[ All ] [ PlayStation 3 ] [ Windows ] [ Xbox 360 ]
Critic Reviews 89% add missing review
TrueAchievements ( ) (100%)
If you read the opening sentence of this summary and felt even just a tinge of agreement with my sentiment, should you only be able to afford one retail title from the impressive lineup we're contending with this year, make it Dishonored. I can offer no higher praise than an unquestionable five star rating, though I'm throwing my hat into the ring and declaring that I strongly believe this is a Game of the Year contender.Oct 15th, 2012 · Xbox 360 · read review
games xtreme (9.5 out of 10) (95%)
Dishonored reminds us of Thief and we're proud to say we love it just as much as we do the Dark Project, the Metal Age and even Deadly Shadows. It has all the elements that make a great game and doesn't skimp on anything - it tests your ingenuity and offers complete freedom of movement/choice through the whole game.Oct 9th, 2012 · Xbox 360 · read review
Consoles Plus (19 out of 20) (95%)
Dishonored fait l'effet paradoxal d'une surprise attendue. Dès son annonce, le titre a fait parler de lui et nourri les attentes démesurées de nombreux joueurs. Et à sa sortie, il ne déçoit pas. Riche, profond, original, intelligent, il nous plonge dans un univers unique et ne nous en fait jamais ressortir durant toute la partie. Mais c'est également un excellent jeu dans le sens le plus ludique du terme. Son découpage en missions et son gameplay exigeant peuvent presque lui apporter un petit côté arcade, moteur de superplay ou de speedruns. Bref, Dishonored est excellent, comme prévu.Dec 2012 · Xbox 360 · read review
Jeuxvideo.com (19 out of 20) (95%)
Avec Dishonored, Arkane reprend le flambeau de références passées, à commencer par Thief et ose ce que peu d'autres titres osent : laisser le joueur se dépatouiller avec ce qu'il a et sortir des chemins tout tracés. S'ils existent malgré tout dans Dishonored, on peut les ignorer et "maltraiter" l'architecture, ne pas faire ce qu'on attend de nous pour jouer les équilibristes sur un fil à linge et se raccrocher à une corniche improbable. Bilan : une fois le jeu terminé, on a qu'une envie, le recommencer.Oct 8th, 2012 · Xbox 360 · read review
Jeuxvideo.com (19 out of 20) (95%)
Avec Dishonored, Arkane reprend le flambeau de références passées, à commencer par Thief et ose ce que peu d'autres titres osent : laisser le joueur se dépatouiller avec ce qu'il a et sortir des chemins tout tracés. S'ils existent malgré tout dans Dishonored, on peut les ignorer et "maltraiter" l'architecture, ne pas faire ce qu'on attend de nous pour jouer les équilibristes sur un fil à linge et se raccrocher à une corniche improbable. Bilan : une fois le jeu terminé, on a qu'une envie, le recommencer.Oct 12th, 2012 · PlayStation 3 · read review
Jeuxvideo.com (19 out of 20) (95%)
Avec Dishonored, Arkane reprend le flambeau de références passées, à commencer par Thief et ose ce que peu d'autres titres osent : laisser le joueur se dépatouiller avec ce qu'il a et sortir des chemins tout tracés. S'ils existent malgré tout dans Dishonored, on peut les ignorer et "maltraiter" l'architecture, ne pas faire ce qu'on attend de nous pour jouer les équilibristes sur un fil à linge et se raccrocher à une corniche improbable. Bilan : une fois le jeu terminé, on a qu'une envie, le recommencer.Oct 8th, 2012 · Windows · read review
Mana Pool (9.4 out of 10) (94%)
This is a worthy successor to Thief. If you don’t like subtle, sneaky games, then, okay! It’s a worthy successor to, say, Bioshock, which the game also invokes with its looting of abandoned places and use of miraculous powers in combat. Loot buys upgrades, upgrades improve your choices. The look also invokes Half Life 2, thanks to the art director. So I’m throwing around some heavyweight names here, all three of those are gaming gold. This is a big, brilliantly made game, and I recommend it heartily!Oct 15th, 2012 · Windows · read review
ComputerGames.ro (93 out of 100) (93%)
Bucuraţi-vă de o raritate în peisajul actual al remake-urilor şi al continuărilor. Dishonored este proaspăt, divers, cu o lume brutală şi în acelaşi timp sensibilă, în care depinde doar de tine dacă vrei să fii călău sau mănuşa de catifea. E o provocare la fiecare pas, mai ales dacă vrei să fii asasinul din umbră prin excelenţă; iar dacă lumina reflectoarelor nu te deranjează când înfigi sabia, poţi să faci şi asta – consecinţele urmează după aceea.Nov 7th, 2012 · Windows · read review
PlayStation Trophies (93 out of 100) (93%)
Dishonored is this year’s must-have new IP, with fresh ideas, plenty of charm and inventiveness, and tying them together in a stylish fashion. Who said creativity in the games industry was dead, huh? Dishonored says hello. Your free time says goodbye.Oct 24th, 2012 · PlayStation 3 · read review
XboxAchievements (93 out of 100) (93%)
Dishonored is this year’s must-have new IP, with fresh ideas, plenty of charm and inventiveness, and tying them together in a stylish fashion. Who said creativity in the games industry was dead, huh? Dishonored says hello. Your free time says goodbye.Oct 7th, 2012 · Xbox 360 · read review
IGN (9.2 out of 10) (92%)
It's a shame that Dishonored's story isn't greater than the sum of its decidedly memorable parts, but its gameplay absolutely is. Each mission is built as an elaborate network of choices for players to explore, and the same can be said for Corvo himself. Each player's selection of powers, perks and other upgrades will inform how they see and interact with this world, and no two play-throughs will be exactly the same. Dishonored is a game you'll talk with your friends about, and that you'll want to play multiple times. In this game there are always other paths to be taken and other challenges to conquer, and that's a refreshing thing indeed.Oct 7th, 2012 · Xbox 360 · read review
IGN (9.2 out of 10) (92%)
