Star Wars: Jedi Knight - Jedi Academy

The Good
This game capitalizes on its predecessor's strength: lightsaber combat. This time around there is more variety with plenty of opponents and new saber modes (dual saber and saber staff). While these fights can get fairly hectic, the developers have added some special moves that you can execute, and the whole experience can really come together quite well.

While the story is minimal, and there is a groan factor at the beginning of every mission as you "unexpectedly" encounter trouble in the unlikeliest of places, once the action gets going it is generally varied enough to keep you entertained. There are vehicles to operate, huge monsters to contend with, and you even get to man the battle stations to shoot down some TIE ships a couple of times.

The Bad
The games missions are structured more like "chores", which you must do in groups of five (you can skip one of each group), in order to get the the few plot-advancing missions. This means that each one is mostly unrelated to the others plot-wise. A major gripe I have with these missions is a good 50% of them are not what they advertise to be. For example there is an early mission taking you with rescuing crash survivors. However once you get to the crash site, your ship breaks and it turns out there are no survivors to save. So the mission is actually about fixing your ship to get back. There are quite a few such bait-and-switches, where nothing gets accomplished by your being there.

My second biggest gripe is the level design. Of all the Jedi Knight games, I believe the first one with its old proprietary engine worked the best at presenting Star Wars' massive settings. In Jedi Academy, to an even greater extent than in Outcast most of the levels seem cramped and artificially walled off. Additionally, some of the levels' population of baddies goes strangely unexplained. While it's easy to believe that an Imperial Remnant installation on some god-forsaken planet would be full of Storm Troopers, one tends to wonder why the rooftops of a residential district on Corusant are a veritable menagerie of alien life hell-bent on trying to kill you. Civilians are nowhere to be seen, even in places you would expect them, and a number of areas seem empty and desolate because of this. And while there is significant variety in levels, a lot of them are simply a sequence of nondescript hi-tech looking rooms with various meaningless displays, populated by a lot of troopers. I believe that the use of the Quake 3 engine, which was designed to allow for intense combat in relatively small and cramped quarters really hurts the game here.

Puzzles are more or less meaningless - there are buttons to push and keys to find, but it seems like they're only there because one is supposed to be pushing buttons and finding keys in these types of games. The rule of thumb is push any button you see, and this will get you past 90% of the games "obstacles".

It is also unfortunate that the designers chose to limit the use of force powers to a few "key" points. For example, while you posses the push and pull force powers, you can only use them on designated objects in the game world. It would be much more fun to incorporate the force powers into the physics system, and allow the player to find creative ways to use them to navigate obstacles. Instead you will see your trigger light up when pointed at a "force-friendly" object, to let you know that this rock, out of thousands of identical rocks in the level can be force-pushed.

The Bottom Line
Despite its flaws, it is definitely an enjoyable experience once you get going. The lightsaber fights alone are worth the price for a star wars fan. As a shooter/saber fighter it's a pretty good game, but don't expect a lot of Star Wars immersion.

The Good
I'll just start this one off with my base opinion on the issue of whether this game is a sequel to Jedi Outcast or not. Yes it is. No matter how similar the technology is, or how many of the sound effects are reused, or how many textures there are that have carried over, Jedi Academy still fits the sequel brand perfectly. The lightsaber fighting system has been reworked to fit a ton of new moves, two new lightsaber styles, reworkings of force powers central to the gameplay, a semi-nonlinear storyline taking place in pretty much nothing but showcase levels, new multiplayer modes, new enemy characters and in a nod to the original Jedi Knight; character development (albeit extremely simpleminded character development). To top it off, J.A's plot is a direct continuation of J.O's storyline. In the end however, what does it matter? Jedi Academy is exactly what i expected from a sequel. It's more, it's bigger, it is (in true Hollywood fashion) more action packed, and I loved every second of it

