Join our Discord to chat with fellow friendly gamers and our knowledgeable contributors!


User Reviews

There are no reviews for the PlayStation 2 release of this game. You can use the links below to write your own review or read reviews for the other platforms of this game.

Our Users Say

Category Description User Score
Acting The quality of the voice or video acting. 3.8
AI The quality of the game's intelligence, usually for the behavior of opponents. 3.4
Gameplay How well the game mechanics work and the game plays. 3.1
Graphics The visual quality of the game 3.9
Personal Slant A personal rating of the game, regardless of other attributes 3.6
Sound / Music The quality of the sound effects and/or music composition 3.6
Story / Presentation The main creative ideas in the game and how well they are executed. This rating is used for every game except compilations and special editions which don't have unique game content not available in a standalone game or DLC. 3.4
Overall User Score (14 votes) 3.6

Critic Reviews

MobyRanks are listed below. You can read here for more information about MobyRank.
It still has a ways to go to catch GTA, but with this finely crafted sequel Luxoflux has raised this series up from another me-too title to a necessity for fans of this genre.
IGN (Nov 16, 2005)
The original True Crime: Streets of L.A. was something of an ambitious game. It managed to pull off some of this ambition quite well, like almost perfectly mapping the layout of the entirety of Los Angeles for you to drive through, but some other aspects that may have sounded good on paper didn't quite come through in the end. The gunplay was a little wonky to use, the hand-to-hand combat was decent but didn't control all that well, the move upgrades were cool but rather annoying to obtain, and the game's characters honestly weren't nearly as intriguing as others in competing titles.
GameZone (Dec 08, 2005)
The game begins in blood and bruises. Drenched in remnants of dead criminals, Marcus Reed heads for an apartment building. The player is unaware that, within less than three minutes, he will bust into a dangerous situation, whip out his weapons and expect the one holding the controller to save the day. This is not a game of heroic actions and happy endings -- only one man will leave the building alive. The rest will leave in body bags. The one still standing might as well be Marcus.
Video Game Generation (Jan 21, 2006)
The game will of course appeal to you if you just can't get enough of this kind of game: if you're so big a fan of sandbox-type games that you will jump on anything even remotely like one, then by all means grab this because it's for you. But if you want something fresh, something consistent or something that shows what life is really like in New York City, you should probably keep walking.
65 (Nov 29, 2005)
New York City est plus beau et plus profond que True Crime, les nouveautés sont légion mais de très nombreux bugs et autres soucis techniques (absents de l'épisode précédent) nous empêchent de nous éclater pleinement. Malgré tout, le titre de Luxoflux témoigne de l'énorme travail réalisé par les développeurs et on croisera les doigts pour avoir droit à un troisième opus qui gommerait toutes les imperfections de cet épisode tout en se voulant aussi ambitieux. True Crime a les atouts pour concurrencer GTA, il suffit juste d'attendre encore un peu pour avoir droit à l'épisode sachant combiner gameplay irréprochable et profondeur ludique.
UOL Jogos (Dec 19, 2005)
"True Crime: New York City" seria bastante satisfatório não fossem as missões tão repetitivas e a velocidade do game tão baixa, sem contar os notórios erros de programação. A "parte veicular" ficou prejudicada pela estranha dirigibilidade e simulação de física, mas o título ainda tem atrativos como um mapa sedutor e um sistema de jogo robusto, principalmente nos combates. Infelizmente, os acertos não são suficientes para apagar a impressão de um título que parece ser menos cuidadoso que o antecessor.
PSX Extreme (Jan 31, 2006)
So, True Crime: New York really is a menagerie of all the elements of bad game design. It takes many more steps backwards than it does forwards, and awkward (even game-stopping) bugs will frustrate you if the embedded elements don't. Every attempt it seems to make at emulating the good games in the free-roaming genre (side missions like fighting arenas or underground racing leagues) just seem totally inconsequential to its core (albeit a rotten one). True Crime: New York is neither compelling nor fun and even its $30 price tag doesn't make it worth your money.
1UP (Nov 16, 2005)
At this year's Digital Life, Ziff Davis Media's conglomeration of games, gadgets, and technology, Redman -- rap superstar extraordinaire -- vaunted about the upcoming True Crime: New York City, and cited that it was "...on fi-yah" and "all the graphics...that sh*t is wow, bananas." Redman, who has a small yet pivotal role in the game, is merely hyping his merchandise, of course, but it's easy to be skeptical of his used-car salesman tactics; in fact, TC: NYC does not represent the embellished painted image that he meticulously depicts.
59 (Dec 24, 2005)
