Join our Discord to chat with fellow friendly gamers and our knowledgeable contributors!

User Reviews

Extremly Underrated Game Giacomo (6) 3.71 Stars3.71 Stars3.71 Stars3.71 Stars3.71 Stars

Our Users Say

Category Description User Score
Acting The quality of the actors' performances in the game (including voice acting). 2.9
AI How smart (or dumb) you perceive the game's artificial intelligence to be 2.8
Gameplay How well the game mechanics work (player controls, game action, interface, etc.) 3.2
Graphics The quality of the art, or the quality/speed of the drawing routines 3.3
Personal Slant How much you personally like the game, regardless of other attributes 3.3
Sound / Music The quality of the sound effects and/or music composition 3.2
Story / Presentation The main creative ideas in the game and how well they're executed
(required for every game entry that isn't a compilation or special edition)
3.0
Overall User Score (10 votes) 3.1


Critic Reviews

MobyRanks are listed below. You can read here for more information about MobyRank.
94
Game Chronicles (May 15, 2002)
Pirates: The Legend of Black Kat is a great adventure game and one of only a few currently available for the Xbox. The excellent story, great graphics, inspiring music, and authentic pirate dialect will totally immerse you in this game. The lengthy and sometimes repetitive gameplay is broken up with a variety of quests, exotic locales, and new faces, as you travel the world in search of fame, fortune, revenge, and even love. This is one adventure you can't skip, so don't miss the boat.
92
Consoles Plus (May, 2002)
Comme sur PS2, le jeu est assez joli et de plus en plus captivant au fil de l'aventure toujours aussi longue.
91
The Video Game Critic (Oct 14, 2006)
This Xbox version's graphics are noticeably more polished than the Playstation 2 version, and its crisp audio includes creaking boats hulls, exotic birds, resounding explosions, and a lively musical score. The save and load times are much better in this version as well. Those looking for realism will prefer Sid Meier's Pirates (Xbox, 2005), but gamers looking for non-stop action should check out this underrated adventure.
90
Overall, Pirates: The Legend of Black Kat is fantastically fun. This is not a game that pushes the envelope by any measure, but as adventure games go, this is probably the best one out for the Xbox right now. The combination of graphics, sound, and an easy interface really makes for a lot of fun exploration. Westwood Studios brought all the right pieces together to make a great adventure and seafaring game that I rate at 4.5 GiN Gems.
85
Game Over Online (Jun 14, 2002)
All in all, Black Kat is a solid platform title with a great premise, solid action, and a lot of replay value. With hidden artwork, costumes, and other secrets on top of the ship battle mode and story mode, there’s quite a lot to discover within this title. It also captures the spirit of both the old pirate movies, imparting a sense of heroism and roguishness within the player. Any gamer would be proud to join Kat’s crew or her adventures and bring the evil Captain Hawke to justice. So, matey, set sail fer a merchant, get yourself a copy, and bury it in yer Xbox. Ye won’t regret it.
80
Pirates: The Legend of Black Kat blends solid and fresh gameplay with great graphics and exceptional sound design to create a title that lets you relish life on the high seas. Casting you in the role of Katarina De Leon, you’ll swash and buckle your way through hostile islands populated with voodoo priests, giant apes and scummy pirates, always able to retreat to your ship where you’ll have to deal with broadsides combat and fort assaults. With plenty of ship upgrades, lots of environments to explore and a compelling, if somewhat linear, storyline to follow, The Legend of Black Kat proves to be one of the more seaworthy pirate games to ever sail onto a console.
80
X-Power (Jul 17, 2002)
We hebben in deze review de verschillende elementen van dit spel afzonderlijk bekeken. In het spel lopen ze natuurlijk door mekaar en ik moet zeggen dat dit bijzonder goed werkt. De afwisseling behoedt het spel van verveling en bedekt voor een deel de zwakke punten van elk element afzonderlijk. Ook de sfeer die dit spel uitademt, vond ik een verademing. Tropische stranden, palmbomen, papagaaien,schatkisten en een stralende zon... je waant je op temptation island. De xbox heeft op dit moment te weinig adventure games. Pirates is zeker geen topper maar eerder een middelmatig spel. Toch vond ik het veel beter dan verwacht en Pirates heeft me uiteindelijk vele uren spelplezier opgeleverd. Voor de gamer die een spel wil waar hij eens stevig zijn tanden in kan zetten maar kan leven met de bij momenten repetitieve gameplay en de magere grafieken. Denk er alleen aan : de zomer is nog lang...
80
GameZone (Apr 01, 2002)