Jedi Academy is hampered by two issues that pretty much every review i've read has brought up. It recycles a lot of content from the previous Jedi Knight game, and the character development gimmick the game is sold by is tentative to say the least, although my girlfriend kicked off on simply being allowed a choice of gender. I've seen reviews base almost every other opinion of the game on criticism derivative of these two comparatively major points. However, to me, neither of these two problems really made a difference when the core gameplay is as good as it is. It is common knowledge that Jedi Outcast had a nasty habit of turning people off during the first few levels; The Star Wars setting simply wasn't enough to carry a generic first person shooter. Although i thought the beginning was quite good for its genre, there's no denying that, upon acquisition of the light saber, the gameplay simply shifted into a league of its own. The light saber combat of Jedi Outcast was immensely satisfying, if a tad random, and near the end of the game you ended up being basically immensely powerful, taking on armies at a time. Academy picks up the thread where Outcast left it, and this time you begin the game with your lightsaber in hand. In fact, while Outcast brought you up to consider the Lightsaber a supplement to your regular artillery, Academy never ever downplays the significance it has on the gameplay. The guns, which were pretty generic to begin with, take a far more suitable part. In Outcast, after you got the lightsaber, you didn't really need any of your other weapons. Academy lets you choose, and there are parts where the lightsaber simply feels unwieldy, particularly against certain heavily armored foes in the second half of the game. Raven made a worthy attempt of getting rid of the Lightsaberiitis of Outcast and put the lightsaber and guns side by side. Well done.

The storyline is shallow and simple, but since the game is like one of those Simpson's episodes where they have flashbacks to other episodes constantly throughout, thus not ever having real continuity, that isn't really a problem. Basically, enemies from Jedi Outcast are at it again, and while Luke Skywalker and Kyle Katarn are doing all kinds of flipping out to find out what's going on, you the player are doing a bunch of missions as part of your Jedi education, occasionally playing a part in Luke and Kyle's schemes, and finally becoming the hero that saves the day. Considering how tired the Star Wars universe is story-wise, I was grateful that the move be made to stop being so god damn pretentious and simply provide the larger-than-life entertainment. I didn't watch Episode 1 and 2 for the wonderful art of George Lucas' storytelling. I wanted to see adventure! We haven't had a good and proper adventure movie since the last Indiana Jones film, and the void is becoming more and more apparent. Jedi Academy treats the source material with dignity and recreates what might be some of the coolest set piece battles in a Star Wars game ever, and that's almost all I want from a Star Wars game.

The lightsaber combat of Jedi Academy, though superficially similar to that of Outcast, carries a lot more weight this time around. You still strafe around enemies and hammer the trigger until everything quiets down, but in saber vs saber combat, timing and force powers play a much stronger part than it used to. Specifically, powers previously useless almost always have a significant impact on a fight between light/dark side Jedi. There is a rock/paper/scissors aspect to it that, while existent in Outcast, simply plays a bigger part. In Outcast, force push would cancel a force grip, force absorb would invalidate force lightning etc. In Academy, there's the issue of force push in light saber lock battles, which are occurrances where two opposing Jedi lock sabers during battle. The ensuing struggle is played out by hammering the trigger as fast as possible until one overtakes the other, who is momentarily open for attack. In Academy, a sufficiently powerful force push can end the battle easily. In addition, battles used to end with the loser going prone. In Academy, going prone can be avoided by quick reflexes; hitting back or forward before hitting the ground will cause you to flip out of danger or attempt retaliation with a kick. If you do go prone, you can now roll sideways out of danger, Tekken-style, should your opponent try one of the new finishing moves; A rather violent stab to the chest of a prone opponent. This is just an example of how the combat system has been elaborated upon. There is far more room for improvisation, and some fights can play out downright impressive, with combatants hopping from wall to wall, shielding themselves from concentrated attack by releasing flurries of saber blows, shooting across the room with the new force leap move before bouncing off to other walls, all while still dueling. Upon completing Jedi Outcast, I wrote Raven a quick email saying how impressed i was with their impersonation of the Hong Kong flying sword movie. I got a reply stating that chinese cinema was a real influence for them. If it wasn't apparent then, it sure is now. Jedi Academy is one of the finest video game executions of the flying sword film i have ever seen. Enter the Matrix eat your heart out.

