Ultima IV: Quest of the Avatar

The Good
Ultima IV stands as a beacon of innovation in the RPG realm. Its groundbreaking departure from conventional fantasy narratives into a world centered on ethical exploration is commendable. The eight virtues, driving gameplay, add a layer of depth rarely seen in the mid-'80s. The open-world design encourages genuine player agency, promoting immersive experiences. The game's ahead-of-its-time concepts and progressive storytelling lay the foundation for modern RPGs. Richard Garriott's visionary approach and the game's lasting influence on the genre make Ultima IV an enduring masterpiece.

The Bad
While Ultima IV excels in many aspects, its dated graphics and interface may deter contemporary gamers. Navigating the game world can be clunky, and the text-heavy presentation might be overwhelming for those accustomed to more visually polished experiences. Additionally, the game's moral system, while groundbreaking, lacks the nuanced consequences seen in modern RPGs. The steep learning curve and lack of in-game guidance may frustrate newcomers, making it less accessible compared to newer titles.

The Bottom Line
Ultima IV is a seminal work that undeniably shaped the RPG landscape. Its ethical framework, open-world design, and innovative storytelling make it a must-play for those appreciating gaming history. While hindered by dated visuals and accessibility challenges, its profound impact on the genre transcends these limitations. For players seeking a deep, thought-provoking adventure and willing to overlook some retro quirks, Ultima IV remains a classic worth exploring, showcasing the roots of RPG excellence.