NHL '94

The Good
Great multiplayer action, especially with penalties turned off. There is a method and skill to scoring, rather than the goalies being impossibly hard or easy.

The Bad
None really. I wish you could get more players than the 5-person limit but that was a limitation of the SNES hardware. Their multi-tap only supported 5 controllers.

The Bottom Line
The best game ever made. You should play it with 5 people with the penalties turned off and it turns into a combination of football and hockey. You block for each other, try to knock the goalie out of position right before your teammate takes a shot and generally do all the things you can't do in real life.