It's a shame that Dishonored's story isn't greater than the sum of its decidedly memorable parts, but its gameplay absolutely is. Each mission is built as an elaborate network of choices for players to explore, and the same can be said for Corvo himself. Each player's selection of powers, perks and other upgrades will inform how they see and interact with this world, and no two play-throughs will be exactly the same. Dishonored is a game you'll talk with your friends about, and that you'll want to play multiple times. In this game there are always other paths to be taken and other challenges to conquer, and that's a refreshing thing indeed.Oct 7th, 2012 · PlayStation 3 · read review
IGN (9.2 out of 10) (92%)
It's a shame that Dishonored's story isn't greater than the sum of its decidedly memorable parts, but its gameplay absolutely is. Each mission is built as an elaborate network of choices for players to explore, and the same can be said for Corvo himself. Each player's selection of powers, perks and other upgrades will inform how they see and interact with this world, and no two play-throughs will be exactly the same. Dishonored is a game you'll talk with your friends about, and that you'll want to play multiple times. In this game there are always other paths to be taken and other challenges to conquer, and that's a refreshing thing indeed.Oct 7th, 2012 · Windows · read review
PC Games (Germany) (91 out of 100) (91%)
Mit Entscheidungsfreiheit haben schon andere Spiele geworben. In Dishonored sind aber erstmals alle Wege zum Ziel gleichberechtigt! Auf meine Taten folgen logische Konsequenzen, die sich zu einem Happy End oder einer ungleich düstereren Auflösung des Plots zusammenfügen. Hier habe ich das Gefühl, dass meine Entscheidungen echte Auswirkungen haben. Und das ist nur einer von einem halben Dutzend Punkten, in denen Dishonored mutig (und erfolgreich!) neue Wege beschreitet oder bekannte Mechaniken perfektioniert: Schleich-Gameplay, Kämpfe, Leveldesign, Gegner-KI, Szenario, all das ist eine Klasse für sich. Das macht Hoffnung für die PC-Spiele-Zukunft abseits großer Marken!Oct 12th, 2012 · Windows · read review
Gameplay (Benelux) (91 out of 100) (91%)
Eindelijk nog eens een originele first person stealth shooter die moedig afwijkt van de platgetreden paden en nog bruist van de sfeer ook. Eentje om rustig je tijd voor te nemen en ten volle te beleven!Oct 31st, 2012 · Windows
Legendra ( ) (90%)
Dishonored est un jeu aux multiples facettes. Parmi elles, chaque joueur a la possibilité de se retrouver, de choisir et d'influencer le monde qui l'entoure, non pas seulement par ses propos, mais aussi par chacun de ses actes. Les développeurs ont de surcroît accompli la prouesse de ne léser aucun des nombreux aspects de l’œuvre et délivrent ce véritable ovni dans un emballage pour le moins reluisant. On pourrait alors résumer Dishonored en disant qu'il est le fruit inattendument harmonieux du délicieux paradoxe constitué par la fusion de l'adaptabilité au joueur avec la personnalité de l’œuvre, sans que son essence n'en soit altérée. Un must-have.Oct 24th, 2012 · Windows · read review
Softpedia (9 out of 10) (90%)
Dishonored is an impressive first-person stealth experience, managing to emphasize subtlety while still allowing players to engage in more violent actions during their quests in Dunwall. Corvo's adventures are quite engaging and, while there may be a few faults, like the AI that feels a bit too smart or the hit and miss sword-based combat, the game is still quite impressive and will entertain gamers for many hours and several playthroughs thanks to the array of choices that can be explored.Oct 15th, 2012 · Windows · read review
Atomic Gamer (9 out of 10) (90%)
Arkane Studios has doubled down on the importance of a solo experience, as Dishonored has no multiplayer component at all - and I'm absolutely happy with that. Sure, it's got some problems, like some missions with separately-loaded sections that can occasionally reset guards if you merely knocked them out rather than killed them, forcing you to deal with them all over again, or a few framerate issues on slightly low-end PCs that are still comfortably above the minimum requirements. But this kind of a thinking-man's action game doesn't come along too often, and Dishonored has many of those difficult-to-include things that a true FPS-RPG that's descended from Deus Ex and Ultima Underworld should have. Pure FPS fans may not be too excited and there are a few minor problems, but this is a rare gem that anyone looking for a more cerebral action game should be paying serious attention to. And by "paying serious attention", I mean that you should buy it.Oct 8th, 2012 · Windows · read review
PCActu (9 out of 10) (90%)
Si vous aviez perdu espoir au vu de la casualisation du jeu vidéo, vous retrouverez le sourire, Dishonored est typiquement ce qu'il vous fallait. Ici, vous ne serez pas pris par la main, vous aurez droit à un univers énorme et en prime, le scénario est aux petits oignons. Avec ses multiples possibilités et son gameplay hyper soigné, voici la bonne surprise venue de chez Bethesda, merci les gars !Oct 17th, 2012 · Windows · read review
Cheat Happens (9 out of 10) (90%)
There's no way around it -- with its impressively creative world, open-ended gameplay and precise mechanics, Dishonored is one of the best games of the year. More importantly, it's one of those games that you're going to be playing for quite some time, one of those games that you're going to be thinking about even you're not playing. It may not be a masterpiece, but Dishonored is pretty damn close.Oct 25th, 2012 · Windows · read review
JeuxVideoPC.com (18 out of 20) (90%)
Dishonored est un mélange réussi et improbable d’Assassin’s Creed, de Bioshock et de Hitman. Non seulement le pari d’Arkane Studio de mêler un monde semi-ouvert au FPS solo d’infiltration est réussi, mais en plus l’univers est prenant, le gameplay mêlant discrétion, combats et magie est complet et la durée de vie généreuse. Comptez une petite vingtaine en le finissant plusieurs fois. Car oui, une fois l’aventure bouclée, le premier réflexe sera de relancer Dishonored pour découvrir d’autres fins. Que demander de plus ? Un scénario un peu moins prévisible ? On le pardonne aisément tant Dishonored est le FPS incontournable de cette fin d’année.Oct 12th, 2012 · Windows · read review
