Join our Discord to chat with fellow friendly gamers and our knowledgeable contributors!

User Reviews

The apex of the series and the only one worth playing. AkibaTechno (254) 3.83 Stars3.83 Stars3.83 Stars3.83 Stars3.83 Stars
A sequel as a sequel should be. Classic! Rensch (218) 4.33 Stars4.33 Stars4.33 Stars4.33 Stars4.33 Stars
An awesome sequel to the original Pokemon Game Paks. pocketgamer2000 (22) 4.17 Stars4.17 Stars4.17 Stars4.17 Stars4.17 Stars
Certainly one of the best games of all time... Jim Fun (243) 4.83 Stars4.83 Stars4.83 Stars4.83 Stars4.83 Stars

Our Users Say

Category Description User Score
AI How smart (or dumb) you perceive the game's artificial intelligence to be 3.6
Gameplay How well the game mechanics work (player controls, game action, interface, etc.) 4.3
Graphics The quality of the art, or the quality/speed of the drawing routines 3.9
Personal Slant How much you personally like the game, regardless of other attributes 4.2
Sound / Music The quality of the sound effects and/or music composition 3.9
Story / Presentation The main creative ideas in the game and how well they're executed
(required for every game entry that isn't a compilation)
4.0
Overall User Score (48 votes) 4.0


Critic Reviews

MobyRanks are listed below. You can read here for more information about MobyRank.
100
Video Games (Dec, 2000)
Fazit: Größer, dicker, satter, lecker! Pokémon Gold und Silber übertrumpfen ihre Vorgänger in jeder Hinsicht und sind für alle Poké-Fans ein absoluter Pflichtkauf.
100
Pixel-Heroes.de (Dec 05, 2010)
Ich liebe dieses Spiel - damals im großen Pokémon-Hype freute ich mich besonders auf das Spiel. Als ich es endlich in die Finger bekam, war ich sofort wieder von der Pokémon-Welt fasziniert, was auch lange anhalten sollte. "Pokémon Gold" ist bis heute eines meiner Lieblingsspiele und ich vergebe - rein subjektiv wie immer - zehn von zehn möglichen Punkten. Wer das Original nicht mehr spielen möchte, der sollte zum Remake greifen. Man wird es ganz sicher nicht bereuen.
100
IGN (Oct 16, 2000)
Pokémon Gold and Silver are going to be the top-selling games on the Game Boy Color system, regardless of what this review says. Pokémon is not a fad, it's here to stay, and this new Game Boy Color series is only going to fuel the blaze of popularity further.
100
Edutaining Kids (Jun, 2001)
Our 10 year old tester has invested more time in this game than any of his other video games combined -- which can be considered either good or bad -- or a little of both -- depending on your point of view. Left on his own, for example, it definitely cuts into reading time. Certainly, in terms of entertainment value, he has received more than his money's worth. Players are required to read text to a fair degree, and use their brains through strategy and memory skills. Though not particularly difficult to play, the game is detailed, deep, and entirely engrossing.
98
Gold and Silver are extremely enjoyable and not difficult to learn how to play. The skill comes in being able to fully develop the Pokémon that you catch to defeat all your opponents. I highly recommend this game for the young and old alike.
96
Gaming Target (Nov 03, 2000)
Pokemon Gold owners will become addicted to the unraveling gameplay that gets better every time you play it with interesting puzzles and a decent story line that’s not overly linear for a Game Boy game. I’d like to see a sequel on the Game Boy Advance done right one day, though. Pokemon Crystal will be tedious like Pokemon Yellow was, so I’d like to see the inevitable Pokemon Advance make use of the GBA's superior audio hardware and of course visual power. Until then, Pokemon Gold, exactly like Silver, is a must-buy for any Pokemon freak out there.
95
Link-Cable (Jun 12, 2017)
“Pokémon (Gold/Silver) was an experience like no other. It brought the Pokémon franchise to a new level with its massive world to explore, new Gyms, Pokémon and even deeper lore that had players playing for hours on end.”
90
Den enda bristen jag hittar i Pokémon Gold och Silver är det fakum att spelandet ibland blir lite enformigt. Städerna ser nästan alltid likadana ut och tycker man inet att det är jättekul att samla monster finns det bättre bärbara rollspel. Man ska dock ha i åtanke att spelet i första hand riktar sig till barn. Barn som älskar Pokémon. Och gillar man Pokémon vill man bara inte vara utan det här spelet.
90
Power Unlimited (Apr, 2001)
Uitmelken? Ja, maar dan wel met twee prachtige titels, volgestouwd met nieuwe features, nieuwe levels en natuurlijk nieuwe Pokémon! Allebei absolute must-haves voor de Pokémon-fan.
80
Jeuxvideo.com (Apr 02, 2001)
Difficile de comprendre l'engouement pour les titres Pokemon si l'on n'a pas soi-même pris la peine de tenter l'aventure. Pokémon est un titre addictif qui passionne tous ceux qui s'y adonnent quelques minutes et pas seulement les enfants. Les versions Or et Argent prolongent l'aventure avec un nouveau continent, de nouveaux défis, et des Pokemon inédits. Un titre qui mérite amplement son succès et qui convient parfaitement au support Gameboy.
75
Electric Playground (Nov 14, 2000)
However, for those gamers willing to accept the fact that they will probably miss out on over half the Pokemon in the game, Pokemon Gold provides entertaining, if not challenging, gameplay that should satisfy Poke-fans until Nintendo comes up with something new for the world of Pokemon.
70
Legendra (Oct 21, 2007)
Un jeu quasiment identique à l'autre version... Une fois de plus, deux jeux sortent, mais les avantages sont très limités. Posséder les deux versions n' attirera que les Pokémaniak, et ne présentera aucun intérêt pour les autres...
60
Gamekult (Apr 02, 2001)
Une nouvelle aventure, des graphismes largement améliorés, de nouveaux Pokémon, de nouvelles options de jeu (parfois douteuses, comme les bestioles diurnes et nocturnes), un monde plus grand n'empêchent pas Pokémon Or et Argent de franchement se distinguer des précédentes versions. Les jeunes pokémaniaques vont évidemment adorer, les nouveaux venus seront certainement séduits, mais les autres risquent de trouver cette nouvelle fournée un peu abusive. Reste que si on se laisse happer par ces nouveaux Pokémon, et malgré toutes les critiques qu'on peut y porter (matraquage, merchandising outrancier et tutti quanti, on a de fortes chances d'y rester plongé des heures durant avec plaisir, sans pour autant devenir complètement "pokédépendant", comme d'aucuns l'affirment. Et dire qu'après, il y a Pokémon Crystal...