Saber combat, comedy and acrobatics aside, the basic gameplay hasn't changed much. The game is playable from both a third person and first person perspective, and uses the good ol' wsad/mouse control setup, which works admirably. You still get missions that require you to navigate a complex area filled with enemies, and they basically all end with you hitting a button, defeating an opponent or vacating an area. Where Academy gets it all right though is the pacing. Jedi Academy is played across three tiers of missions, linked by a set of storyline missions. You are given the choice of 6 missions at a time for you to complete in any order you choose. For every mission you complete you get a new force point to spend buying force powers. This basically means that if you encounter a mission you have problems with, you can always play others, then return later with new force powers. I'm very impressed with how Raven executed this. It's basically the Megaman approach to character development, but the game would have been thoroughly dull hadn't it been for the incredible imagination that has gone into each individual mission. They are rarely long, rambling affairs like certain missions of Outcast, they have no connection whatsoever other than the types of enemy you fight, but they all look fantastic and play beautifully. In essence, Jedi Academy is like one of those UFC greatest hits tapes. A bunch of really great and spectacular fights in equally great and spectacular settings. My favorites include a brilliant tribute to that stupidly great horror comedy Tremors; The player crash lands on a desert planet crawling with sound and vibration sensitive sand worms, and must guide his character across a plain strewn with wreckage, hopping from rock to rock to avoid the worms. At one point i thought the reference to Tremors was so clear i wanted to try the Tremors' heroes' approach to the worm problem; throwing grenades at the sand and trick the worms into eating them, and what do you know, it worked. A really really good level. Another superb level is a 1 on 1 fight with none other than Boba Fett in the ruins of a dead city. Whoever did his AI, you have my respect. He really acts like the hunter he is supposed to be. Graphical centerpieces include the level where you are chased across a factory by an utterly enormous mutated rancor (you know, those drooling things Jabba feeds his slaves to for no reason). Trying to fight dozens of Jedi while being chased by a two story tall monster on steroids, trying to figure out a way of killing it is some of the coolest stuff i've done in a game. Most of all though, what impresses me is the pacing. Every level puts you right in the thick of it. There are no dubious gameplay elements that don't fit in or halt the flow. It's just straight ahead, full steam, and it's all great fun.

Soundwise you pretty much know what to expect, though it is brilliantly executed as always. There's the dynamic John Williams score (which gives me the willies now. God damnit get some new music guys), the British officers and the American troopers, bleeps and boings and humming sabres, and lots and lots of explosions. If you've played a star wars game, you know what to expect, because in the end they all sound exactly the same. The voice work needs a little brushing up however. I ended up playing a female character simply because the female voice actor did a job that was easier on the ears. The male voice actor for the player character delivers his lines with the dynamic flair of a vacuum cleaner, which is odd considering the high quality of pretty much all the other voices.

Graphically, Jedi Academy is basically gorgeous. It's a Quake 3 Arena engine game, and you can tell, but Raven are just so damn good at putting it to use. Those level designers deserve a raise. One of the levels take place on a runaway tram, with rain in your face and buildings flashing by in the fog in a blur while you hop from car to car. The sense of speed is tangible. Another level taking place on Coruscant gets something right that Outcast somehow didn't; it got my fear of heights going. Jedi Knight was well known for its huge environments, and Academy is no slacker in the huge environments department. There are few new graphical tricks however. There are some neat new warp effects when using force push or pull, but aside from that there is little to wow you. However, character models look superb, and in what may be a Raven first ever, they actually got mouth animations right. The Ghoul rendering system has produced something that actually doesn't look like ghouls! Remarkable! In addition, the female twi'lek player model is actually attractive, something i never thought i'd see in a Raven game. An attractive female that is. Character animations are mostly excellent, although the retarded walk cycle Raven has been using since Outcast and Soldier of fortune 2 is still in place. God damnit, get rid of that! Normal people aren't perpetually constipated!

The Bad
There are some gripes I have, but their single player impact is quite minor. First and foremost; Force grip is way too powerful. It didn't take me long to fully upgrade my force grip, having loved it in Jedi Outcast. The big problem is that most of the fights in Jedi Academy take place on high mountains or bridges above lava or something of the sort. Any Jedi will resist your force grip with a quick force push, which is all good, but in the split second you have until they do, a quick flick of the wrist will toss any enemy helplessly to their death. This includes boss battles. One central boss battle was over literally within the first second simply by tossing the fool into a hole. It's really quite sad how simple some really challenging fights can be, especially when the stage is set dramatically. Example. You open the door. There's a giant radar dish in front of you on a platform hovering miles above a sea of molten lava. An enemy Jedi turns to face you, saying "Do you fear me?". He draws his double edged light saber and draws a half circle in front of him, gesturing me forwards. I toss him into the lava without even activating my sabre. Whee! There are parts where the drama vs the anticlimax of using force grip simply cracked me up. The atmosphere goes from tangibly thick to slapstick comedy in an instant. In fact, in the aforementioned boss battle, i simply reloaded my save game to fight the boss properly. It just felt too cheap.