Factornews (9 out of 10) (90%)
Dishonored réussit le quasi sans faute, se mettant haut la main au niveau des attentes qu’il a suscitées tout au long de son développement. C’est un véritable régal que de se plonger dans les méandres de Dunwall et de redécouvrir chaque niveau selon la manière dont on choisit de l’aborder.Oct 5th, 2012 · Windows · read review
newbreview.com (4.5 out of 5) (90%)
If nothing else, Dishonored offers up a glorious break from the standard run and gun, and a wonderfully rich new environment to indulge in.For those of you just re-emerging from your XCOM induced exile, go put your FPS mask back on and give Dishonored a spin.Nov 13th, 2012 · Windows · read review
Games Finder (9 out of 10) (90%)
Dishonored walks an interesting line between action and stealth based game with plenty of decisions left in the hands of the player. The difference between high and low chaos alone definitely warrants a second playthrough.Dec 25th, 2014 · Windows · read review
GameSpy ( ) (90%)
In the era of sequels and reboots, rare is something that feels new, and rarer still is something that feels new and fully realized. Dishonored then, is the golden tabby tiger of videogames. Drawing its strength from such greats as Thief, BioShock, Batman: Arkham City, and Portal, Arkane Studios' latest manages to deliver that magical formula of intimately familiar and refreshingly new. It doesn't shine as brightly as it should on PC, and it might not offer the challenge stealth-action fans are used to, but it's an impressive accomplishment that immediately stands out as one of the best things we've seen this year.Oct 7th, 2012 · Windows · read review
newbreview.com (4.5 out of 5) (90%)
If nothing else, Dishonored offers up a glorious break from the standard run and gun, and a wonderfully rich new environment to indulge in.For those of you just re-emerging from your XCOM induced exile, go put your FPS mask back on and give Dishonored a spin.Nov 13th, 2012 · Xbox 360 · read review
Brutal Gamer (9 out of 10) (90%)
I can’t recommend Dishonored highly enough for anyone previously turned off to the world of stealth. Those that are fans of the genre will already be worked up and need little encouragement from me to know this is an essential purchase for them.Oct 8th, 2012 · Xbox 360 · read review
Chip Power Play ( ) (90%)
Auf den ersten Blick erscheint Dishonored überschaubar, sklavisch eine mittelmäßige Story abarbeitend und technisch durchschnittlich. Der zweite Blick offenbart einen enormen Handlungsspielraum, eine Vielzahl roter Fäden und eine faszinierende Welt, die unglaublich stimmungsvoll in Szene gesetzt ist. Und der dritte Blick dauert 20 oder 30 Stunden, die erfüllt sind mit Geheimnissen und Überraschungen, in denen das Herz klopft und der Atem stockt, die zutiefst befriedigen, wenn Pläne funktionieren. Das Design von Dishonored ist ähnlich stimmig wie das von Bioshock, lauschen und schleichen funktioniert so gut wie in Thief, die spielerischen Möglichkeiten sind vielfältig wie in Deus Ex. Und doch ist dieses Spiet von hinreißender Eigenständigkeit — dank der einzigartigen Welt, der Fülle an Inhalten und der tollen Spielbarkeit.Nov 2012 · Xbox 360
411mania.com (9 out of 10) (90%)
Dishonored looks like it will easily secure the title of Top New IP of 2012. The gameplay is solid and story is entertaining. While the graphics may drag the game down a bit, don’t let them stop you from enjoying what is a great title, whether you play it stealthy or guns blazing and sword flying.Oct 9th, 2012 · Xbox 360 · read review
GamersHell.com (9 out of 10) (90%)
All wrapped together, the Dishonored package is a model I wish more games—especially the tired first-person shooter genre—would follow. More so today than ever, it seems like they're intent on only offering violent measures as means and ends to their conflicts. Dishonored, instead, uses violence as a choice—a fact that makes it more appropriately rewarding, and happily avoided. There are some weird technical hiccups (like guards able to hear downed and snoozing enemies through walls) and the protagonist is a shell without a voice, but everything gels together so impeccably otherwise, it's unfortunate the game has an ending.Oct 8th, 2012 · Xbox 360 · read review
Hooked Gamers (9 out of 10) (90%)
Despite executive producer Harvey Smith's confliction on continuing the series, I can only hope that we see a sequel in the years to come. Perhaps one day we get to explore the other Isles or even the Pandyssian continent. For now though we have a fantastic stealth title worthy of adding to your collection.Oct 18th, 2012 · Xbox 360 · read review
allaboutgames.co.uk (9 out of 10) (90%)
While Dishonored doesn't do anything wrong, it could do with a little bit more to receive a perfect score, perhaps another mission or two, or a more dramatic ending. However, the gameplay, visuals and story put many games this year to shame.Nov 2nd, 2012 · PlayStation 3 · read review
newbreview.com (4.5 out of 5) (90%)
If nothing else, Dishonored offers up a glorious break from the standard run and gun, and a wonderfully rich new environment to indulge in.For those of you just re-emerging from your XCOM induced exile, go put your FPS mask back on and give Dishonored a spin.Nov 13th, 2012 · PlayStation 3 · read review
VentureBeat / GamesBeat (86 out of 100) (86%)
Dishonored nails the Thief-style gameplay while missing the BioShock-quality story that would’ve elevated it into something truly special. It’ll have to settle for amazingly cool instead. The impressive depth, range, and balance earn this one an easy recommendation despite a few hiccups and one dreary, excessively long level. Gamers who don’t feel the need for repeat plays might not get their money’s worth, but for me, one spin through Dunwall wasn’t enough. The care and imagination that went into Dishonored makes each return visit worthwhile.Oct 7th, 2012 · PlayStation 3 · read review
