Gothic

The Good
The story is great, everything feels real, you can do almost everything. I loved strolling through the woods which look quite real and go hunting (or be hunted by packs of wolves or snappers which show realistic behaviour like attacking you from behind and almost always in groups). The quests aren't too hard. Great fun!

The Bad
The handling is sometimes annoying, buying things can be a pain. But that doesn't matter.

The Bottom Line
Starting as a simple prisoner who is cast into a hostile world without weapons and armour, knowing no-one and having to fear wolves and giant rats, you will grow to be the hope of all three (ah, at least of two) communities of prisoners.