The second gripe is one i had in Jedi Outcast as well, and an even bigger source of comedy. Level 3 force pull and level 3 force jump is probably the funniest way ever to kill off armies of enemies at the time. On its own, force pull is nasty enough in that it disarms enemies, but jumping high up in the air and force pulling enemies up toward you will send them all comically flying miles into the air, dying when they land. It's truly funny the distances you can send some people. Some set piece battles in Outcast were made ridiculously easy by this technique as it works equally well on Jedi.

These two techniques can make the game both ridiculously easy and involuntarily comedic. I'm not sure how force grip has been tweaked for multiplayer yet, but i hope dearly that the throwing bit has been toned down. It was annoying enough to be tossed off bridges in Outcast deathmatches, but i can see some major griefing done by players overusing grip if it plays out in any way similar to the single player game.

The Bottom Line
Overall, i'm very surprised. It's easy to be cynical in these days of cheap crap being pushed on the market for every discernible franchise, and particularly during the mad dash Lucasarts has done with Star Wars games. There was a time when the word Lucasarts was synonymous with quality, but that is so long ago i can't even remember. I honestly thought Jedi Academy was going to be an utter cash-in, and i was more than prepared for disappointment. However Raven have proved me wrong in every possible way. Jedi Academy is enjoyable throughout, and is a superb example of how to execute a Star wars game. Now how about a proper kung fu flying sword game you bastards =) You obviously know how to do it

The Good
This game takes all the fun parts from Jedi Knight II and expands on them. For example, in JK2 the lightsaber combat was a strong feature but you didn't receive your lightsaber until halfway through the game. This made replaying the game tedious. However, in Jedi Academy you have your lightsaber from the first level. In Jedi Academy there are more force abilities to learn but you will never have enough points to become a master at all so you can customize your character by becoming a specialist at some or have a little of everything. The lightsaber combat has been enhanced with the addition of two more saber styles: dual sabers and saber staff.

The Bad
Level design is very linear, but not lacking in variety. Graphics have not been enhanced and still use the Quake III engine which looks dated. Audio is what we've come to expect from Star Wars. The classic soundtrack still repeats. The voice work is good for the cut scenes but enemy taunts a repetitive and sometimes don't make much sense - especially if you've just effortlessly slaughtered their friends and they're still telling you "You are weak". Enemy AI is very lacking, even on more difficult levels a force grip and push over a ledge is good enough to dispatch most of your enemies.

The Bottom Line
Fans of the Star Wars and the Jedi Knight series will be pleased with this unambitious release. Those who were hoping for something more than a rehash will be disappointed.

The Good
It’s been ten years since the defeat of the Empire above Endor’s sanctuary moon. While the New Republic continues to battle the Imperial Remnant, Luke Skywalker’s newly trained Jedi are fulfilling their historical role—that of guardian and peacekeeper. This may not be a dark time for the Republic, but it is a tenuous time for the Jedi, especially with the Cult of Ragnos threatening to resurrect the ancient Sith lord.

The Cult reveals itself during the opening cutscene, firing on a transport carrying would-be students. This is revealed to be a diversionary tactic, with the Cult’s real motive involving hacking into the Academy’s computers. If the Cult can locate areas strong with the Force then they can siphon the Force energy for their Master. At this point in the Dark Forces franchise, you’d think that only Kyle Katarn could thwart their dastardly deeds. You’d be wrong.

After the events of Jedi Outcast, Katarn is now a Jedi Master training students (of which Jaden, your character, is one). In an interesting contrast to the RPG Knights of the Old Republic, Jedi Academy begins with you picking Jaden’s gender and race (KotOR offered human-only role playing). You then customize Jaden’s outfit and select a lightsaber color and hilt. As you progress through the game you also add new Force Powers, so in many ways Jedi Academy blurs the line between shooter and RPG.