GamesCollection (8.5 out of 10) (85%)
Aprire la propria mente ad un gameplay diverso dal solito è sempre intrigante, oltre ad essere una sfida con noi stessi non da poco. Forse Bethesda ha esaltato qualche caratteristica di troppo, ma Dishonored resta comunque un titolo dall’altissimo valore ludico ed artistico ed ha il grandissimo pregio di riportare alla luce il fascino lasciato in eredità da giochi come Half Life 2 e Thief: Deadly Shadows (a mio avviso imbattuto sotto l’aspetto stealth). Se volete immergervi in una storia affascinante e portare la vendetta a chi giustamente la merita...non esitate! Dishonored vi darà l'esperienza che cercate!Oct 10th, 2012 · Xbox 360 · read review
GameStar (Germany) (84 out of 100) (84%)
Ach, Dishonored. Ich würde mich wirklich gerne Hals über Kopf in dich verlieben. Aber du lässt mich ja nicht so recht. Du hast alle Elemente für eine fantastische Story – und erzählst stattdessen einen 0815-Plot. Du hast eine faszinierende Spielwelt – und erweckst sie nie so wirklich zum Leben. Du hast alternative Lösungswege, unheimlich coole Spezialfähigkeiten und originelle Einfälle – und treibst mich mit einer verunglückten KI und einem viel zu niedrigen Schwierigkeitsgrad in den Wahnsinn. Ach, Dishonored, was mache ich bloß mit dir? Oh, ich weiß: Ich wünsche mir, dass du dich trotz meiner Kritik super verkaufst, weil du Charme hast und Ambition und Mumm in den Knochen. Und dann wünsche ich mir, dass dein zweiter Teil nicht nur mutig ist, sondern verwegen genug, um zu sagen: »Ich kann mindestens genauso gut sein wie Thief und Bioshock und Deus Ex!« Denn das kannst du; auch wenn du es im Augenblick noch nicht bist.Oct 8th, 2012 · Windows · read review
4Players.de (84 out of 100) (84%)
Leider hapert es später an reaktiver KI und Anspruch in den Missionen, denn das Teleportieren ist Segen und Fluch zugleich: Man beamt sich zwar elegant vorwärts, aber im Zusammenspiel mit den schwachen Wachroutinen wird das Erlebnis nicht nur vereinfacht, sonder auch stark verkürzt - da überwindet man selbst riesige Brücken in null Komma nichts. Selbst in den erzählerisch wichtigen Momenten, wo die Regie eine knifflige Infiltration ankündigt, kommt man schwuppdiwupp vorwärts. Wo sind die Feinde und Sicherheitsanlagen, die Corvo so das Wasser reichen können, dass man den Erfolg der Überwindung genießen kann? Egal ob Bosse, Infiltration, Rätsel oder Entwicklung: Es fehlt der Anspruch, man ist zu früh zu mächtig. Vor allem im letzten Drittel wird die anfängliche Faszination leider von zu viel Beliebigkeit und Leichtigkeit ausgebremst.Aug 10th, 2012 · PlayStation 3 · read review
4Players.de (84 out of 100) (84%)
Leider hapert es später an reaktiver KI und Anspruch in den Missionen, denn das Teleportieren ist Segen und Fluch zugleich: Man beamt sich zwar elegant vorwärts, aber im Zusammenspiel mit den schwachen Wachroutinen wird das Erlebnis nicht nur vereinfacht, sonder auch stark verkürzt - da überwindet man selbst riesige Brücken in null Komma nichts. Selbst in den erzählerisch wichtigen Momenten, wo die Regie eine knifflige Infiltration ankündigt, kommt man schwuppdiwupp vorwärts. Wo sind die Feinde und Sicherheitsanlagen, die Corvo so das Wasser reichen können, dass man den Erfolg der Überwindung genießen kann? Egal ob Bosse, Infiltration, Rätsel oder Entwicklung: Es fehlt der Anspruch, man ist zu früh zu mächtig. Vor allem im letzten Drittel wird die anfängliche Faszination leider von zu viel Beliebigkeit und Leichtigkeit ausgebremst.Oct 8th, 2012 · Windows · read review
4Players.de (84 out of 100) (84%)
Leider hapert es später an reaktiver KI und Anspruch in den Missionen, denn das Teleportieren ist Segen und Fluch zugleich: Man beamt sich zwar elegant vorwärts, aber im Zusammenspiel mit den schwachen Wachroutinen wird das Erlebnis nicht nur vereinfacht, sonder auch stark verkürzt - da überwindet man selbst riesige Brücken in null Komma nichts. Selbst in den erzählerisch wichtigen Momenten, wo die Regie eine knifflige Infiltration ankündigt, kommt man schwuppdiwupp vorwärts. Wo sind die Feinde und Sicherheitsanlagen, die Corvo so das Wasser reichen können, dass man den Erfolg der Überwindung genießen kann? Egal ob Bosse, Infiltration, Rätsel oder Entwicklung: Es fehlt der Anspruch, man ist zu früh zu mächtig. Vor allem im letzten Drittel wird die anfängliche Faszination leider von zu viel Beliebigkeit und Leichtigkeit ausgebremst.Oct 8th, 2012 · Xbox 360 · read review
OMGN: Online Multiplayer Games Network (8.2 out of 10) (82%)
(1) Dishonored is a compelling game in which everything from the aesthetics and gameplay come together. The best games are the ones that immediately suck you in, the ones that, through story or pristine gameplay, can make you forget you are playing a game and allow you to spend a few hours lost in their worlds. Dishonored can now sit on the same shelf with Red Dead Redemption and Fallout 3. Immersive and enjoyable, Dishonored is a must-play. (2) Dishonored is a well-designed piece of software which suffers only from its own narrative framework. Despite all the positive things one can say regarding its gameplay and level design, it can’t escape the shadow of a flawed morality system that drives the title’s story forward. It's worth a bargain purchase or a Steam sale, but avoid paying full price for it.Dec 11th, 2012 · Windows · read review
Calm Down Tom (8 out of 10) (80%)
Running across rooftops with sword and crossbow in hand, jumping, teleporting and dispatching guards with silent, deadly efficiency, Dishonored is an encouraging step in the right direction for new IP’s. Open ended, engaging and an example of the very best in modern videogame level design, it’s the most exciting major new IP this year.Oct 15th, 2012 · PlayStation 3 · read review
Games.co.il ( ) (80%)
