Fallout: Brotherhood of Steel Reviews (PlayStation 2)
|The Rosemary Kennedy of the Fallout family.||Terrence Bosky (5463)|
|Fallout has turned into Diablo.||Horny-Bullant (59)|
Our Users Say
|Acting||The quality of the actors' performances in the game (including voice acting).||2.0|
|AI||How smart (or dumb) you perceive the game's artificial intelligence to be||1.8|
|Gameplay||How well the game mechanics work (player controls, game action, interface, etc.)||1.9|
|Graphics||The quality of the art, or the quality/speed of the drawing routines||2.2|
|Personal Slant||How much you personally like the game, regardless of other attributes||1.8|
|Sound / Music||The quality of the sound effects and/or music composition||2.1|
|Story / Presentation||The main creative ideas in the game and how well they're executed
(required for every game entry that isn't a compilation or special edition)
|Overall User Score (18 votes)||1.9|
Critic ReviewsMobyRanks are listed below. You can read here for more information about MobyRank.
Gamesmania.de (Apr 20, 2004)
Fallout: Brotherhood Of Steel spielt sich im Prinzip wie die beiden Dark Alliance-Titel, nur das Szenario ist düsterer und abgedrehter. Statt Fantasywesen begegnet man Prostituierten, schleimigen Bürgermeistern sowie vor sich hin rottenden Zombies und lässt Gesocks wie Banditen, Mutanten und Roboter über die Klinge springen. Allein schon wegen der beachtlichen Waffenvielfalt ist der Suchtfaktor enorm hoch. Fans des Genres können somit bedenkenlos zugreifen.
Game Over Online (Jan 14, 2004)
As I said at the start of this review, I made this list of mistakes over the course of eight hours of playtime that felt like an hour, so Brotherhood of Steel is by no means a failure. It's just got some weird quirks to it that I can't understand, since this other game over here that's a lot like it doesn't have the same issues. Brotherhood of Steel is fun enough, but with just a few tweaks and refinements to the gameplay, this would've been a truly great game.
GamePro (US) (Feb 03, 2004)
Based on Black Isle Studios' 1997 PC game set in a postapocalyptic milieu that can only have been ripped from the tortured brain of the most feverish Cold War paranoiac is this role-playing/action/adventure crossover. Using Snowblind's Baldur?s Gate: Dark Alliance engine as a template, Fallout: Brotherhood of Steel has you skulking around smoldering city ruins, contending with genetically mutated ghouls (and really big mice), and conversing with cripples, prostitutes, and two-headed cattle while searching for members of the Brotherhood of Steel, self-appointed guardians of the wastelands.
Fragland.net (May 03, 2004)
What if? What if the world you live in suddenly underwent a nuclear holocaust? In a few days time thousands of cities are wiped out, and half of the world population is exterminated. The ones that do survive start mutating or turn into rotting ghouls. Impossible you say? Play Fallout: Brotherhood of Steel and see for yourself!
IGN (Jan 13, 2004)
As 2003 wound to a close, Interplay axed its Black Isle division due to financial difficulties. Presumably, this puts an end to Fallout 3, a PC title that had been in development and was to follow up the popular Fallout and Fallout 2 that had come out in 1997 and 1998, respectively. Keeping their focus on the console market, Interplay is instead continuing to come out with Fallout: Brotherhood of Steel, an action title with some RPG elements that was developed by Interplay and takes place in the Fallout universe. What then takes place is a classic hackfest that's set in a post-apocalyptic world. While it won't make you think too much, it's got enough action for a Saturday afternoon.
GameSpot (Jan 09, 2004)
Fallout: Brotherhood of Steel isn't a great game, but it can still be entertaining to play. The action is repetitive and straightforward, but the game features a lot of cool weapons and tons of stuff to hack or shoot at, plus it's got some of the charm that helped make Fallout a genuine classic. Brotherhood of Steel is no substitute for a true Fallout sequel, but it doesn't aim to be one. So, if you're looking for a hack-and-slash game that you can unwind with, but you're a bit weary of how they all take place in fantasy-themed settings, then Fallout: Brotherhood of Steel should do you good.
Legendra (Nov 16, 2009)
Fallout: Brotherhood of Steel est un bon défouloir, l'univers reste dans la lignée des précédents épisodes, même si le scénario est un cran en dessous, non pas qu'il soit inintéressant, mais dans ce genre de jeu il n'est pas assez exploité, et donc pas assez visible et détaillé. Reste donc un gameplay sympa, le mode coop, et une bonne maniabilité. Ce jeu a été pas mal critiqué tout comme Fallout Tactics car il tranchait avec les deux premiers Fallout de par son genre. Je trouve que ça reste un jeu intéressant qui peut ouvrir l'univers de Fallout à tout ceux qui ne sont pas passionnés par les combats au tour par tour et les tonnes de dialogues.
Jeuxvideo.com (Apr 16, 2004)
Un peu moins profond que Baldur's Gate : Dark Alliance, Fallout : Brotherhood Of Steel n'en est pas moins un bon hack and slash qui a pour lui un intéressant background apocalyptique. Ca nous changera de l'heroic fantasy, tiens !
