurately like aces. Albeit before they couldn’t even hit you, for your ship was too fast for them.

Next to the last thing are the asteroids. These objects are usually seemed sometimes like grey brains. These rocks look like they have consciousness, because there are some which can’t be avoided. And there is a moment in the story where your carrier needs to hide in an asteroid field. The first time you take off in the field it begins so that a rock is flying toward you at high speed, and if you’re not ready or swift enough it destroys your shield and the front armour of the ship. The best thing was that when I flew the last mission, and an asteroid destroyed just that device on my ship that is needed for the torpedoes.

The Bottom Line

Finally I think the whole game is a great crap with its bugs, and advantages too. The mission disks are not worthy enough to play with it either, unless you wish to end up in a sanitarium. I can only recommend that if you want to start the wing commander series then start with the third part or the Armada. At least they’re already 3D, and not a maddening piece of sh…