משחק, בסופו של דבר, שהוא בגדר יהלום פגום (עם שלב אחרון חלש במיוחד אבל, תודה לאל, בלי בוסים מאולצים); אבל פגם שניתן לתיקון בחלקו - עם משמעת עצמית Dishonored יאפשר לכם "לאזן מחדש" את המשחקיות שלו על ידי הגבלה של הציוד והכוחות בהם תרשו לעצמכם להשתמש.Oct 16th, 2012 · PlayStation 3 · read review
Games TM (8 out of 10) (80%)
For its soaring highs and captivating hits alone, Dishonored comes as an easy recommendation. Wit the Thief franchise stuck in a lab somewhere, having numbers spliced into its title, and Deus Ex still on the naughty step after those boss battles, Arkane has come with arguably this generation's finest stealth title and a game so lovingly crafted that it begs to be played.Nov 22nd, 2012 · Xbox 360
Gamekult (8 out of 10) (80%)
Melting pot d'influences, de Thief à Hitman, de BioShock à Deus Ex, Dishonored est pourtant un titre unique, un jeu hybride aussi singulier que peut l'être son univers. La recette mi-FPS mi-RPG n'est certes pas nouvelle, mais Arkane l'a préparée avec ses propres ingrédients, mêlant combats dynamiques, pouvoirs originaux et level design de très haute volée. Perdu dans les faubourgs de Dunwall, ou rendu sourd par le vent battant les toits de la Dunwall Tower, on reste fascinés par le résultat et séduits par tous ces choix qui s'offrent à nous, sans même qu'on s'en rende compte. Quel dommage du coup que cette aventure, si singulière et si familière à la fois, s'achève aussi vite.Oct 8th, 2012 · Windows · read review
Giant Bomb ( ) (80%)
If you love yourself some Deus Ex, you're going to really like Dishonored, and if you've found the genre impenetrable in the past, I've got some good news for you.Oct 7th, 2012 · PlayStation 3 · read review
Giant Bomb ( ) (80%)
If you love yourself some Deus Ex, you're going to really like Dishonored, and if you've found the genre impenetrable in the past, I've got some good news for you.Oct 7th, 2012 · Xbox 360 · read review
GNT - Generation Nouvelles Technologies (8 out of 10) (80%)
Arkane Studios nous propose une fois de plus une production atypique et efficace avec Dishonored. Mettant l'accent sur la liberté d'action, ce FPS aux allures de Thief mise énormément sur l'infiltration, même s'il est possible de foncer tête baissée au prix d'une difficulté corsée. Le soft jouit d'une pâte artistique de très bonne facture, en dépit d'une réalisation graphique en deçà de ce qui se fait actuellement. En bref, Dishonored c'est avant tout une expérience de jeu unique en son genre, qui sera surtout appréciée par les amateurs de jeux de discrétion qui apprécient les background originaux et riches en détails.Oct 22nd, 2012 · PlayStation 3 · read review
Entertainium ( ) (80%)
Regardless of Dishonored’s issues, that mainly involve some stealth design and its too predictable of a story, there’s much to enjoy in Dishonored. From the lived in world feel and its incredibly reach backstory, to all its gameplay possibilities, this is one incredible game. With missions that can take you anywhere from twenty minutes to two hours to finish depending on your approach and numerous secrets you discover, every play through is its own contained experience. Dishonored is simply one of the best and most atmospheric games out this year. This is one choice that’s very easy to make.Oct 20th, 2012 · Windows · read review
Alec: The thing about Dishonored for me is how much it feels right. Jim: Agreed. It overflows with master craftsmanship. Beautifully made. It's a luxury construct. John: It's a stunning spectacle of a game. It's a game-game too - it embraces what only gaming can deliver, and cares so much about delivering it. Adam: It is an important game too, which sounds so bloody pulpit-thumping, but it really is. Jim: So we're recommending people buy it? Alec: I never felt confused or uncomfortable, it immediately made sense, tapping into things and skills I knew well but without simply repeating them. People should buy itOct 9th, 2012 · Windows · read review
Overall the game is a very good one and should definitely be on your to-buy list. It was released in 2012 but it is a game for the ages with a special kind of gameplay, and the story is very interesting and adaptive. I would definitely recommend this game to buy, especially with it now being rather cheap.Oct 17th, 2014 · PlayStation 3 · read review
Overall the game is a very good one and should definitely be on your to-buy list. It was released in 2012 but it is a game for the ages with a special kind of gameplay, and the story is very interesting and adaptive. I would definitely recommend this game to buy, especially with it now being rather cheap.Oct 17th, 2014 · Xbox 360 · read review
It feels like a game from another timeline, one where Thief and System Shock set the bar for what first-person games could be, leading to designs that were built around intelligent use of space and world-building. I still wish Dishonored were longer but I also recognise that it takes a great deal of skill, hard work and time to create something of this quality; to ask for more in terms of content would be to ask for less in so many other ways. What we really should be asking is for other developers to learn the lessons that Arkane can teach them. Of course, it’s not as simple as that, because for all that there are flaws – there are always flaws – Dishonored is a work of rare imagination and skill, the sort of thing that can't simply be copied and repeated. I hope I'm wrong, but we may not see its like again for a good while.Oct 8th, 2012 · Windows · read review
Dishonored is the third game created by the French developer Arkane Studios after their debut Arx Fatalis and Dark Messiah of Might and Magic. I haven't played those two games, but their reception by hardcore RPG circles was lukewarm at best. Dishonored is less of an RPG than those titles, and it looks like the developers approached it from a different angle. Very soon it becomes clear than the game attempts to emulate a particular breed of hybrid games from the past, as immortalized by Looking Glass and to a certain extent Ion Storm.