While the entire game covers the Cult of Ragnos threat, the structure of Jedi Academy differs from previous entries. After the initial events and training/tutorial levels, you are presented with five missions around the galaxy. You can play the missions in any order and only have to complete four of them to advance to the next tier. The structure of the game works out to be five mini-missions followed by one larger story-related mission, repeated three times.

As you move up in tiers, your core Force powers (Jump, Speed, Push, etc) advance to the next level (up to level three- Jedi Knight). After each mission, you can add a new Force power or strengthen a preexisting one. These are the other Force powers (Light or Dark Side) like Heal, Grip, Mind Trick, etc. In an interesting switch, Force powers no longer seem to be viewed as good or evil, rather it’s how you use them.

Unlike Jedi Outcast, you start off with a lightsaber (something Jaden was able to build on his own before the Academy). Lightsaber combat is even more dynamic this time around with many more new moves and combinations. I can’t really say I figured out how to use the new moves, but with frantic button mashing I executed many of them. Towards the end of the game, you have the option of keeping with your single saber or picking dual sabers or a double-ended saber. You can also bring along the clumsy, random blaster and other weaponry if you want to try Jedi Academy as a FPS. These weapons are less vital this time around, especially against Dark Jedi who can deflect blaster bolts and Force Push missiles back in your direction.

So how is the game? The mini-missions are a lot of fun. There are plenty of different landscapes, mission types, villains, etc. You can investigate an attack on a Jawa Sandcrawler, become the hunted in a The Most Dangerous Game level, explore the acid rain blasted ruins of Vader’s Bast Castle, plant targets on an orbital platform for a Rogue Squadron assault, and more. Within the missions you can ride Tauntauns on Hoth, race along on swoop bikes, turn a capital ship’s turrets against a wave of TIE Fighters, and kill many many Stormtroopers and Dark Jedi.

The Bad
So what’s wrong with this game?

First off, this is the first Dark Forces game which isn’t a great improvement over its predecessor. In-game graphics are great and the rendered cutscenes look great, but the cutscenes using the game’s engine are poor. Lip-synching is way off and character animation is clumsy. Pathfinding seems to be missing in missions where characters fight along side you and they are also less effective this time around and more prone to falling down chasms, not reacting to combat situations, and (in one strange situation) attacking each other. Finally, spawning is very visible in this game—it’s very disconcerting to see enemies beam in right in front of you.

Then, while the mini-missions are varied, there is no depth to them so you have a nonlinear game comprised of very linear missions. One mission was so strictly scripted that I had to restart the mission when I took the wrong path. Other missions end abruptly once the goals have been met, so in some cases it may be possible to escape combat and just run from objective to objective.

Finally, the story is serviceable but lacks the punch of Dark Forces, the scope of Jedi Knight, or the richness of Jedi Outcast. Jedi Academy does feature a Light and Dark Side path, near the very end of the game. Unlike Jedi Knight, which had a primitive, but workable, alignment system, Jedi Academy stops the game at a crucial moment and tells the player: “Do this to be on the Light Side or do this to be on the Dark Side.” The end result is something that feels like a compilation of mod missions, feebly tied together.

The Bottom Line
Where does this leave us?

Jedi Academy is still a great game, but it suffers in comparison to Jedi Outcast. I would recommend this game for its fun, short missions that mix familiar worlds and characters with new planets and enemies. I think it misses the mark set previously, but it was such a high mark.

The Good
It's the StarWars universe with all its little details, sounds and characters, and every once in a while it feels good to ignite that lightsaber and bring justice to the galaxy. The graphics are great, especially regarding the rusty Quake-3-engine. The sound effects and score are on a high level. The level design is interesting, moody and diverse. The controls are easy to learn and the light saber duels are fast and furious. Its way better than JK:Outcast because it doesn't have the awful jump sequences and boring "puzzles".

The Bad
The story can be a bit lame and hacked together sometimes, its more a detective novel than a truly enthousiastic StarWars action adventure. As in JK:Outcast, there is not a lot of "life" in the levels, so they can look a bit artificial at times. The choice between light and dark side isn't really given.