This game looks terrific, sounds terrific and plays well. There is action; there is adventure; there is entertainment. Pirates: The Legend of Black Kat has some small quirks, but manages to overcome those and provides a great gameplaying time.
80
GamePro (US) (Apr 29, 2002)
Pirates: The Legend of Black Kat follows the swashbuckling adventures of the aforementioned heroine as she engages in sea battles and treks on foot across mysterious islands to hunt down her father’s killer and to learn a few things about her legendary swashbuckling mother.
78
GameSpot (Apr 04, 2002)
Pirates is, simply put, an endearing and well thought-out game. It's neither extremely innovative, nor technically impressive--rather, it's an especially well-executed example of a fairly common sort of game, and Xbox owners should be happy to see it appear on the platform. Its vast environments, endearing concept, and successful combination of two distinct types of gameplay--the seafaring and the on-foot swashbuckling--make Pirates: The Legend of Black Kat a solid and welcome addition to the 3D action adventure genre in general, one that you'd do well to check out for yourself.
76
4Players.de (May 10, 2002)
Trotz gelungener Freibeuter-Atmosphäre und interessanter Grundideen ist Pirates keine wirkliche Konkurrenz zu Sid Meiers gleichnamiger 8Bit-Legende. Dafür ist der Spielablauf einfach zu monoton und linear. Vor allem die Landausflüge bieten trotz motivierender und auf der Xbox dank verbesserter Rumble-Funktion komfortablerer Schatzsuche wenig Abwechslung - Ausnahme: die taktischen Bosskämpfe. Wasserratten freuen sich hingegen über spektakulär inszenierte und auch spielerisch gehaltvolle Seeschlachten, die man in einem speziellen Spielmodus auch zu zweit erleben darf. Grafisch ist die Xbox-Version dem PS2-Pedant aufgrund realistischerer Wasserdarstellung und detaillierterer Texturen dezent überlegen, ansonsten gleichen sie sich jedoch bis auf das einfachere Aufspüren vergrabener Schätze wie ein Ei dem anderen.
75
The Next Level (Aug 21, 2002)
It may not be the ultimate pirate game, but it's certainly a step in the right direction. The game lags at points, but the moments where it shines are worth waiting for. Hopefully this is just the beginning of Kat's adventures.
65
Game Critics (Mar 27, 2002)
Pirates: The Legend Of Black Kat is the story of a young firebrand named Katarina, and her quest for salty vengeance after her fathers death at the hands of evil rogues. The setting of the story features an interesting mix of classic swashbuckling elements, fantasy monsters and magic items. While the pirate theme itself isnt very common on consoles, what makes this title particularly noteworthy is that it was produced by Westwood Studios, more famous for their Real-Time Strategy titles under the Command & Conquer banner. However, Pirates is nothing but console-style action, unlike their other titles.
64
GameSpy (May 09, 2002)
Pirates is a great game for beginners. It's simple, the game guides players along the proposed path, and the water visuals will impress most anyone. The community of people who own Xboxes at the moment are mostly hardcore gamers, so this title doesn't seem to fit yet. Give it a year and maybe your younger sibling or a friend who decided to pick up a system because Toys "R" Us was having a sale that was advertised in the Sunday paper will take an interest. Pirates is, and still will be, a decent game for the novice gamer. Until then, adventure elsewhere, matey.
60
GamesFirst! (May 29, 2002)
When it comes down to it, Pirates could have done a lot more. Though there is a laugh factor in fighting a one handed, one hooked Blackbeard with a bikini clad swashbuckler, the developers seemed to restrain themselves almost completely from exercising their creative humor-bone in the actual game. An entertaining romp in a time past, with a massive world and a solid amount of game play, Pirates is a solid three stars, but missed the boat on what it could have been. The world is just begging for a little comedy, a random encounter with Bigfoot or Moby Dick, a Swiss Family Robinson look alike, or a chance meeting with some Survivors. As is, Pirates is a competent game that will hold most people's attentions for at least a little while. I probably wouldn't recommend purchasing it unless you're a true blooded third person fan, and in which case your could do much, much worse.
60
IGN (Apr 09, 2002)
Pirates is not a bad game, it's just not that great. This is the definition of a middle of the road game. It does offer a lot of gameplay, but that gameplay feels pretty standard. Is it fun? At times. Is it tedious? Occasionally. Is it worth $50? Probably not, though a rental would give you a pretty good idea of its value to you. I'm still waiting for a pirate game that can equal the addictiveness and sense of adventure as Pirates Gold. Monkey Island did a much better job at capturing the spirit of pirate lore and it's a spoof title. Perhaps the next in the Pirates series will go a bit further. Until then, Pirates Gold still remains king in the console pirate world.