The main inspiration here appears to be Thief II with a touch of Deus Ex. Many people (myself included) consider those games the epitome of intelligent level design and absorbing gameplay. Paying homage to them is a tricky business, since modern game designers are more restricted by mainstream requirements, which state that every game should be as streamlined and as user-friendly as possible. Nevertheless, Dishonored succeeds in most of its lofty aspirations, with only Deus Ex: Human Revolution towering over it as a more successful modern example of genre-merging.
The first thing to notice here is the generosity. We are all familiar with the type of level design that eschews everything except what is needed to complete a stage, with doors that can't be opened by any means, unrealistic structures that scream "it's just a game level", and so on. What I probably love most in Dishonored is that it does away with this kind of thinking. One of the reasons for the immersion it evokes is its level design, which brings back memories from Thief and Deus Ex and all those beloved classics. The levels are large and feel believable. Doors can actually be opened and they lead to areas you do not need to visit in order to finish the mission. The game excels at creating an illusion of a real world around you, a world that exists there because it exists, not because somebody constructed it to serve as a stage in a video game. You sense around you an environment that lives its own life, independent of your presence, and when you explore the locations there is a feeling of wonder and excitement. This is a fantastic achievement that only a few games have been able to accomplish.
Let us not confuse this with open-world design. The key word here is quality, not just quantity. Dishonored is not an open-world game, but it succeeds in creating dense environments that make you feel that you don't need any open-world gaming afterwards. The areas are not only exquisitely detailed - they are full of useful, gameplay-related objects. Collection is one of the cornerstone mechanics of game design, and Dishonored is great at satisfying our collector's instinct. There is so much to find in the stages that it becomes almost overwhelming. In a smart move, the game also tells us after every mission how much stuff we were able to collect and how much of it we missed. If you know that you only got 341 out of 1127 possible coins you are bound to go back and replay the mission. There are no empty places in the game's world, but it's so easy to miss out things that careful exploration becomes a goal in itself.
Gameplay philosophy here is quite Deus Ex-like: choosing different ways and routes to complete a mission is what makes this kind of gameplay so rewarding and thrilling. Dishonored is radical in this aspect: you can finish the entire game without killing anyone or become a walking death machine. In a cool twist they made these choices affect the world: killing more people will call forth more rats to feed on the corpses - which, in turn, will spread the plague and more people will become infected. The freedom of choice is exhilarating, and every mission offers ample opportunities to play it in any style - be it by carefully crawling on suspended beams, seeking out alternate paths and hiding from guards, creatively using your arsenal to sneak upon them and put them to sleep, or risk it all by sniping them with crossbows or hacking them to pieces when they attempt to bring you down. Some instances also offer moral decisions concerning the target's ultimate fate, harming innocents, etc. In short, Dishonored is a game that begs to be replayed and savored to the full.
Dishonored is worth checking out just for its setting. In a world full of recurrent fantasy, sci-fi, and post-apocalyptic scenarios, this game stands out as an example of true originality and thought put into creating a believable setting. Thief II with its mixture of medieval and steampunk is probably the closest famous example, but Dishonored only has a touch of "ye olde Europe" style and instead goes for something that looks like an alternate future of early 19th-century England where science continued to develop while society did not. In other words, the game's world is full of grim cruelty associated with the Middle Ages coupled with the oppressive, hierarchical social structure of a powerful empire and crude technology, producing a setting with electric torture chambers, messages recorded on mechanical devices, industry powered by whale oil, and wooden crossbows fired in a mad scientist's lab. Books scattered through the levels provide more insight into this interesting world and add more depth to it.
This world is also incredibly detailed, inviting you to stop and gaze at all those little things that make it come to life. You know that art designers put their hearts into the project when you stop fighting on a staircase in a gorgeous brothel just to admire stylish black-white photographs decorating the walls or when you stare at a thug taking a leak near a dumpster containing a mechanical trap device. Posters, paintings, furniture, architecture, clothes - everything has been paid attention to, everything exists for a purpose, with rare coherence and conviction that, once again, makes you forget that you are in a game. Never since Bloodlines have I seen such a lavishly designed game world full of contrasts, beauty, and artistic inspiration.