The Bottom Line
Years after the demise of the Empire, there are still planets and systems where the dark side of the force is strong, and where huge armies of the emperors troops hide. Kyle Katarn, the Jedi Knight, has become a Master at the Jedi Academy that Luke Skywalker has found on Yavin. You are a young, promising Jedi padawan who just starts his study at the academy, when a new menace arises and threatens the still fragile structure of the New Republic.The remnants of the Empire ally with the remaining Sith to form a deadly alliance that could bring the young republic down...can the few courageous Jedi around Master Skywalker stand against this dark army...?

Jedi Academy is the best StarWars first person game hands down. The graphics are great and the universe is true to the movies. Like in the first Jedi Knight game, You have a limited control on how to augment Your "forces".Some a given and can not be altered, some can be increased every once in a while, thus making the replay value better than in JK:Outcast. The forces are spectacular as ever, and the way You can combine the saber and the force powers are fascinating and fun. Its always cool when You are beeing attacked by the sith apprentices, because in some levels, You can use the "Force Push" to throw them over a cliff, and when they come jumping at You, You can stop them in mid-air and push them back so they fall into the endless pit, that way You can avoid some of the saber duels. Additionally, for those who are skilled, there are quite some interesting acrobatic tricks like running on walls, flic-flacs, salto backwards, salto forwards, its very rewarding and the controls are not too hard to master. The game has its dull moments, and weak AI, but when You are starting to do a salto backwards, hit the enemy in mid-air, add a combo that kills three in a row and end this with a force push, You really feel like a Jedi. Kudos to Raven, in this version they really put the Jedi acrobatics as seen in Episode 1 and 2 to shine, and the game will be fun even when You are replaying fights, because You can always try some new combinations. Sure, story-wise and from character development its not KOTOR, but it doesn't want to be that, its a good, fun, easy to access StarWars-action-game with bags full of atmosphere and great action scenes.

The Good
Graphics-despite the apparent age of the Quake3 engine, they managed to pull it off again with JA. A new game engine would have smoothed all the rough edges out and improved the look of the game.

The game is not very difficult. There are no real puzzles to solve, just use your force powers and good sense and you'll beat most of the levels in a flash. It was very satisfying to see various Star Wars worlds like Tatooine (and Chewbacca) and Hoth with emphasis on action and adventure instead of boring puzzles and infinite mazes or labyrinths. I liked the action emphasis of the game because levels which are too difficult because of strange puzzles are so discouraging and detract from gameplay. Lighting for the levels was really good so I could always see the immense environments I was playing in. The single player was too short but it was very gratifying to breeze through this action-adventure that is full of jedi action from start to finish. Killing stormtroopers (stormies) has never been so much fun.

Riding those swoop bikes made me feel like I was part of the Star Wars adventure and that one level with the bike featured the best use of Star Wars music I have ever seen in a computer game. The tauntaun was also a lot of fun as I'd just ram into those stormies.

The game really has an emphasis on lightsaber battles whether you're playing single or multi-player. Those dual and saber staff weapons are truly a marvel as you can just slice through multiple enemies at once.

Creating my own character and seeing him through all this action made it more of a personal experience but with bad single player it dosen't measure up to JK or TIE Fighter.

The Bad
Single player mode was badly done in overall. You don't get to fight alongside Luke or play as Kyle, which would have been so fitting. Level design in the last few levels is atrocious, the momentum of the earlier levels is completely ruined by the last confusing levels. The music for the last levels is even more disappointing as they add no dimension to the last levels (or climax as some would refer to them as) unlike the levels in Jedi Knight or TIE Fighter. The last duel features music that really dosen't fit with the level.

The bad guys are so repetitive in this game. Dark jedi are used to such an extent that they cease to be a threat. Every corner you pass it feels like you'll fight yet another new reborn. The reborn say silly things like "you are weak" even when you slaughter tons of them. It's funny to see them say things like "now I, am the master" when you die because its really short-lived. They get easier to kill as you progress and even with force powers are no match for the power of the light side. The female dark jedi say really stupid things like "are you afraid?" and spoil the mood of the levels. Tavion is a pathetic boss and dosen't pose a threat in the final duel.