Ich habe noch nie ein so detailliertes, lebendiges und atmosphärisch umgesetztes Manhattan gesehen. Auch die Story, die euch in den Big Apple entführt, macht mit einem furiosen Auftakt und namhaften Charaktermimen Lust auf mehr. Doch schon bald beginnt die Fassade zu bröckeln: Die Handlung, sofern sie nicht schon durch fahrlässige Programmierung unwiderruflich stecken geblieben ist, wiederholt sich immer und immer wieder, nur mit anderen Gesichtern und Schauplätzen. Auch die Dinge abseits der Storyline entpuppen sich bald als ewige Wiederkehr des Gleichen. Zudem sorgen technische Unzulänglichkeiten und Schlampereien regelmäßig für ungläubiges Staunen, Ärgernis und Frust.
PlayFrance (Dec 20, 2005)
Activision ne réussira pas encore cette fois-ci à détrôner le maître GTA bien installé dans sa position de leader. Malgré des graphismes léchés, une ambiance sympa, une bande-son très correcte et une durée de vie plus qu'acceptable, True Crime New York City est le leader des bugs en tout genre et de l'IA la plus succincte en termes d'esprit. Certes, le jeu n'est pas mauvais en tout point mais il reste médiocre dans l'esthétique et aurait mérité de vraies phases de test pour atteindre un niveau tout à fait dans la mesure des productions de Rockstar. J'espère tout de même que les idées de Luxoflux seront conservées car ils seront mis en valeur avec les possibilités des consoles nouvelle génération. Un jeu a acheter en occaz ou à jouer chez un pote.
GamePro (US) (Nov 29, 2005)
The notion of playing a fledgeling detective in New York City is alluring, whether your fantasies entail justice or brutality. As Marcus Reed, a young man with an incarcerated father, a checkered past, and a gold shield, the Big Apple is your oyster.
GameSpy (Nov 28, 2005)
Complete with more bugs than month-old flypaper sitting outside a slaughterhouse, True Crime: New York City is utterly mediocre. Sure, it's got its moments, such as exciting and twitchy shoot-out action, but the on-the-street combat is as broken as the last title, driving is a nightmare, the graphics are drab, the framerate chugs, and the overall experience is just plain bad. Unfortunately, there are going to be lots of unwitting beta testers out there this Holiday season who will buy this game in spite of the bugs. Don't be one of those people who makes that expensive mistake.
The original True Crime was a respectable stab at the free-roaming action genre pretty much created by Grand Theft Auto, despite its bizarre, Big Trouble in Little China story twist (though who doesn't love flaming demon skulls mixed in with their police drama?) and occasional glitch. And now we have True Crime: New York City, which takes the same formula, adds a bunch of new features, and goes all urban culture on your ass. Again, the game is a respectable stab at the genre GTA built, but one so rife with bugs that it's really hard to appreciate what it offers.
GameSpot (Nov 23, 2005)
True Crime: New York City should be avoided regardless of whether or not you enjoyed the first True Crime. The gameplay has a few almost-decent spots, but the technical problems far outweigh any faint hope this game ever had of being enjoyable. If you're curious about what a video game looks like before it goes through adequate testing and quality assurance, then by all means give this one a try. Otherwise, stay away, because it's a waste of your time and money.
JeuxActu (Nov 28, 2005)
Fort de sa première expérience avec True Crime : Streets of LA, Luxoflux avait le potentiel et l'ambition pour espérer marcher aux côtés de GTA. Malheureusement, il semblerait que le développement ait été quelque peu écourté, laissant derrière lui un goût fort amer. On tire la langue comme le frame-rate de True Crime : New York City tire la tronche. On enchaîne les missions sans vraiment s'amuser et les nombreux bugs (qu'on pardonne pourtant à GTA) viennent mettre un terme à l'envie d'aller plus loin. Peut-être pour la prochaine fois...
New York City, once a rat-infested cesspool of punk rock and peep shows, is now well on its way to becoming Disneyland for urban-curious suburbanites. I prefer the NYC put across in old movies and TV shows, the dangerous city where you might get mugged in broad daylight. So the idea of a Grand Theft Auto-style crime game set in real New York (not Liberty City) has serious appeal. With its block-for-block re-creation of the entire island of Manhattan, True Crime: New York City could have been great.
The first True Crime game was a bit raw in a lot of ways, but introduced a lot of interesting concepts to the Grand Theft Auto-style of game. The real-life city, character development, melee combat, and the choice between being a good cop or a bad cop added some aspects that made the game noteworthy in the early part of last year.
Game Revolution (Dec 13, 2005)
You play as Marcus Reed, a tough street cop looking to avenge the killing of his mentor. As Marcus rises up the ranks of the police force, he takes on the crime bosses of a fully-rendered Manhattan, eventually uncovering a giant conspiracy. It's an unbelievable story, just as Marcus is an unbelievable character. In the first scene of the game, you gun down twenty people just to get a slap on the wrist from your detective friend. This derivative tale tries to be gritty, absurd, serious and nutty all at the same time. The only thing it doesn't try to do is suck, but ironically, that's all it manages.