It looks like Arcane couldn't quite shake off its "magical" past, and as a results made the unfortunate decision of adding magic to the setting. This was a bad choice for two reasons: first, the world of Dishonored was already complete and even homogeneous in a certain way, and magic just gave it an unnecessary edge that came close to destroying its delicate balance. Second, magic had a similar effect on the gameplay as well, ruining an otherwise successful equilibrium of rough combat and nerve-tickling stealth. I didn't even touch the other spells, but Blink is given to you right at the start and there seems to be no way to avoid using it in certain situations. The problem is that Blink quickly become a cheap way of dealing with enemies, giving you an unfair advantage in a game that is not too difficult to begin with. Blink behind an unsuspecting enemy, choke him and drag away the body - this becomes a recipe you'll be too tempted to follow, as any other way of surpassing your obstacles is significantly more troublesome. In a rare case, I wish there was a patch that removed (or at least weakened) certain elements of a game. Dishonored would have been a more complete package if magic weren't there.
The story is disappointing. A setting like this could have become a stage for a cool tale full of mystery, intrigues, and ambiguous characters. Instead we get a schematic video game plot we've seen countless times before (even if we consider first-person 3D games only, the plot of Strife, released sixteen years before, is by and large identical), with a twist in the middle that feels by-the-book and predictable. Most characters lack charisma and personality, and most of the dialogue is as bland as they go. Voice acting is uniformly forgettable, and scenes that are supposed to move us emotionally barely do so. It is a bit sad to see that storytelling standards in video games are so low that even a game of such caliber survives without bothering to come up with anything more original and involving.
The Bottom Line
Dishonored may fall just short of the giants of the past, but it is nevertheless in the top echelon of smart gaming and an instant modern classic. Original setting, generous and inventive design, and loads of atmosphere resurrect the kind of playing experience we thought was mercilessly destroyed by modern streamlining, and restores hope in a better future for the medium.
by Unicorn Lynx (180537) on Sep 15th, 2017 · Windows
A Great little First Person Stealth Game.
I give credit where credit is due. The French know their political intrigue and have endued this game with a convoluted tale of backstabbing and double crossing. You start off as a valued body guard who is framed for a terrible murder. You're recruited by both the loyalists who want to see the rightful emperor restored to power and by a mystical figure who grants you magic powers to assist in your missions.
You're an assassin who has to remove political leaders from positions and assist the loyalists in their goals. Here is where the fun starts. You take two approaches to game play. You can hide, and sneak around, avoiding unnecessary kills. You can also go through and start killing everyone you see. The actions you take will reflect on your ending. You have the ability to jump, climb and teleport to various locations to get around tough obstacles. I tend to avoid killing in games like this for the challenge.
The levels are sprawling and complex. You can usually find more than one way to approach a location and with blink, you can often reach hard to find places. Light plays an important part of the game because it makes you more visible and more likely to attract attention. You spend a great deal of time exploring ruins that are infested with a plague that turns people into zombies.
There are hidden treasures everywhere, and exploration is necessary. You also have the option to restart any level you completed to see if you can make a better run of it.
There are interesting characters that are voiced by the likes of Susan Sarandon and Brad Doriff. The game is more than a little obvious in its inspiration, as it quotes "Thief" more than once. Once in a while, you get a outcome you didn't expect which makes your decisions more interesting.
Be prepared to save and load a lot. You will die many times as you learn the layout of each level. You never know what to expect.
The powers handed out to you are a mixed bag. Some are extremely useful, and others barely do anything.
The Bottom Line
It's really fun and can be completed within a fairly short period.
by Scott Monster (985) on Aug 4th, 2014 · Xbox 360
One does not simply kill the rat plague
Imagine a stealth game that’s stuffed with phantom dark shadows which all guards see, but you don't, because you're a cat like that. Place some candles in the isolated rooms so you could vent steam by blowing at the poor things. Generously splash on a good amount of pattern recognition and sneaking in plain sight. Pour some sword and some choking, add some guns and some tranquilizers. Possess a guard, summon a herd of rat-looking moles from under the earth, blast them away with a deadly wind out of your hand, stop the time just because you can, merrily teleport away from the mess you’ve created. This mess should give you a pretty good idea of what Dishonored plays like. Unless you're a sceptic for whom Dishonored would play like your regular stealth game with lots of pleasant climbing and searching for the ways around obstacles.
But ignoring teleportation is rather like eating a cake box instead of the cake itself, for the quick accessibility of everything brings so much pleasure to the gameplay. Although it has a price too. The locations don't surprise or amaze you with their greatness and even sneaking through places that should, like the giant bridge, feels a bit like a stroll through your own kitchen.
And it's not the only thing that's underwhelming. The whole game just isn’t exactly drearie, dearie, despite the mounts of corpses everywhere and loads of sad abandoned buildings. And it’s a good thing because it’s cozy and pleasant to play. And if you have a problem with your scary game with a plague in it being cozy, you should probably contact the tech support.
On the technical side, it’s done rather nicely. Your screenshot taking finger will ache, scream and beg for mercy oblivious of the sometimes poor texture resolution.
Your ears won’t ditch you for that Prokofiev loving person next door too. Even though there’re no long memorable compositions in the game at all, at least there’re some nice short ones – and being repeatedly brought to the base location while listening to one, boy will you remember it.
Even your brain won’t seek to be extracted by a rogue dentist for the writing isn’t at all bad. It has a funny reference to Thief. It has unusual intriguing characters (or rather a character). The scattered around books sometimes contain nice ideas and are at least remotely interesting, although the game could really do with more of them. If you’ve read stuff thoroughly in the first two levels, then there won’t be much to read for the rest of the game, since most of the books have copies and even those copies sometimes have copies too, strategically placed so you would see them again and again.
Even some plot devices work as they're expected to, and that doesn’t disappoint in providing a really nice contrast to…
…the plot devices that don't. Which are most of them. Because the story itself sucks rats, and in so many ways too. Not only its logic and originality are dangerously close to something Rhianna Pratchett would write, it also screws up all the potential the game has for becoming something more than just a fairly nice experience you choose to discuss the quality of your tasteless breakfast scone over. And one had to try really hard to screw it up here.