When you play as a dark jedi it's discouraging because unlike JK you don't get any dark force powers. You go to the dark side so late in the game that it makes almost no difference until the final duel. You're stuck with your light side force powers and forced to fight with that great guy Kyle Katarn. Unlike Tavion he's impossible to kill as he just slices right through your defenses as if he's more powerful than Darth Vader.

You don't get to go to all the places like Dagobah and there are so few levels with Kyle Katarn that you're all alone in your distant corner of the galaxy away from all the real action, so it seems.

The level with the mutant Rancor is so out of place that it has really no positive bearing on the level progress.

The Bottom Line
I'd buy Battlefront instead of this unless you really want to play as a jedi. The jedi combat is the prime element of the game and no other element of Star Wars is featured.

Buy at your own risk.

The Good
Since it uses the same engine as Jedi Knight 2, you know what to expect from this game graphics-wise. This is a good or bad thing, I suppose. Certainly the graphics are dated, but hell, they RUN on my computer, so that's a good thing in my book.

New lightsabers! If there's one thing to sell this game, it's the new lightsaber tricks, which are certainly cool. Two lightsabers, a saberstaff, new special moves, combined with force powers and slow-motion "finishing moves" -- it makes for some memorable battles, and more than once I quick-loaded back just to replay a fight, even if I beat it flawlessly the first time.

The hoverbike levels were actually pretty awesome.

The Bad
Unfortunately, "two new lightsabers" is about all this game has going for it. Everything else is abysmal. Don't even mention the plot in this game, because it's about the worst I've seen in any computer game in recent memory.

The first disappointment I found was that, unlike every previous Dark Forces game, you're not playing Kyle Katarn. Instead, you're some student in a Jedi Acadamy who quickly (VERY quickly) rises to the title of Jedi through fight after fight after fight. The fights are cool, don't get me wrong...but it doesn't make any sense toward the plot.

You're given five missions, and then a plot mission. Rinse. Repeat. And with every of those five missions, your task involves something like, "Go talk to this guy," only, in every case, you'll not only NOT "talk to this guy", but you'll find that you were -- gasp -- ambushed by a hundred lightsaber-wielding goons.

At the end you get a choice between choosing the light path or the dark path, but the outcome is pretty much the same. At least, it was for me. If you choose the light path, you fight alongside other studen jedis -- unless the morons get in the way of your lightsaber and you accidentally cut one up, in which they all turn against you. And heck, that's even funner. That's essentially the dark path, as well. Same level, same thing, only you fight other jedis as well as bad guys.

The cutscenes are awful. Animation is awkward and just plain bad. And the voice acting certainly doesn't make up for it. Especially annoying is the voice of a fellow student who turns on you, which is also pretty obvious from the first time you meet him.

Your character has absolutely no depth to him at all. You know nothing of his past, you know not why he's becoming a jedi, you don't know anything. And you don't need to, I guess, because your task is just to go in and kill everything and beat the game. Don't expect anything from this game other than an arcade hack 'n slash, because that's all it amounts to.

Also what I found disappointing was that you start with a lightsaber. I loved how in Jedi Knight 2, the first half of the game you are without it. It was like playing two games -- a Star Wars first-person shooter, and then a lightsaber-swingin' third-person hack 'n slash. Unlike many people, I didn't mind the first half at all. In fact, I may have enjoyed it more than the second. But Jedi knight 2 was an awesome game. Jedi Acadamy is NOT.

The Bottom Line
It's Jedi knight 2 without the cream in the middle. It's shiny on the outside but completely hollow within. The new lightsaber stuff almost makes up for it, as long as you're not expecting anything more than what it delivers.

The Good
The lightsaber is cool. A couple new force powers and improved ways of using old ones. Using the 3 different kind of sabers and the 5 or so colors is cool. You go to a bunch of different planets. The music and voices is ok. You can choose your force powers. You can choose the missions to some extent.