GameZone (Mar 24, 2004)
When it was released on the PC back in 1998, Fallout offered up a great blend of futuristic storyline and Dungeons and Dragons inspired gameplay set in a rich RPG universe. The series went on to gain critical acclaim and set the mood for the release of the Baldur’s Gate series and it’s subsequent sequels and emulators. Now, Fallout is finally hitting consoles in the same vein as the Baldur’s Gate series with Fallout: Brotherhood of Steel. The gameplay is pretty much pulled straight from the Dark Alliance games, warts and all. The action RPG elements have been largely untouched, as have the repetitive missions and situations. However, the rich and deep Fallout universe is all here. For fans of the series, the game should provide a fun, if brief experience.
Next Level Gaming (Jan 16, 2004)
The United Nations failed in 2052 as the planet's natural resources dried up, causing many smaller nations to go financially bankrupt and fail. Europe and the Middle East were cast into a long, drawn-out war over the few remaining productive oil fields. As war moved its way through the rest of the world, in the winter of 2066 China attacked Alaska over what were most likely the last drops of oil in the world. The U.S. responded with force, but it would be ten years before the conflict would end. In a desperate maneuver, both superpowers invaded neighboring countries in an effort to bolster their dwindling resources. The U.S. annexation of Canada was concluded by 2076. Canadian timber provided fuel for U.S. military needs, and Alaska was reclaimed by early 2077.
RPGFan (May 12, 2011)
Brotherhood of Steel is an awful game and an insult to the Fallout series.
GamerDad (Mar 28, 2004)
Black Isle's Fallout RPG is a bona fide classic, and the post-apocalyptic game world used for that game series is one that's sorely missed by plenty of gamers. While some of them would prefer another straight up RPG set in that world, most will be content with Brotherhood of Steel, a co-operative beat ‘em up action RPG that bears more than a passing resemblance to fan favorite Baldur's Gate: Dark Alliance.
GameSpy (Jan 12, 2004)
Fallout: Brotherhood of Steel is a competent and occasionally compelling hack-and-slash, but fans of the PC games won't give a damn about it, and Champions of Norrath is a more satisfying and more technically impressive example of the genre on the PlayStation 2.
The Game Hoard (Nov 19, 2018)
While a general lack of world-building and the shift away from strategic turn-based combat may make Fallout: Brotherhood of Steel almost heretical to Fallout fans, the odd truth of the title is that its shift towards accessible hack and slash action coupled with light RPG elements does hit the marks the developers were aiming for. It’s not too hard for players to attach themselves to the mindless mayhem of shooting apart enemies in a raunchy post-apocalyptic wasteland, but the design decisions made for broader appeal are still felt strongly. The story and world are barebones and have little to get invested in, so the combat has to carry the weigh despite its simple design. Loot, level progression, and seeing new areas are small rewards for pushing through similar groups of enemies without too much difficult opposition, with most enjoyment in the game coming from tapping into primal reward systems rather than hooking players with inspired design.
4Players.de (May 08, 2004)
Wenn man zwei viel versprechende Lizenzen (Fallout und Baldur´s Gate Dark Alliance) verbindet, ergibt das nicht automatisch ein gutes Spiel. Abgesehen davon, dass die Echtzeitkämpfe allem widersprechen, was die PC-Spieler von der Fallout-Serie kennen – nämlich anspruchsvolle Taktik, wurden die mit Spielen wie der BGDA-Serie und Champions of Norrath eingeführten, hochmotivierenden Gameplay-Mechanismen bei der stählernen Bruderschaft weitestgehend in den Sand gesetzt. Was nützen mir eine gute Steuerung und einigermaßen spannende Kämpfe gegen die Allerweltsmonster, die sich in den Abschnitten verbergen, wenn sich die Bosskämpfe einfach nur uninspiriert und bar jeglicher Spannung zeigen und dazu noch viel zu einfach zu bewältigen sind? Die sechs spielbaren Charaktere sind zudem noch mit viel zu wenigen Unterschieden ausgestattet, als dass sich ein nochmaliges Durchspielen lohnen würde. Und zu alledem bleibt Brotherhood of Steel technisch weit hinter den Fantasy-Kollegen zurück.
DreamStation.cc (Jul 29, 2004)
Fallout: Brotherhood of Steel suffers from some basic timing issues and dumb AI. The enemies just keep coming one after another and you keep mowing them down. There is really nothing that sets Fallout: Brotherhood of Steel apart from the rest of the games that are out like it. As a matter of fact there are better games out there. I think they could use a lot less profane language and crudeness and better game play and smarter AI. Rental only! Maybe!
Jeuxvideo.fr (Apr 23, 2004)
Alors que la série des Baldur´s Gate était une vraie réussite, on ne peut pas dire que Fallout soit de la même trempe. La violence gratuite ne peut être la qualité première d´un jeu, il faut autre chose : une ambiance, de l´originalité. Or Fallout n´est rien de plus qu´un titre bourrin qui tombera immédiatement dans les limbes de la nullité. Je terminerai donc par cette phrase mythique sortie tout droit d´un western de John Wayne : "ce n´est pas une balle dans le coude qui va me faire plier du genou". A méditer.
Eurogamer.net (UK) (Apr 08, 2004)
Brotherhood Of Steel is to Fallout what Dark Alliance is to Baldur's Gate - or at least that appeared to be Interplay's intention when it commissioned a "gritty and darkly humorous" (their words not ours...) third-person action-adventure take on its successful PC-derived RPG series from the late 90s. While DA and its recently released sequel are largely entertaining action-adventure approximations with a smattering of RPG, BOS (as it shall be referred to from now on) isn't far off being a travesty for those who enjoyed the post apocalyptic series a few years back.