The thing is, the archetypal stories about revenge are pretty much autonomous. They don’t need unexpected plot twists, they don’t need hidden messages, they don’t even need complexity. All they need is a hero you can sympathise with, a bunch of mean bastards you can trample on and a way to make it personal for the hero. That’s it, and all the three points is where Dishonored shamelessly fails.
There is no hero – only a shell with a bunch of replies that don’t convey a shred of character. Yes, make me some gear. Yes, take me to the next target. No, I’m not a mute scary freak who stares at you holding a blooded knife in his hands while you talk.
There’re no mean bastards. Well, there’re bastards. And they do their things not quite out of kindness. But if you take for granted that adversaries should at least inspire some respect by not having the intelligence of a dead whale, you’re out of luck. And instead of justified hatred most of the time you feel... pity. What a nice way to trick people into thinking that revenge doesn’t solve anything, Dishonored! Wait, what was your slogan again?
And it’s not even close to personal. I mean, yes, the bastards framed Corvo for the murder of the empress and tried to execute him. But was she the love of his life or was she just a really good employer who always gave him the raise he wanted? Is this Corvo's daughter running around or is it his grandmother who suffers from the growth hormone deficiency? Is Corvo a man or is he secretly a bird so he can indefinitely stand on a rim of a flimsy cardboard box standing on the edge of a skyscraper precariously balanced on top of the Tower of Pisa? I honestly don’t know. And why is that I don’t know the most simple facts after spending over forty hours in the game, reading every scrap of paper and seeing all the endings playing as Corvo?
Oh no, I did notice they’ve gone for ‘invent the vital parts of the story yourself and don’t feel that nasty disappointment if something we’ve come up with wasn’t good enough for you’. And it’s ok as long as you give players the opportunity to clearly express what they’ve thought up in the various situations, like RPGs usually do (ok, who we are kidding, rarely as drunken whalers survive to sober up do). But there’re virtually no important choices in the game at all, except for just the one. And all you get after it is a drivel of the one of the characters about how Corvo quite possibly doesn’t know why he does things himself. Dear developers, seeing your own mistakes is very nice of you. Coulnd’t you fix them or something while you were at it?
But what really smacks you on the cheek and yells ‘Immersion!’ in your ear when you’re finally starting to get immersed are little things. Cheap things. Like when you realise there’s only one song known to the citizens of Dunwall.
Or graffiti. The same ultra realistic graffiti are everywhere! The legacy of some pessimistic maniac who needed to tell you that you can not kill the rat plague rather desperately. And all the ads of the new indie rock band ‘Blood From the Eyes’. ‘Send us food, not bullets’, they write in the closed off apartments accessible only by unhealthy courageous climbing or magical teleportation. Surely the kind postman climbs among us! And what a sad world it is if they have no spud guns invented yet... By the way, didn’t you somehow manage to forget that you can not kill the rat plague? Well, you can’t.
And you can tell fortunes with this game! Just tell me, Dishonored, will anybody ever like the same bland dialogs repeated over and over? (Indeed, I believe so.) Could there be a suitable explanation of why do the guards answer all the questions with the same 8 ball phrases? (Chances are very good.) Does it include owls or the murderous cherry pie? (Never doubt it!) Ok, it's getting tiresome, I should probably blow off. (Blow off!) But tell me, why on earth they didn't pursue a storyline about that mysterious 'he' who says to undress to so many women? (Never doubt it!)
But (as if adversaries weren’t enough) you can also interact with your allies. For example, Corvo's typical briefing sounds very much like this: 'Hi. This guy’s a meanie. Go kill him. Climb in the boat and go. Bye.' And way-hey and up he climbs, accompanied by the player’s silly outraged screams about proper discussions and preplanning.
Well, it does seem like a little excessive measure when you know that the guards have severely impaired vision and a healthy tendency to overlook the defencive mechanisms’ sudden malfunctions (at least they can recognize a bottle when it hits them in the arse), but it’s believability that suffers. And once this 'don’t you have someone to kill blow off' dialog happened with the senders slumped over a map discussing things. But not with Corvo, who actually does the missions!
Also, is there a stealth game at all that doesn’t do the ‘He’s probably watching us right now out of those shadows, ewww, how dreary indeed’ joke? (Blow off!)
Another thing, for a game where you need to access unobvious places to get your levelupping runes it really lacks the New Game+ feature. I completed the game, heck, I did it twice on the hardest setting (which wasn’t much harder than normal, mind you), can I please have fun with the creative killings now from the very beginning, and not from the middle of the game where you can at least pretend you got the half of the stuff you want? ‘No!’, says the strict game injuring its neck with a severely starched collar. ‘We can’t allow fun! Oh well, you can replay separate levels with the abilities you’d gathered by that point, but that’s it, and don’t even think to ask for more. And before you do ask for more, know that there aren’t even cheat codes!’. Truly Victorian!
But then again, what did you expect from a game that stuffs your pockets with guns and threatens to show you the bad ending if you’ll have the nerve to use them?
The Bottom Line
So it was an unfairly short, sadly and rather stupidly spoiled, but still fairly nice experience, one that doesn't change anything inside you but undoubtedly pleas… Oh wait, no, it was probably just the wind.
by Hugh Instead (18) on Jan 2nd, 2013 · Windows
Contributors to this Entry
Critic reviews added by Kennyannydenny, Cavalary, Alsy, jaXen, Big John WV, Yearman, Patrick Bregger, Cantillon, Samuel Smith, Alaka, ryanbus84, Tim Janssen, Damian Fraimorice, Atomskyu690, Jake AM.