The Bad
First, choosing "Light or "Dark" force powers has ABSOLUTELY no bearing on the game. Get all "dark" powers and you can stay on the light side. Max-out on "light" and you can turn to the dark side. The force powers are very unbalanced. Grip lets you choke guys like Darth Vader and throw them around. This allows you to barely use your lightsaber and just throw stormtroopers and dark jedi down cliffs or into lava. The game can be extremely easy. Stormtroopers are sit there firing lamely at you while you block their shots. Dark Jedi will, if you fight them, then just get a short distance away, turn off their lightsaber (!?) and sit there, allowing you to shoot at them and\or recharge your force and health. The toughest part of a game is finding where to go and not falling off a cliff. The levels are linear and boring. No civilians or anyone else. For no apparent reason, thugs or other non-empire guys will attack you. Also, I don't think street (or roof?) thugs on Coruscant should have powerful weapons like the disruptor rifle and thermal detonators while the supposed powerful storm troopers just have blasters and the occasional repeater and "metal gun". The story is ridiculous. Something about resurrecting a ancient sith lord using force energy stored in a scepter "sucked-up" from places with lots of force. Since the people trying to bring the sith lord back to life are evil, why not use the power on themselves. After all, even Darth Vader made an offer to Luke to help him overthrow the Emperor in Empire Strikes Back. In the beginning of the game, you get to "customize" your character, choosing species, looks, etc. However, this weirdly has no effect what so-ever. No change in abilities or anything else. Same voices even!!! All the missions are described as meet with this and talk with this, etc. But that never happens. You are always ambushed, or the guy you were supposed to talk to gets killed and almost every level is fundamentally the same. The game also offers almost nothing about your character's past or anything. You just slash your way through a seemingly endless supply of the same 7 or so different types of enemies. The "basic" force powers, speed, push, pull, and sense, unlike what you here in the training mission, are rarely used for anything. You don't really need to push any switches etc. this brings up the worst problem, the lack of depth. You won't go through a city, getting stuff to trade with other people or interact with anyone in a non-linear basis. The galaxy is nearly lifeless. it seems that the entire galaxy has either your allies, or mercenaries, dark jedi, stormtroopers etc. out to kill you. Boba Fett is in one of the missions. Normally, this would be a good thing, but they totally make him more of a nuisance then anything else. Mostly, he will just fire bursts of laser fire as you deflect them back, hitting him with his own fire. Occasionally, he will use his flamethrower or missile launcher, but not enough to show him to be a deadly assassin. Finally, absolutely no puzzles!!! If your not hacking and slashing through enemies, wandering from room to room, you're putting your cross hair over everything to see if it can be affected by the force.

The Bottom Line
If you are a die hard Star Wars fan, wait a couple of years for the price to get down to ten bucks. if not, avoid it, as it is a complete waste of money. (I spent 50 bucks on it and learned the hard way)

The Good
First off, the graphics are very good. You can even see the stubble on Kyle's face. Secondly, I love the way that people can make their own skins and maps easily. The online multiplayer is very good, but it's better with a mod such as JA+ and Xmod. I love the dual saber option especially. Ah, good old backslash...

The Bad
The single player is the most boring thing I've ever played. There are no addictive weapons, the force is weak, and pretty much the whole premise sucks. Secondly, on multiplayer, it's brought out the worst in people. The option to "lame kill" has attracted more than a few (killing while someone is away from keyboard or chatting). And "clans" have completely made this game into a dictatorship; the clan administrators can change any option they want for the server, such as which type of saber style does more damage. They are forgetting it is supposed to be a fun game where people can respectfully play together and admit defeat without calling their prey "n00bs."

The Bottom Line
If you buy this game, think twice before entering a clan. 8/10

The Good
There are a few good things about this game. The lightsaber fights are the best part, but do not really take skill because you can just swing your blade randomly and kill the enemy jedi. The weapons are almost the same as outcasts, save you get 2 or 3 new ones. As a first-person shooter, it doesn't exel, but is alright.

The Bad
The horrible plot line, bad lip synching, bad movies, and useless force powers will make this game feel like a bad interlude, than a good follow up to outcast. The levels on this game feel more like mini levels as you could easily beat them in 5 minutes. Also, you'll have to level a completely useless force power just to get by one stupid level. It is just annoying.

The Bottom Line
This game is simply pathetic when compared to Knights of the Old Republic, and you'll beat it the first day, but it isn't bad for ten bucks.